Maybe you didn't understand the joke buddy.At first you give a reasonable sounding answer. But then you immediately follow it up with a condescending answer when someone does what you asked them to do, which is to be specific.
A specific question needs someone who can respond to a particular aspect, while a general question allows someone to give an overall impression.
People usually want to know this: "Is feature A fixed? And even if it's not, will I regret installing it?" Two different questions with two different answers.