Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Yeah… it’s a thing called the paradox of choice. Or analysis paralysis. Choices confuse, and too many lead to one simply making no choice. That’s why, to stick to your terrible analogy that didn’t help your cause, good restaurants have short menus. And to continue on why that’s a bad example, the restaurant has a menu… of only what they serve. You can’t go into Hell’s Kitchen and order McDonald’s. Sorry.

Hey thanks for the kind words!
I hope you have a great day my friend!
 
I'm not saying the ecosystem is intrinsically bad though, it wasn't my point
Y’all keep claiming at anytime it’s locked down and I laugh because we aren’t trapped. We aren’t beholden to apple. I and millions of others can leave we choose not to because android is inferior.

The walled garden works for us because without it we would have the haphazard mess that is android.

Even google is slowly getting like apple. Still don’t ever want to use a lagdroid as my daily driver again but still.
 
Apple also has a choice, comply to sell in the EU or pull out. Let us see what they will choose.
I wish they’d pull out. It may hurt them in the short term but so many businesses run on apple. They would hurt the EU.

We already see android is crap for enterprise. Chromeos is barely suitable for education and google is not viable in fitness, entertainment, music, wearables.
 
Y’all keep claiming at anytime it’s locked down and I laugh because we aren’t trapped. We aren’t beholden to apple. I and millions of others can leave we choose not to because android is inferior.

The walled garden works for us because without it we would have the haphazard mess that is android.

Even google is slowly getting like apple. Still don’t ever want to use a lagdroid as my daily driver again but still.
Y'all? Laughing ? My point being that if one is to leave for any reason, the impossibly to transfer years of data makes it . Or if you need to work on dual platforms . Now , try to find a way to have years of data imported . I see no denying of such an evidence within your arguments either tbh

I don't deny the superiority and reliability of apple nor am I saying Google is better

I must say though, out of experience android is way less laggy than what you seem to be willing to believe
 
Just some perspective.
  • Is WhatsApp open?
  • Is Signal open?
  • Is Skype open?
  • Is Telegram open?
  • Is Viber open?
  • Is Slack open?
What needs to happen is the entire messaging industry needs to design a low-level Message Interchange Format allowing messages to seamlessly and securely pass between these networks.

Then competition can be remain at the surface UX level. If an app doesn't support a particular feature or media type, it's just ignored on the receiving end, maybe with a placeholder indicating such.
Defining a standard message format, while difficult considering how much crap Apple has stuffed into iMessage over the years, is relatively easy. There’s even a recent standard for encrypting messages: message layer security (MLS). The hard part is identity and key management. Who do you allow to send messages to your users? How do you verify FB/Signal/etc users? Just look at how spammy email is that a bunch of security properties had to be bolted on, and now at this point you pretty much need email hosted at a large corp or it won’t send through all the filters. (Not commenting on how much spam is or is not present already for iMessage/WhatsApp. But it will undoubtedly get worse if all the message platforms merge.)

I’d rather have third party client support than having these distinct message platforms have to hack things together. Then you can have your “all in one” app like Beeper tried to do. Not that Apple will ever willingly allow it for iMessage.
 
We don’t want to be forced to use alternate app stores. Complicates the whole reason we have iOS. In before someone says, “you don’t have to”.
There are alternative app stores on Android than you can shake a stick at. I only use the PlayStore.
Nonsense some of the apps we all use will decide to go to other stores to save money.
Ever consider an alternative app? Facebook is the only app I can think of that has no viable alternative. In which case, that's the trash taking itself out.😁
Then we will be a fragmented and difficult to use as an Android phone.
Copying files to and from android is 10,000x easier than iOS
Leave our iPhone along.
Our iPhone exactly. There are iPhone owners who want alternative app stores. I don't care for another app store, but I support the choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Samplasion
People seem strangely averse to "options"
I really don't understand it - at all

Apparently going to the restaurant and being force fed from only the Appetizers menu is somehow desirable for all meals at all times.


