Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Maybe Tesla has an unofficial agreement with Chinese companies that Tesla will buy their tech in exchange for them staying out of the US market.
Ah it must be the Chinese doing shady “unofficial” agreements.

Definitely not because their EV tech is better and cheaper so Tesla buys from them.
Definitely not because US bans Chinese companies after they gain market share in the US for “national security” reasons.

Which Chinese CEO in the right mind would even bother to spend the resources and money to try and enter the US market?
 
600 people is a lot. And a 2000 person team. All for it to be scrapped?

With a team that large you’d think they would have really been able to create something amazing.
I believe they were, but the market suddenly shifted to Economy EVs because of China so what they were planning was becoming unsupportable. Do keep in mind that the iPad was originally being worked on but the technology for the concept was years away, so they took what they had and spent 5 years working on the iphone. 3 years and 3 versions after its release the original project was released.

It is possible the car will return in some form when the pricing and technology makes sense.
 
I think it is completely unacceptable that they couldn't find something for these people.
I find it completely unnacceptable that you are spouting off with such an uninformed and illogical take.

First: The team had over 2,000 members, 2/3 of them have already found other jobs in Apple and I imagine some of the remaining 600 still might.

Second: If you’re an automotive engineer and Apple cancels its automotive project where are they supposed to place you? You can’t just randomly add someone with a particular skill set to a project that’s completely outside their area of expertise. That’s like taking a musician and telling them to go paint a portrait. Different skill sets.

Three: Apple spent a decade on this. It didn’t work out. That happens. Throwing more money and people at it just to appease someone who doesn’t have a clue what they are talking about would be a terrible decision.

It’s clear why Tim Cook is in charge of Apple and you are not.
 
Why can't the Apple Car employees fix Siri? It's a disaster
Why can’t a cello player perform open heart surgery?

Why can’t an airline pilot practice law?

Why can’t a botanist fix your car engine?

Building a car and building an AI assistant aren’t even remotely similar. You can’t just randomly throw people from one project onto another and expect good results.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tagbert
It just gets worse for Apple. MR not long ago reported about Apple cancelling the car project after spending 10yrs and billions of $$$ and nothing tangible to show for it. Now we see from the article that there was approximately 2000 employee's working on the car project. So to cap it off, 2000 employee's, 10 years and billions of $$$ and nothing tangible to show for it. That is a massive massive failure by Tim Cook. I wonder how many of the employee's that were poached/head hunted from other car manufacturers are now regretting their decision to accept the move to Apple.
 
Ah it must be the Chinese doing shady “unofficial” agreements.

Definitely not because their EV tech is better and cheaper so Tesla buys from them.
Definitely not because US bans Chinese companies after they gain market share in the US for “national security” reasons.

Which Chinese CEO in the right mind would even bother to spend the resources and money to try and enter the US market?
True. The U.S. is only a modest market compared to the Red Dragon.
 
Apple fires 600 engineers after cancelling car project. Apple hires 600 engineers after starting home robotics project.
 
Why can’t a cello player perform open heart surgery?

Why can’t an airline pilot practice law?

Why can’t a botanist fix your car engine?

Building a car and building an AI assistant aren’t even remotely similar. You can’t just randomly throw people from one project onto another and expect good results.

This is hilarious because:

1. I know a surgeon who is also a violinist.
2. I know a botanist who is eternally fixing his car.
3. I know a pilot. He has nothing to do with law though.

On my commercial team, I have a mechanical engineer, one former doctor, one hairdresser, myself an EE and mathematician and one guy who is the best of all of us: a former McDonalds manager with no qualifications at all.

YMMV. It depends not on just what you are qualified to do but what you can do and that is somewhat fluid over the decades.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jlnr and diggy33
Apple are not doing good enough IMO, weekly outages across its services, and now laying off several hundred staff after failed projects. They need to try much harder and stick to what they know.
Yes, but at the same time they have to radically innovate, because all their products are in a mature market. What can you really do with another slightly updated iPhone or Macbook?
 
Apple probably decided they couldn't compete with Chinese EV makers (BYD et al.). They've really come into their own recently and, as a byproduct, showed that Tesla's high margin approach (which is probably what got them interested in the first place) probably isn't sustainable for a car manufacturer. Apple have no interest in low margin products.
 
Never really understood the Apple Car thing. What was it going to be, a super expensive version of something expensive that already exist in a totally over crowded marketplace.
 
  • Like
Reactions: freedomlinux
Apple management screws up car strategy so they fire a bunch of great engineers instead of putting them on other projects? Dumb companies do things like this.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Tagbert
The Apple car would have been an amazing EV. They binned it off because the future of EVs now seems radically different. So much has changed.
 
This is normal in the course of business. Hopefully these employees have been highly paid and coming out with a good severance package. On the whole, they should be able to easily find new employment.

For Apple, nothing ventured nothing gained. This shows that they are still daring enough to try big new things. Onward and upward.
 
Apple management screws up car strategy so they fire a bunch of great engineers instead of putting them on other projects? Dumb companies do things like this.
It’s an opinion… Even though I doubt you know any of the (so called) great engineers or Apple Management. What's your opinion based on?
 
It's always the lower level employees that take the fall. I think for every mass layoff event there should also be someone laid off in the upper management who has to be responsive for said program.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: G5isAlive
This is normal in the course of business. Hopefully these employees have been highly paid and coming out with a good severance package. On the whole, they should be able to easily find new employment.

For Apple, nothing ventured nothing gained. This shows that they are still daring enough to try big new things. Onward and upward.
And they would have learned massive amounts on LiDAR, AI and I’m am sure, a lot more tech.

It's always the lower level employees that take the fall. I think for every mass layoff event there should also be someone laid off in the upper management who has to be responsive for said program.
Not knowing, because we’re all just guessing, that there would be far more than a single layer of employees no longer required.
 
  • Like
Reactions: I7guy and Dremmel
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.