Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Makes me want to leave EU 🇪🇺.
Why do politicians make these crazy decisions without asking the citizens?
This is completely Apple’s decision lol. Google, Samsung etc. are doing similar stuff in the EU and being much less transparent about it. The DMA has nothing to do with Apple Intelligence. At this point it’s literally just Tim Cook trying to kill whatever’s left of the company before he leaves by making the offerings less and less attractive to the rest of the world outside of the US again and again.
 
How is Apple supposed to implement iPhone mirroring without letting any other company have access to core APIs that would allow this sort of interaction? That would violate the DMA

How is Apple supposed to implement Apple Intelligence without giving third party AI programs the same core OS access that Apple Intelligence will have? (Chat GPT does not have that same access, it will be more akin to a wrapper that Siri will pass requests to)

This was something people were screaming out when the DMA was being debated. And now it's happening
If this is the reason then it’s actually a good thing, advancing the goal of leveling competition. Either Apple devices will become less attractive because they’re missing features the competition has, or if they open it up third-party app developers will be able to compete more fairly with Apple’s first-party apps.
 
Makes me want to leave EU 🇪🇺.
Why do politicians make these crazy decisions without asking the citizens?
You had your vote less than two weeks ago. Or did you forget?

Also, this is completely on Apple. They’re just being childish. First claim how amazing and private their AI is, and then not be able to release it in the EU due to privacy concerns? That’s a joke.
 
This is Apple, perhaps in a subtle way attempting to get their customers to turn on the regulators in the EU. Ha ha. Or maybe they don’t want to be forced to create android mirroring on the Mac desktop.
In the EU customers will turn to Android… Trust me, we really are not attached to the iPhone as people in the US are. People here think iMessage is like SMS so they think it costs money. We text, call, etc. on WhatsApp and FB Messenger.
 
Last edited:
If this is the reason then it’s actually a good thing, advancing the goal of leveling competition. Either Apple devices will become less attractive because they’re missing features the competition has, or if they open it up third-party app developers will be able to compete more fairly with Apple’s first-party apps.
Less capable devices being a good thing is an argument only people blinded by irrational hatred could make unironically
 
Maybe. I haven't delved into it, but don't understand how a screen sharing feature needs to be regulated by the EU.
It is the not the feature, it is access to the relevant API, so someone could also build a screen sharing app. That is called competition.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JSDK
You had your vote less than two weeks ago. Or did you forget?

Also, this is completely on Apple. They’re just being childish. First claim how amazing and private their AI is, and then not be able to release it in the EU due to privacy concerns? That’s a joke.
Childish? Argue better. Did they create the Digital Markets Act? No. Plain and simple.
 
it's ok though, I can now side load that one shady looking app that I've always wanted that's going to steal all of my info

hurray!!
No sideloading required for that. Apple makes it easy for you by making shady apps available in your favorite Appstore all the time. If you wanted better curated apps, you might have to go to the alternate appstores. They only have a few and hence can check them easily. Appstore, OTOH, has nearly 2 million apps and no way to check them all. Below are the search results limited for one year. Otherwise, there would be hundreds.



 
no it doesn't as these features would first have to be classified as gatekeeping under dma by the eu or a regulator, and that can only be done once or if it's available. so apple would actually need to make it available here first, then eu would start the process of review and in my opinion would most likely classify these as not being gatekeeping.
What a mess of a process...

Besides, since so many on here who support the EU are saying that Apple must comply with the "spirit of the law" then who KNOWS what the EU will do or say. There is no certainty about what the DMA does or does not require. According to many arguments I've read on here, the spirit of the law is expansive.
 
this is complete and utter bantha poodoo!

nothing in our dma says apple can't bring it to our markets in the way they've announced it at wwdc in fact I would say and hazzard a guess with them offering an external ai processor from the start, in this case OpenAI's ChatGPT, it is already in complete compliance with the spirit of the DMA. Add to that the fact they spent a long time going on about their private cloud compute and then I assume it's also in compliance of GDPR and even goes beyond what GDPR stipulates.

So, this is just Apple being spiteful for their other troubles with eu lawmakers, the spotify case and the epic thing....
There is a context aware side of the AI that requires data from several apps to be combined. That may be an issue in the EU. Not sure how Google and Samsung are doing though.
 
Some EU guys paid too much for their 14PM, are angry so no-one should get AI? 😁
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.