The is correct. That's why a set course menu is the most expensive meal at the most luxury restaurants. Now if the Appetisers are not good, then that's a problem. But for me to decide what is good in the restaurant? What's luxury about that?

I want to make ONE choice: which platform to go for. After that I want everything I need to work out-of-the-box. The choices given at every step after that is mostly an annoyance. Think of all the people who just tap skip, skip, skip during set up of their phone. That's most of them. They want everything working a quickly as possible, out of the box.
 
A closed ecosystem. Where you have no choice. It’s so weird that people in the US are so against freedom and choice nowadays. People in the EU are still enjoying the EXACT same ecosystem as before. But have the bonus of more options, which they can ignore.
I have plenty of freedom and choice in the Apple ecosystem. Overwhelmed with choice, in fact. I prefer the integrity of the design and it’s functionality. The EU does good work on privacy. These sustained assaults on Apple have only to do with EU generating cash for itself with fines and bolstering the greed of other companies.
 
By this time next year, it might be possible for EU users to buy a brand-new iPhone, and replace Safari with Samsung Browser, replace the home screen with Xiaomi Launcher, swap Siri with Google Gemini, drop FaceTime in exchange for Google Duo (this physically pains me to type😖), etc., etc.

Thanks to the power of legislation, now you can create a phone that only an engagement-hungry tech YouTuber could love. :cool:
😱
 
It's fascinating to watch... you are aware that no one will take that experience from you and you can stick with it but you can now extend the experience (if wanted and only then). But the you refuse that and claim that limited choice is better than more choice... 'because of a reason'... 🙄
It’s bizarre the EU is compelling Apple, because of its success, to carry things on its « menu ». It’s about EU corporate greed, not « choice ». Those so-called choices are other companies simply wanting a taste of what Apple built. Has nothing to do with giving « choice » to people. The EU has done good work on privacy.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: .wojtek
Because it's either iOS or Android for almost 100% of the market outside of china. The "almost" is because of the few linux phones out there. Apple and Google form a duopoly and it's not efficient nor good for consumers.
Based on what exactly? I’m quite happy being able to avoid google as much as I can. It’s certainly the more heinous and intrusive outfit. How about alternatives to Meta stuff and opening that all up.
 
This cable reminds me the USB cable you could buy 20 years ago on Ebay to transfer data between PC!
 
Why would that bother you? If someone wants to install android on their iPhone, it’s their property to do as they choose.
Seems to me Apple’s choice is to say we run Apple software to make Apple hardware work. That’s what they’re selling and I’m buying. It’s a package. It works. Thank you
 
...
What mobile OS choices did EU and rest of the world bring ?
please name a few.
it is easy to complain, difficult to make something.
Symbian from Psion. Not bad for its time (90ies). The OS tried to be a classic personal computer, but small. Touch with stylus. Not at all so open. And not at all so easy to use for non-tech people.
 
iPhone hardware is great, but iOS lacks customizations, really hope EU will force Apple to make their hardware compatible with Android and Linux mobile OS.
EU should force apple to work with Linux and Gggole to make it work smoothly :)
or force Apple to make their A/M series processor design open source to increase competition. :)
we all can benefit from this, world will be a better place.
How does forcing Apple to work with those entities make for better « competition ». It’s clear that all the competing apps and other software for the Mac too are competing to be on the platform. I’m quite content to have google do google as far away as possible from my devices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iOS Geek and pesc
You don't care NOW, but maybe, just maybe, someday they'll be an amazing app you can't install in your iPhone vs Europe, and then you'll see how absurd Apple's attitude is by not allowing these new features on US.
Emulators is about all I can think of

Serious question, what besides apps for piracy do ya’ll have ideas for?

Maybe I’m not thinking outside the box enough, but I don’t really want for anything with the current restrictions
 
Yeah… it’s a thing called the paradox of choice. Or analysis paralysis. Choices confuse, and too many lead to one simply making no choice. That’s why, to stick to your terrible analogy that didn’t help your cause, good restaurants have short menus. And to continue on why that’s a bad example, the restaurant has a menu… of only what they serve. You can’t go into Hell’s Kitchen and order McDonald’s. Sorry.
The world is filled with options. Sometimes we’re spoiled for choice.
 
