Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The SE was not a “small phone”, which is why people who ask for small phones don’t buy it. When we say “small”, we mean “small”. Like iPhone 4s was the last phone I could use one handed. Give me an iPhone 4s sized phone, and people who want small phones will buy it.
100% not true. You’re the exception. Just like people who pine over manual transmissions. Not enough people buy them to justify the cost of research and development.
 
I get why folks for whom their phone is their primary device want a big screen.

But I have big monitors on my desktop Mac, and an iPad. I prefer the convenience of a phone that is small enough to easily go into my pockets. So, it’s the physical size, not the screen size, that is the constraint I’m concerned about.

Ideally, I would like a mini with:
  • a good (not top/pro, but not low-end) camera
  • decent storage (256 or more)
  • decent battery life
I’m currently on a 13-mini with 512GB storage (would have gone with less, but that was the one my carrier had a good deal on for; I’m currently only using about 90GB, but occasionally record video, so like to have the working space). I also don’t put a case on it, to further keep the overall size smaller.

When that phone eventually becomes no longer usable, I’ll be looking for whatever is physically smallest as a replacement, to make it easy to carry around. (Assuming civilization hasn’t already collapsed by then… 😅)
 
We can only guess.

In a real world example: I know a guy who is operating a small phone repair store near my house. He has two iPhone 12 mini that was sitting in his inventory for like half year without anyone want buy it.

The resale value on the mini iPhone is really bad, they go less than $250 in Canada. Given Apple along all the smart phone manufactures are all given up on small phone. And Apple is only one who is able to sell mini phone in volume and with reasonable profit margin. Even Apple can't stop making small phones.
I mean the 12 mini is the worst small phone. It's not just that it's a year older than the 13 mini, it also has terrible battery life and anyone who's looked into it knows to skip the 12 mini and buy the 13 mini.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iGüey
This is absolutely horrific.

I do not want a phone bigger than about 5.5 inches. I also do not use a case because I don't want to make my phone bigger than it needs to be.

I don't know what I'm going to do when my 13 mini dies.

I would upgrade yearly if there were a new small phone to upgrade to, but given there isn't, I'll likely upgrade only when I'm absolutely forced to.

The latest features (e.g. better cameras, dynamic island, action button, longer battery, USB-C, a faster processor, etc.) are absolutely not worth the downside of going to a larger phone. A reasonably sized iPhone is THE single most important feature.

I do not want a JumboTron in my pocket!
 
Except every single smartphone manufacturer has moved away from small phones due to the fact that there is just not large enough of a market anymore. Nobody's going to manufacture something en-masse just to acommodate a niche segment of the smartphone market.
The same argument could be made about automobiles — they've been getting bigger and bigger as the result of market forces, but that's partially (if not largely) because of auto manufacturers' marketing efforts to sell increasingly more expensive models to Americans instead of more affordable sedans — so much so that Ford, Chrysler, and Chevrolet stopped selling sedans altogether.

And the result is that Americans are spending drastically more on cars than ever before, and footing a higher gas bill to boot. Exactly what the auto manufacturers wanted. Not to mention, larger cars are actually more dangerous to pedestrians and other motorists, with little increase in safety to their own occupants. So this shift has not been in our best interests as a population.

Consumers are never making decisions in a vacuum, and it's not safe to assume that consumers actually wanted larger phones as much as we were convinced to buy larger phones.
 
The same argument could be made about automobiles — they've been getting bigger and bigger as the result of market forces, but that's partially (if not largely) because of auto manufacturers' marketing efforts to sell increasingly more expensive models to Americans instead of more affordable sedans — so much so that Ford, Chrysler, and Chevrolet stopped selling sedans altogether.

And the result is that Americans are spending drastically more on cars than ever before, and footing a higher gas bill to boot. Exactly what the auto manufacturers wanted. Not to mention, larger cars are actually more dangerous to pedestrians and other motorists, with little increase in safety to their own occupants. So this shift has not been in our best interests as a population.

Consumers are never making decisions in a vacuum, and it's not safe to assume that consumers actually wanted larger phones as much as we were convinced to buy larger phones.

CAFE standards were a major factor for this change in America


Screenshot 2025-02-19 at 12.02.09.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: addamas
This might sound crazy, but part of the reason I want a smaller iPhone is not only that I want something easier to use 1-handed and easier to put in my pocket (and not drop), but actually because the all-screen design of the modern iPhones make it really hard to use 1-handed even if you can comfortably hold it with 1 hand. The motion to go from the bottom of the phone to swipe it open compared to the Home Button on the SE for instance is just more annoying to use, and going even higher for Control Center is nearly impossible because of how much higher it is relative to the screen on the older iPhones.

