Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Except I recall parents and kids generally liking & listening to much of the late 70’s, 80’s and early 90’s music together. After all the angst/anger-ridden grunge and gangsta rap that rose in the early/mid 90’s, then things started to really separate.

Let’s see if the music in this commercial is ever heard in stores or on elevators or in waiting rooms after 5-10 years from now... :) Not that a song becoming Muzak defines a “good“ song...but more, a song staying memorable enough to be heard for decades really says something about its a quality IMHO.
We all have different histories. I remember parents hating 70s and 80s music. And their parents not liking 50s and 60s "garbage" that my parents liked.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Biorunner
So we should now like things that we don't like, otherwise we are bigots?

There may be a polite reasons to withhold judgements of appearance in a face-to-face context. To express those opinions on a minor forum when a rich artist is being remunerated is a completely different context.

Your suggestion that we should not be able to form or express our own aesthetic preferences is full-on authoritarian and anti-liberal.
No I don’t think it’s that at all. There’s a common dismissive theme in the forum suggesting it’s not music because it’s different. This is not fine.

It is music just not the stuff you like and that’s fine.
 
Seeing the comments in this thread gives me hope that the large majority of people here (and by extension elsewhere) are waking up to the nonsense these companies are pushing in order to pander to certain groups and push nonsensical content or “art” in order to ultimately sell products while claiming “virtue”

It’s a terrible ad to most who see it and I think even Tupac Shakur is spinning in his grave to what the genre he pioneered has become and to whom it has been taken over by.
Tupac didn’t pioneer this genre he was a participant, the genre pre-dates him by over a decade.
 
Nonsense it’s extremely creative. Could you do better?
Sure... I'd just re-use 2019's holiday ad, or 2018's holiday, etc, etc. The point I'm making, is this year's ad is inferior to past ones. Sure art is subjective, but I think you'll find a difficult battle convincing anyone that this year's ad is as good or better than year's past. But keep up the good fight!
 
I remember the days when you could actually understand the lyrics of a song and holiday songs sounded like holidays. *sigh* those were the times...
The casual racism with post likes these is gross. If you couldn't understand the lyrics, you may just not understand the English language. Also, this isn't a holiday song ... it's a holiday themed commercial, but the song is not a holiday song.
 
Sure... I'd just re-use 2019's holiday ad, or 2018's holiday, etc, etc. The point I'm making, is this year's ad is inferior to past ones. Sure art is subjective, but I think you'll find a difficult battle convincing anyone that this year's ad is as good or better than year's past. But keep up the good fight!
So you’d reuse last years ad to be more creative?!? Think about that for a minute.

Anyway yes if you feel this ad is inferior then yeah cool.
 
Can anyone tell me what its message is?

Adverts usually have a really simple and obvious message.

For example:
“Our deodorant will make you attractive”
“This phone makes life more fun”
“You can do real work on this iPad”
“Giving this product as a gift indicates real love”
”Macs are for fun people; Windows is for boring nerds”


Obviously they’re usually complete bollocks, but they’re clear. I don’t know what this one’s is.
 
I guess I’m not the target demo of that production because I thought it was dreadful. And what, in the name of all that is holy, was going on with that woman's teeth?
I’m not sticking up for the terrible advert, but I don’t get people’s problem with the tooth decorations. OK, you don’t like them, but it’s obvious they’re decorative and therefore represent personal taste; surely you don’t expect everyone to have the same taste as you, so what’s with the shock? You’re basically saying “I’m appalled by this demonstration of taste which differs from my own”.
 
Oompa Loompa's in the hooooussse! Do they really run commercials that are this long on TV? I guess Christmas ads focus on selling a style and a feeling more than a product. I know I need more puffy sweaters with skirts on the sleeves and mile long scarfs. Now I'm jealous. I'm sure it sounds fine but it looks like it collects dust easily and its always listening to you. If Apple could just make a set of computer speakers that would be nice.
 
I’m not sticking up for the terrible advert, but I don’t get people’s problem with the tooth decorations. OK, you don’t like them, but it’s obvious they’re decorative and therefore represent personal taste; surely you don’t expect everyone to have the same taste as you, so what’s with the shock? You’re basically saying “I’m appalled by this demonstration of taste which differs from my own”.
The artist is entitled to decorate herself however she sees fit. She is not entitled to universal approval of her decorative choices.
 
Can anyone tell me what its message is?

Adverts usually have a really simple and obvious message.

For example:
“Our deodorant will make you attractive”
“This phone makes life more fun”
“You can do real work on this iPad”
“Giving this product as a gift indicates real love”
”Macs are for fun people; Windows is for boring nerds”


Obviously they’re usually complete bollocks, but they’re clear. I don’t know what this one’s is.
See Post #152
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: mazz0
"I am offended by your opinion, I want to speak to the safe space manager".

Lol. Says the person behind a mostly anonymous internet identity, on a forum where members can't share their opinions about each other. This is the epitome of "safe space." But I'm glad the Negative Nancys of the site have a place to share their toxicity. 😂


It’s a terrible ad to most who see it and I think even Tupac Shakur is spinning in his grave to what the genre he pioneered has become and to whom it has been taken over by.

Ummm. I don't know what genre you think Tupac "pioneered" but I'd probably be showing my age if I listed all the rap artists that came and went before he even dropped his first album. You're full of it anyway - people who know the genre beyond being able to spell 2Pac's name know that if he were alive, he'd probably be collaborating with current artists (like this one) in order to stay relevant.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.