I agree there seems to be a problem, but my concern is if this is truly effecting EVERYONE, like the internet states. Why are so many people keeping their phones?
I can only speak for myself but - I would prefer to have an IP4, despite the reception issue, than a different phone. I've been Apple for 15 years. I'm on my 10th desktop, My 4th laptop, My 4th iPod and the IP4 is my second iPhone.
changing to another phone would involve lots of problems like:
learning how to use it
Syncing it with my existing Mac apps and other Apple kit
Making my MobileMe redundant
writing off my $200+ investment in iPhone Apps
maybe having to re-encode all my AAC files
The IP4 reception issue is a serious problem. But for me at least, taking it back and getting a different phone would be an even bigger problem as I've bought into everything Apple in a big way.
My not returning the phone should not be interpreted as an acceptance of the reception issue or cast doubt on the seriousness of the issue in any way. I honestly do believe that Apple will come up with a way to fix (or at least improve) it and will make good in the end. Hopefully we'll hear about how they are going to do that tomorrow.
A free bumper won't cut it. My money is on a recall/swap out.