I was really hoping we'd get a 16 mini as a surprise, but I guess this'll have to do for now. I need a phone with better battery and camera, and this seems to be the best option now, on a budget.
 
The 12 mini had better battery life than the SE, but poor battery life was the narrative.
I have had the 12 mini as a work phone, and currently drive the 13 mini as a personal. Both are a good phone, the 13 mini a better one, and I will keep it as long as possible. No one makes a small phone anymore. I use an IPP for the bigger screen needs and it is my main computer in the backpack.

The mini was Apple's poorest selling phone. But it still sold in volumes most other phone manufacturers would kill for.

Typed on 13 mini.
 
CAFE standards were a major factor for this change in America


View attachment 2483954
Sure, we can put some blame on Congress for capitulating to the auto manufacturers' lobbying efforts, but ultimately it's the auto manufacturers that are to blame. They wanted to sell larger, more expensive cars — and they did, by convincing Americans it's what they wanted, even though it's not in our best interests by almost any measure.

Bringing it back to the topic at hand: did the iPhone mini get any of Apple's best features or sexiest marketing? I think we know the answer to that. Let's face it, phone manufacturers would rather sell a large phone for more money than a small phone for less.
 
Sure, we can put some blame on Congress for capitulating to the auto manufacturers' lobbying efforts, but ultimately it's the auto manufacturers that are to blame. They wanted to sell larger, more expensive cars — and they did, by convincing Americans it's what they wanted, even though it's not in our best interests by almost any measure.

Yes, I put blame on both - as the quote indicated, it was lobbied for, absolutely 100%
 
  • Like
Reactions: dmi and macJOS
If Apple was smart, every 3-5 years they would produce a small phone form factor. Maybe two models, one with the pro features (that will fit in the chassis anyways). There's obviously a market, it might be small but a lot of people don't want to buy a huge phone.

Including me, I went from a 5 to an X and just did not like having something that big. Sure, it was nice to read and use the map in my car, but carrying it around in my pocket always sucked compared to the smaller one. I have a 13 mini now, and I'll keep that as long as I it is working...I'm considering finding a refurb and sticking it in the closet until the time comes, though I think mine can keep going since I keep it safe in a case, just a battery change in a couple years and the hardware should be good if I can keep my daughter away from it. A new mini phone will be a purchase in the future, odds are they can sell millions of those every few years if they produce it.
 
If Apple was smart, every 3-5 years they would produce a small phone form factor. Maybe two models, one with the pro features (that will fit in the chassis anyways). There's obviously a market, it might be small but a lot of people don't want to buy a huge phone.

Including me, I went from a 5 to an X and just did not like having something that big. Sure, it was nice to read and use the map in my car, but carrying it around in my pocket always sucked compared to the smaller one. I have a 13 mini now, and I'll keep that as long as I it is working...I'm considering finding a refurb and sticking it in the closet until the time comes, though I think mine can keep going since I keep it safe in a case, just a battery change in a couple years and the hardware should be good if I can keep my daughter away from it. A new mini phone will be a purchase in the future, odds are they can sell millions of those every few years if they produce it.

They'll just eventually rug pull software support and force folks to choose an iPhone they sell, or let you walk to an Android

They don't care if some people are out here as buyers

They make more money hyper optimizing around patio paver sized devices of multiple tradeoffs

This is not a "product driven" or "what's best for customers" company anymore
 
Last edited:
They'll just eventually rug pull software support and force folks to choose an iPhone they sell, or let you walk to an Android

The messed up part is that there aren't smaller, high-quality options on the android side either. We're just SOL.

It's as you say - making the best product for their customers is no longer a priority.
 
If Apple was smart, every 3-5 years they would produce a small phone form factor. Maybe two models, one with the pro features (that will fit in the chassis anyways). There's obviously a market, it might be small but a lot of people don't want to buy a huge phone.

Including me, I went from a 5 to an X and just did not like having something that big. Sure, it was nice to read and use the map in my car, but carrying it around in my pocket always sucked compared to the smaller one. I have a 13 mini now, and I'll keep that as long as I it is working...I'm considering finding a refurb and sticking it in the closet until the time comes, though I think mine can keep going since I keep it safe in a case, just a battery change in a couple years and the hardware should be good if I can keep my daughter away from it. A new mini phone will be a purchase in the future, odds are they can sell millions of those every few years if they produce it.
Buy a refurb to your daughter in appreciation to her good taste.
Planning, at least thinking about it, to pick up a red refurb too.
I love my midnight, but the red XR I had earlier lingers in my memory because of the color.
 
  • Love
Reactions: iGüey
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.