They don't need to promote the app. It can receive zero coverage and it's just hosted available for download like adult sites are hosted somewhere and available for someone to type in.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple Says It Doesn't Approve of EU Porn App
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
It stands to reason that people would use third party app stores to distribute apps normally not allowed in the iOS App Store. Typically pornography, gambling, vaping, maybe even pirated APKs or those with trackers up the wazoo.
These are the obvious low hanging fruit that supporters of third party app stores risk been seen as endorsing, and it starts from them being unwilling to acknowledge the benefits of the closed App Store model in the first place.
You may have missed the part where Apple said they “approved” it.
When you require every app and its developer obtain your approval for distribution, don’t complain when they take you up on your own terms (and wording) and run with it.
Such a response is a gross distortion of the truth and denial of what the developer is trying to do and their motives as demonsrated by their promotion efforts. The developer's intent is obvious as is your dislike of Apple and high approval of the EU regulators actions directed at Apple.
"You do approve this app" makes no sense grammatically.
Keep children safe from what? Don’t children use browsers? Where there are 1 billion free porn videos?
Why so intent on distorting the meaning of "approved" as it applies only to meeting technical standards and nothing else? I am pretty sure you know that and are trying to push a narrative that is false because it is in compliance with a personal opinion. Could it be there is no objectivity where Apple is concerned? Your profile picture / avatar would seem to provide a hint of your views.
I thought Apple already did hardcore porn. In their case, it’s called “RAM and storage upgrade prices”
However, watching people blow each other’s heads off with machine guns is OK for kids to watch, it’s just the sex that’s dangerous.
Yes, so it seems like the people who are really asking for a sideload/alt store option is very small, and therefore rules should not be created to serve the few.
Delete the sideload option. This is just a massive headache for most people.
Prudish, hypocritical Americans.
The country with the largest porn industry.
Better give some money to Trump Mr. Cook
hypocritical, money hungry ceo
The country with the largest porn industry.
Better give some money to Trump Mr. Cook
hypocritical, money hungry ceo
same argument applies to side loading: some will sideload, almost everyone will not. weird how some people will go through the ends of the earth to fight for one thing, but minimize another thing of similar calibre when they don't like it.
Qualifier: Apple's point about what the developer is doing is obviously correct even to a blind person. It's not Apple's job to play the role of a parent. They are well within their rights to disapprove of certain categories of material and to say so. Apple has provided extensive tools for parents to monitor children's online activity and their access to their app store. Far more tools than any other OS and App Store provider has. To claim Apple has not take reasonable steps to protect children and then conflate that with with dating / hookup apps is just plain wrong and a distortion made for purposes of pushing a personal narrative. If parents fail to use the tools or allow their children to access inappropriate material it is a parent failure not Apple's failure. Any app that allows message communication between people can be used as dating apps can to find partners for sexual activity. Such apps have nothing in common with apps that directly provide porn images.
The article gets lost in these ridiculous side arguments that are based nothing other than an individual's personal dislike for one of the parties they mention masked by some flimsy moral or ideological claim.
Let em remind readers the article was a bout a developer intentionally trying to give the impression Apple approved of their porn app. Injecting semantics and the rest of the hypocrisy I read into the comments is laughable.
Does Apple know about p0rn content on twitter and reddit, no? Do they plan to ban those apps, too? 😅
While I’m sure Apple is not ecstatic that people use Apple devices for porn via browsers, there is no other practical option for Apple. The internet is too vast and wild. But a closed app ecosystem is small and manageable by comparison, so control is an option in that case.
And there are important distinctions between visiting a porn site with a browser vs downloading a porn app. A website exists independently and generally has no affiliation with any device/platform, neither in social concept nor in a technical way. It can generally be accessed by multitude of browsers and by a multitude of devices. An app however is much more closely associated with its device/platform, both technically (lives on the device, usually deeper access/integration to hardware and OS, often uses platform-specific design language, etc) and in social concept. You will hear people say, “download the (eg.) Yelp iPhone app” and the app will look and act like it belongs on an iPhone. You will never hear anyone say, “visit the Yelp iPhone site” because that wouldn’t make sense.
So an app is both more personal to the user and to the device. This association is significant if the creator of the platform believes the thing being associated is detrimental either to the creator’s/platform’s image, or to its users, or both. And if they believe it’s detrimental to their users, and they have a way to control it, then it’s understandable if they feel they have a responsibility to restrict it on their product, even if in this case porn is still accessible via browser. For Apple, it could be less about keeping porn from their users in the practical sense, and more about not condoning porn by allowing it in their App Store, since that is very direct access and within their control. And who knows, for some people, having a dedicated porn app may cause them to look at porn more than if they had to go into a browser and find a bookmark, etc. (I think that is true for social media apps for many people so it reasonably stands to be true here too), so there may be measurable practical results to the restriction as well.
