Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I wanted one so bad... but that price is just a little too much for me to justify the purchase when all I wanted was a second display to ... well, do nothing productive. But at that price? $100 shy of a second iMac? Nah, can't do it.

I'll have to look into monitors from other makers... Samsung or LG maybe...
 
  • Like
Reactions: haruhiko
I will let you guys know how this monitor is. I ordered one:

1646771816461.png
 
I find the specs pretty underwhelming and not forward looking at all.

Given how infrequently Apple updates products like these, that’s not great
I think it's just the best they could do at this price right now. You're right about the future though. We're at a moment where we're switching to mini-led, oled, promotion, etc. So in a few years it will feel outdated, whereas a monitor from a few years ago today still holds up quite well.
 
It will be interesting to see if LG pulls the plug on the UltraFine 5K like they did the 21.5" UltraFine 4K in the year or so before Apple killed the 21.5" iMac 4K in favor of the 24" iMac.
I'm guessing they will. It just didn't sell well, even after they updated it to expand support for additional Macs and iPads. Apple was about the only reseller.
Is it ridiculous that I want one to pair with my base M1 Mini?
Not at all. That's essentially the replacement for the base 27" iMac.
 
I think it's just the best they could do at this price right now. You're right about the future though. We're at a moment where we're switching to mini-led, oled, promotion, etc. So in a few years it will feel outdated, whereas a monitor from a few years ago today still holds up quite well.
Also, Apple's devices are never about the specs. I mean look at the iPhone as a prime example - they never talk about the RAM and the iPhone always has as little RAM as possible and they run fine if not better than Android phones that boast the amount of RAM that they have...
 
  • Like
Reactions: aimson911 and WP31
You’ll notice that he didn’t say you could connect that screen to the 24 inch M1 iMac. :rolleyes:
 
As for the price tag, it seems like you're getting the similar to a 5K iMac display with upgraded audio and webcam while shaving off an entire Mac computer for only $100 off what a base model 27" imac was.
I think the 5k iMac was an anomalously insane value considering the quality display you were getting with the Mac computer. Makes much more sense to compare this display to other similar standalone displays in the industry.
 
Was hoping for a 24” display to replace my aging Apple Cinema Display or Dell U2415. Alas, the wait continues.
 
People who until today were buying LG UltraFine 5Ks (at $1300) because they wanted native macOS support (even if buggy) and a display with twice the PPI of a QHD or 4K panel.

Which is my point I guess. The LG has never been known to sell well. In fact, it seems to have proven to the rest of the world that there is no market for 5K monitors.

Also, Apple's devices are never about the specs. I mean look at the iPhone as a prime example - they never talk about the RAM and the iPhone always has as little RAM as possible and they run fine if not better than Android phones that boast the amount of RAM that they have...

Not sure what you are trying to say here, but it is possible to overcome low amounts of RAM with good coding and integration. You can't do that with refresh rate, HDR, connectivity, etc. What this monitor is missing isn't meaningless specs such as RAM in a closed system.
 
I would buy this in a second if it had a 2nd TB (or HDMI/DP) input and built in KVM. I can’t be the only person in 2022 who has a personal Mac and a work Windows laptop in a WFH setup. I figured this would never happen, but I dared to dream!

I’m guessing even with a third party KVM (if one even exists), the speakers would work but the webcam wouldn’t.
 
Was hoping for a 24” display to replace my aging Apple Cinema Display or Dell U2415. Alas, the wait continues.
I think the 24" ship has sailed. I was searching for a high quality 4K 24" monitor too and you'll basically end up with the old LG UltraFine 24".
 
This display feels out of date before it has even launched. A 60Hz, non-HDR, IPS LED, non-HDMI 2.1, edge-lit monitor for $1600? Yikes. And with how often Apple updates their displays, this monitor is not likely to age well.

Who is this for exactly? A video editor is going to want HDR and local dimming. Maybe a photographer? A casual user isn't spending $1600. Seems like it occupies this weird middle space between an everyday user and professional. Not sure there is a market in that space.
This is essentially the replacement for the 27" iMac. If you want a base, pair it with the base M1 mini. If you want to replace an iMac Pro, pair it with the Mac Studio. While it would have been nice if Apple had introduced this display 2 years ago, it still makes sense for them to release it now. Higher refresh rates, OLED, etc. mostly benefit gamers, which this display isn't intended for.

Considering that LG charged $1,300 for the UltraFine 5K, $1,600 for this isn't outrageous. The screen is a bit brighter, it offers a nano option, it's more aesthetically compatible with the Mac, and has a better camera and speakers. Most people who already have the LG display probably won't find a reason to switch, but this is a nice display for its intended purpose.
 
Considering that LG charged $1,300 for the UltraFine 5K, $1,600 for this isn't outrageous. The screen is a bit brighter, it offers a nano option, it's more aesthetically compatible with the Mac, and has a better camera and speakers. Most people who already have the LG display probably won't find a reason to switch, but this is a nice display for its intended purpose.
Now....who was it on ATP who recently purchased a used UltraFine 5K? I'm sure that person is regretting the decision right now...
 
I would buy this in a second if it had a 2nd TB (or HDMI/DP) input and built in KVM. I can’t be the only person in 2022 who has a personal Mac and a work Windows laptop in a WFH setup. I figured this would never happen, but I dared to dream!

I’m guessing even with a third party KVM (if one even exists), the speakers would work but the webcam wouldn’t.
We'll see what PC workarounds come about. For the LG, the speakers work, but the camera is hit-or-miss. I'm able to use the abandonware ClickMontorDDC to adjust the brightness. Whether this works with the Apple Studio Display remains to be seen. I guess we'll find out when these start to ship.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.