Also, does anyone read this to mean that every bank in the EU is going to be offering their own contactless payment solution in the own app, and that Apple Pay will likely not be supported for much longer?
This is one thing worrying me. If my bank stops supporting Apple Pay I hope there is another bank I can switch to that does. I pay with my Apple Watch, never with my phone, and I don't think the bank will be bothered to support anything other than the phone (even if they could).
 
Apple seems to be preparing for a clean exit from the EU.
I’ve been advocating Apple quitting EU entirely repeatedly. Doesn’t seem like it’s going to happen anytime soon huh.
Man Im glad that the EU is fighting back against big tech in general and their monopolistic practices. Someone has to do it and it's not gonna be coming out of the US. Im sick of seeing the way private data is mishandled with no real consequences and how the makers of big platforms rule over everyone like digital lords. Before people start defending tech companies like if they had stockhold syndrom and telling everything "just dont buy it or just dont use it", the argument only holds in a market that has healthy competition, not in a quasi monopolistic one. "Oh you don't like Apple's pratices? Just get an Android (and get all your data exploited by Google)" Two choices isn't synonimous with a competitive market. Governement intervention is required and beneficial when markets fail, as they often do. As much as I love Apple products, Apple also needs to be challenged and held accountable.
I would never understand people speaking for Apple, a trillion dollar company with an army of lawyers able to bankrupt you in seconds should you make them angry. Also, phantom of choice is a thing, and there’s the discontent of both. And what choice do those folks have?

Combined with many other things I am learning by the day, I am starting to understand why American people tout choice and freedom while simultaneously support anti-choice and anti-freedom. Pick a side bro? Or pick neither.

EU at least has the spine to step forward to a better world, and I’m all for it.
 
  • Disagree
  • Like
Reactions: Beautyspin and pesc
By this time next year, it might be possible for EU users to buy a brand-new iPhone, and replace Safari with Samsung Browser, replace the home screen with Xiaomi Launcher, swap Siri with Google Gemini, drop FaceTime in exchange for Google Duo (this physically pains me to type), etc., etc.

Thanks to the power of legislation, now you can create a phone that only an engagement-hungry tech YouTuber could love. :cool:

It would be like someone buying my book, and then proceeding to tear out the pages and use it as toilet paper.

Sure, the book is yours to do with since you have already paid for it, but if that’s your intent, then I would rather sell one less book than see my work being desecrated like that.
 
Get rid of Safari and transition to Android?

Why don’t you just buy an Android?

Are you sure about that? What if a company (say Facebook or Zoom just as examples) decides to ONLY offer their app in their own (or a 3rd party) app store, then you're forced to either not use the app you've used for years or go down the path of sourcing apps from a variety of app stores that may or may not be as safe/privacy focused.

I get what you're saying, you're just thinking that developers will never shun the official App Store which I think isn't as much of a slam dunk as you think once the "cat is out of the bag".

If choice is truly the driver, there should be legislation included that also forces app developers to offer their apps via the Apple App store as well (at full feature parity up to what the official App Store T&Cs allows) or else face massive fines. That would then ensure that the current status quo that many Apple users enjoy remains undisturbed.
That's an interesting point but as counterargument - more competition should force Apple store to be more competitive if they don't want to loose intereitng apps.

On the other hand because if apple dumb policies some apps were not available either way...
 
It’s bizarre the EU is compelling Apple, because of its success, to carry things on its « menu ». It’s about EU corporate greed, not « choice ». Those so-called choices are other companies simply wanting a taste of what Apple built. Has nothing to do with giving « choice » to people. The EU has done good work on privacy.
If one company starts getting dominant position then all the benevolent rules of "free market" stop to apply and it needs to be regulated thus the rules applying to "successful" Apple...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.