You miss his point completely, which is why, in your own words my friend "you fail". He's just exposing the inconsistency of these fanboys. The truth is this, when you buy a BMW you know what kind of track record you are getting but you are willing to put up with it because the benefits outweigh the costs. And BMW doesn't mislead you into thinking otherwise.
Hence BMWFan's point is that paying more for Macs that try to sell themselves as having a superior build quality is bogus. At least when you buy the BMW there is no deception. When I bought my Macbook pro, it was revealed months later that there was a defective video car in it. Did Apple issue a recall or suggest to have my video card replaced? No, all they did was extend the warranty slightly but they are pretty much trying to wait it out hopping that by the time people run into problems they will have run their warranty course. Forcing them to buy Apple Care. I mean, they even "underclock" the performance of the hardware in later updates after the product has shipped and sold. I pay for a certain degree of performance, and then it is taken away from me so that they can avoid replacing a defective product. That certainly doesn't scream quality care and consumer conscientiousness.
Does that mean other PCs are better? No it doesn't. Apple may still be better than all the rest, but that doesn't mean they are providing the quality that they ought to be providing for the price they are asking for. I don't think it's unreasonable for BMWFan to point this out. Now keep in mind, though I'm no fanboy, and though I am certainly critical of Apple, I'd still buy another Mac should this one break down because they are still the best option. However, I wish they would be up front about things and actually strive to improve their quality control rather than have it diminish as seems to be the trend. I also wish that when a problem is encountered they would fix it and not try to avoid it by crippling features likely to expose their irresponsibility in terms of manufacturing. Is that too much to ask for?