I like the way glossy looks, but I've read some stuff on the eye-strain, and that sorta worries me as my eyes are easily strained. I've sat a matte and glossy side by side, and I just love the way glossy works. I can't decide.
If you love the glossy, why not get it? It's what some people want and I don't see the issue if you like it - maybe use it in the store for a while. You can always exchange it, that would be an expensive exchange and a pain (I *think* Apple store is 14 days and 15% - definitely check first) but it's not completely irreversible if you feel you've made a mistake after using it for a week.
Personally I greatly like matte but if you "like" and "really love" glossy I think you have your choice - there is no "wrong"
LOL - I just read the above reply - he'll never decide now...