I loathe Catalina and deeply regret upgrading to it. It should come with a health warning. Here’s the round of warnings I emailed to a friend…
1. The upside of upgrading from Mojave isn’t great. Installing Catalina disciplined me to remove old and defunct 32-bit Apps, and I can see how the splitting of iTunes is long overdue (though Music and TV are irritating in their constant nagging to get you to upgrade to more Apple services). However I don’t keep my iTunes library on this Mac, and won’t be updating the Mac that does have it until Apple iron out the following issues.
2. Major problems with multiple IMAP accounts and Mail: mail requires repeated password input, won’t sync across devices. Apple Mail in Catalina refuses to display such mail in chronological order.
3. All my hundreds of colour-coded Stickies turned grey and stacked over each other.
4. When Saving as, file name no longer preselects filename only (omitting filetype suffix), but includes entire file name. The former version was a timesaving godsend to jpg workflows – all you had to do was type over the previous filename. Why change it? There’s no conceivable way this is an improvement.
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251637697
5. There’s only one typeface for Mail message list view and it’s Helvetica, which a great typeface, but does not work for list view. It can not be changed, despite what Apple claim.
6a. In Mail's column layout view, the columns cannot be moved, nor altered. Don’t want to see inbox info? Tough, you’re stuck with it. Want to see how many attachments a message has? (and nowadays most have one as a logo). Again, hard luck, you can’t.
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/251577490
6b. Sort by size in Mail works, but no longer shows the size of the attachment to emails.
7. The slide-to-delete/mark as unread feature in Mail isn’t sticky enough, meaning it’s easy to trigger inadvertently. This feature isn’t needed in Mac OS anyway.
8. In non-column view, it’s not possible to see the contents of the message (the way it works on iPad and the way Apple advertise Catalina). This could be a hardware compatibility problem, but Apple don’t mention it.
9. Thumbnails generated by Photoshop randomly come out low def.
10. I now have two folders in my Trash (sorry Bin) that I can not delete, even using Terminal.
11. Spotlight search now runs like a slug on a valium overdose.
All of the above should have been sorted out in the pre-release version, never mind the seventh iteration almost a year after launch. When Apple degrade/deprecate a feature it’s usually for long-term gain. These cork-ups just look like sloppy, don’t-give-a-fork design.
If anyone has solutions for any of these problems (Apple Support don’t), please let me know...