And there are important distinctions between visiting a porn site with a browser vs downloading a porn app. A website exists independently and generally has no affiliation with any device/platform, neither in social concept nor in a technical way. It can generally be accessed by multitude of browsers and by a multitude of devices. An app however is much more closely associated with its device/platform, both technically (lives on the device, usually deeper access/integration to hardware and OS, often uses platform-specific design language, etc) and in social concept. You will hear people say, “download the (eg.) Yelp iPhone app” and the app will look and act like it belongs on an iPhone. You will never hear anyone say, “visit the Yelp iPhone site” because that wouldn’t make sense.
So an app is both more personal to the user and to the device. This association is significant if the creator of the platform believes the thing being associated is detrimental either to the creator’s/platform’s image, or to its users, or both. And if they believe it’s detrimental to their users, and they have a way to control it, then it’s understandable if they feel they have a responsibility to restrict it on their product, even if in this case porn is still accessible via browser. For Apple, it could be less about keeping porn from their users in the practical sense, and more about not condoning porn by allowing it in their App Store, since that is very direct access and within their control. And who knows, for some people, having a dedicated porn app may cause them to look at porn more than if they had to go into a browser and find a bookmark, etc. (I think that is true for social media apps for many people so it reasonably stands to be true here too), so there may be measurable practical results to the restriction as well.
Last edited:
Lol viewing porn on iOS is as easy as doing a google
Such a weird take.
A: why are you giving literal children access to a smartphone in the first place?
If they try to access this content, whose fault is it? It’s called bad parenting
B: using that same logic, surely you can block them from downloading alt stores anyway? I dunno why everyone seems to think having the option to download alt stores suddenly makes it less safe for everyone. It’s not true whatsoever
No, European anticompetitive law took it away.
There’s a distinctive difference.
Nice that you ignored my question and then went on a rant... Is there Porn on those Apps?
☐ Yes
☐ No
You can try and change the narrative to something else if you want, but that is not what is happening here. The question that is being asked is, does Apple have the right to restrict the app store categories? What's next, you'd defend a terrorist app or is only what you find morally okay?
So why do you think Children should have access to porn?
Oh wow not like the Americans to be oppressive with anything concerning sex /s
From a country where child marriage is completely legal in 37 states and you keep insisting on parading little kids dressed up as sleazy hookers for "entertainment" excuse us if we just ignore you yeah
You've got much much bigger issues to worry about right now
From a country where child marriage is completely legal in 37 states and you keep insisting on parading little kids dressed up as sleazy hookers for "entertainment" excuse us if we just ignore you yeah
You've got much much bigger issues to worry about right now
Whilst there are many who disapprove of pornography, there are many non adult places where you can purchase it. Book shops sell pornographic novels, newsagents sell pornographic magazines, retail stores sell pornographic DVD's, cable and satellite broadcasters have pornographic channels and it's all legal. Why should the app store be any different?. People may not like it but tough because that is how the world works.
People always use children as an excuse to have pornography banned because they say it is too easy for children to access. All the above example's I have given can be very easily accessed by children because an adult can make the purchase and give it to the child. Are we to ban book stores, newsagents, retail stores and cable/satellite broadcasters because they are unable to control what adults do with the stuff they purchase?
as long as the porn app is clean as in has no malware or virus then it should be allowed in an EU app store.
People always use children as an excuse to have pornography banned because they say it is too easy for children to access. All the above example's I have given can be very easily accessed by children because an adult can make the purchase and give it to the child. Are we to ban book stores, newsagents, retail stores and cable/satellite broadcasters because they are unable to control what adults do with the stuff they purchase?
as long as the porn app is clean as in has no malware or virus then it should be allowed in an EU app store.
It is not Apple's business what I do with the hardware I bought from them.
Most large US companies, Apple included, are censoring everything to Disney like "family friendly" standards because they don't want to "offend" any pressure group.
It's good that this is ending, at least in certain territories.
Edit: and stop being worked up about this porn app. Ask yourself how many other apps that touch "controversial" subjects have been denied by Apple since they started with the iOS app store...
Most large US companies, Apple included, are censoring everything to Disney like "family friendly" standards because they don't want to "offend" any pressure group.
It's good that this is ending, at least in certain territories.
Edit: and stop being worked up about this porn app. Ask yourself how many other apps that touch "controversial" subjects have been denied by Apple since they started with the iOS app store...