Yep--if they do it, everyone will call it a me too product. If they don't do it, everyone will say they're not competing well with Android. It's a lose/lose for Apple.
It's a lose/lose only in forums like MacRumors. Out in the real world, it will be the lead news story for weeks, they will be drowning in margins as this will have premium pricing, it will sell like wildfire, an the kicker is iOS 7 will bring at least some innovation with Johny in charge. So no, I think it will only be a lose / lose in a very, very small circle of Internet rumor echo chamber.