Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
A sealed slab of glass with internals inside would be. Speaker and microphone would probably sound bad though with enough power to the speaker and digital processing after the mic it could be done.
No, glass will eventually crack under pressure. Therefore, it cannot be waterproof.

Waterproof pretty much means, no matter the scenario, water cannot penetrate. By that logic, nothing can ever be truly waterproof.
 
No, glass will eventually crack under pressure. Therefore, it cannot be waterproof.

Waterproof pretty much means, no matter the scenario, water cannot penetrate. By that logic, nothing can ever be truly waterproof.
That's why most products say "water resistant to ____ meters" or whatever.
 
That's why most products say "water resistant to ____ meters" or whatever.
Yes, thats my point with my opening post. They are claiming in the article it will be "waterproof", but nothing truly can be waterproof.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobob
No, glass will eventually crack under pressure. Therefore, it cannot be waterproof.

Waterproof pretty much means, no matter the scenario, water cannot penetrate. By that logic, nothing can ever be truly waterproof.


A rock is truly waterproof. If the phone inside is filled with a good solid like a metal epoxy, it will be waterproof at any pressure. At pressures beyond that the water would solidify and not be water any more. So a phone could be made truly waterproof.

phase-gif.127164
 
  • Like
Reactions: AngerDanger
A rock is truly waterproof. If the phone inside is filled with a good solid like a metal epoxy, it will be waterproof at any pressure. At pressures beyond that the water would solidify and not be water any more. So a phone could be made truly waterproof.
Uh no ... unless the entire phone is made of rock.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mlrollin91
A rock is truly waterproof. If the phone inside is filled with a good solid like a metal epoxy, it will be waterproof at any pressure. At pressures beyond that the water would solidify and not be water any more. So a phone could be made truly waterproof.
A rock breaks down (erodes) because of water. How can that be waterproof?? Eventually the rock will no longer be a rock and become dust and sand particles. Really bad example.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ErikGrim
A rock is truly waterproof. If the phone inside is filled with a good solid like a metal epoxy, it will be waterproof at any pressure. At pressures beyond that the water would solidify and not be water any more. So a phone could be made truly waterproof.

phase-gif.127164
It's laughable that you simply throw out words like "a rock" and "waterproof."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mlrollin91
It's laughable that you simply throw out words like "a rock" and "waterproof."
I like that he edited a graph in later, which doesn't help anything.


Look above. Physics. They tried with you in high school. I'm sorry.
Funny since I don't think you even understand anything you wrote. I did fine in physics though, thank you.


P.S. Water always wins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mlrollin91
The rumored specs on the iPhone 8 is that it will have half the memory and a .4" smaller usable screen (5.1" with a .7" toolbar on the bottom) than the phone you are comparing it to. You're supposed to get more features for the money as time goes on, not less.

Apple is free to price it as it sees fit, but hardware wise the iPhone 8 isn't any great leap over the Galaxy S8 other than the under-glass fingerprint reader that supposedly adds about $20 to the material cost.

I agree that you're suppose to get more features for the money as time goes on, but you're comparing a phone on the market vs. rumors about a phone that doesn't even exist yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Duane Martin
I like that he edited a graph in later, which doesn't help anything.



Funny since I don't think you even understand anything you wrote. I did fine in physics though, thank you.


P.S. Water always wins.

The physics didn't stick lol. I use physics in my job daily and if I get it wrong people get hurt. I have as yet, still not gotten it wrong. Move on, you're out of your league.
 
The physics didn't stick lol. I use physics in my job daily and if I get it wrong people get hurt. I have as yet, still not gotten it wrong. Move on, you're out of your league.
Well.. you did fail to address my point of rocks eroding, so they cannot be "waterproof".
 
The physics didn't stick lol. I use physics in my job daily and if I get it wrong people get hurt. I have as yet, still not gotten it wrong. Move on, you're out of your league.
The weathering and eroding of rock from water is not a new concept, lol. This is going way off topic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mlrollin91
Well I'd hope it has wireless charging otherwise I'm not upgrading. Apple is so far behind but when they finally add a new feature YEARS late (after Android has it usually, and I dislike android) everyone bows to them, not me! I love Apple but they need to step it up.
 
Features that have been around for at least the past year or more on smartphones are supposed to get me excited? Yay? And wireless charging isn't really worth it if you have to pay for the wireless charger which we will and Apple will overcharge for it vs competitors as per usually.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mlrollin91
As others have said it's incorrect to say they will be waterproof. It may be water resistant, but put any gadget with a seal in even still water long enough or deep enough and that seal will break.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mlrollin91
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.