922 said:
An iPod video seems likely, but I wouldn't want one. Make me change my mind, Apple!
I agree. I've already voiced my opinions on what
music issues they need to fix before even
considering video, but that's beside the point. Apple doesn't care about music. What's so cool about having lo-res video in your pocket?
- You can't watch it while walking/riding/driving.
- It's hardly worth watching at all on a tiny screen.
- Plugging it into a TV somewhere else isn't going to give you near the video or surround sound quality of a DVD.
- Very few people carry DVDs around with them wherever they go. Thus very few people are saying to themselves right now "Gosh, I wish I could take my whole collection of DVDs with me at once!" Contrast that to the situation with music, where most people were taking a few CDs in the car, making the iPod an obvious extension of that behavior.
Can video be anything but a gimmick? Even if it's just for video podcasts, you still have to sit down somewhere to watch it. You can't watch while driving like you might listen to an audio podcast.
This is a serious question for all of you who are frothing at the mouth for a video iPod: how do you really expect to use it? Do you expect the video to be as beneficial as the music capability, or do you expect to play with it a few times and rarely use it after that? Would you really use it every day? Every week even? Think about it and be honest.
I had an iPod photo (before it got stolen
🙁) and I loaded a few hundred photos on it, but I really never
used that feature. Not once did I have a situation where I wanted to pull it out and start showing pictures to people. Glad I didn't buy the AV cable, as the photo capability was clearly just a gimmick to me. Isn't video more of the same?
I want to know why it's going to be the next great thing. Besides the fact that it's from Apple and Steve Jobs says it's great. Convince me. I'm a skeptic.
I'd much rather have an improved music experience
(gapless) any day. I'll pay handsomely for
that. Too bad I'm in the minority, I guess!