Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Mmmmm yes, focus on a feature only children will use Apple. Great idea!!! /s

Be careful, that is Apple only reason to exist these days. Children are the only people willing to spend money on Apple's low performing, thin, awkward to use products. Since Apple products are now a fashion statement that people have to own just because its Apple, there is no need for Apple to create any more leading edge products. It would be a waste of profit for the shareholders.
 
Stupid jokes don’t impress me. She needs a lot of real work, not superficial crap like knock knock jokes. How about they make her list businesses in ascending order by distance when I ask for a business location? Google has been able to do that for almost a decade. Maybe make my Series 3 watch be able to send my current location if I say “Send (contact name) my current location”? That seems doable and logical. How about working harder to ensure that Siri actually knows about local businesses? In the metro area of almost a million where I live there are major restaurants that have been here multiple decades that Siri is not even aware exist. I love it when I am in my car and I say “Navigate to woodys smoke shack” and Siri offers directions to a restaurant with a different name more than 1000 miles away. Or when Siri thinks that “Kyle’s Bikes” is “Flix Brewhouse”. This sort of thing happens probably at least 30% of the time when I use Siri for anything that would actually make her useful.

I wish they would just kill Siri and use Google honestly. iOS is superior to Android in every way that has no Siri tie in. But Siri is weak and more of a point of frustration than a feature.

Maybe they should add the ability to prefix every question like this: “Hey Siri, ask Google,” and then ask whatever thing you want to know and let her ask Google. Then Siri could have snarky replies and tell jokes directly, but use Google to get real information since Siri is mainly useless.
 
Last edited:
Why do people call these smart assistants? They respond to voice commands but they’re not smart. People seem to confuse those categories. Smart would be if Siri knew something before I did or reminded me about something I forgot.

The only smart feature that is currently available I can think of is travel time alerts for appointments, as they take traffic conditions into account. Otherwise she’s dumb as f...

One small example: I ask her directions to a store. Siri, in all her wisdom, suggests a store on the other side of the world. So I lookup the store by typing the name. Two minutes later I ask Siri again and she again points me to the other side of the world. She’s not learning anything and remains as frustrating to deal with.

I don’t know about Alexa or google Home as I don’t use those but Siri is not “behind” in terms of capabilities, she’s just not smart. By a long stretch.
I asked Siri :Give me directions to the nearest pizza shop." She responded "One option I see is Pizza Shop, witch is 4,200 miles from you." It was in a completely different country
 
  • Like
Reactions: ADudeInBoston
Sort of related, but I thought I would throw it in here.
We (especially my 5 year old son) do use the joke feature on our Google Home a fair bit. And the other day I tried something neat. I kept asking Google Assistant about Siri. "Do you like Siri?" "Is Siri a good assistant?" "What do you think of Siri?" Anyway, it was interesting how polite Google Assistant is about Siri, continually praising her, understanding "how busy she is" and "how being an assistant is a lot of work". I appreciated Google put the polite respect in there to such an extent. Apple probably did the same. In the end I was convinced they were great friends, and I felt kind of odd lying my iPhone down next to the Google Home last night. Half expected to have three devices in the morning!. (Bizarre world we live in).
 
Although pretty cool, these cheeky little things aren't going to sell me a Home Pod, Apple. And they're not going to make me want to re-enable Siri on my iPhone either. Ok maybe I'll test it out for a second and then disable again.
 
I'd prefer Siri without any sense of humor. For example, when I set a timer, just say "set", "ok" or "done" -- not one of half dozen semi-cute, long replies like "Roger that. T-minus 10 minutes and counting". The cute responses were fun for about 5 minutes back in 2011. Siri needs to get down to actual business, in all respects.
[doublepost=1523538732][/doublepost]
I asked Siri :Give me directions to the nearest pizza shop." She responded "One option I see is Pizza Shop, witch is 4,200 miles from you." It was in a completely different country

I just tried this (from the USA) and it also tried sending me to "Pizza Shop" --- in Europe. SMH
 
  • Like
Reactions: PG(Austin)
The user privacy canard doesn't explain why the voice recognition itself has gotten so bad. Like most of apples recent offerings this is form over function. If I were Tim Cook, I'd ban any new Siri fluff until it actually works.
[doublepost=1523539755][/doublepost]
I'd prefer Siri without any sense of humor. For example, when I set a timer, just say "set", "ok" or "done" -- not one of half dozen semi-cute, long replies like "Roger that. T-minus 10 minutes and counting". The cute responses were fun for about 5 minutes back in 2011. Siri needs to get down to actual business, in all respects.
[doublepost=1523538732][/doublepost]

I just tried this (from the USA) and it also tried sending me to "Pizza Shop" --- in Europe. SMH

Yes! Please give us a setting to turn off the 'personality'. Continent aware responses would also be helpful
 
That's great she knows more jokes a 7 year old would love but how about making her an actual personal assistant that WORKS instead of a personal joke teller?
[doublepost=1523541754][/doublepost]
OMG... I don't even know where to start. Good thing Alexa is so helpful (my use-case only, YMMV).

Google Assistant for the win. In fact, I tell SIRI to open Google Assistant. That seems to be the one thing she does well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rokkit
Siri’s cutesy responses are a thorn in my side. Nothing is more irritating than having an incompetent assistant who thinks his/her jokes will compensate for the blunders and inefficiency. And a cute comment doesn’t improve the more it’s repeated.
 
One problem apple has, compared the competition, is that they cannot make Siri smarter by using private data of the users. Apple’s privacy rules are. Incredibly potent.

Personally, I use Siri a lot and it works fine for me. In the light of Cambridge analytics / Facebook: I don’t think apple’s stance on privacy is bad at all.

I don't think it needs personal user info to get better. It already has my location if I'm asking for a business. And I'm asking Apple essentially, not a third party needing to access it. So my data is already there for Apple to see. Same with asking for information she will find online. This is not something that sharing my personal information is required, yet she gets it right about 30-40% of the time...and I'm being generous.

I'm good with them keeping my info safe, but SIRI could be so much better and in many areas not needing my personal info.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jdawgnoonan
Oh man this is awesome. I mean, it isn't like that they need to invest time elsewhere, like getting Siri to just handle my home automation like by Amazon Echo does, supporting continuity of subject across multiple requests, etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rokkit and 9081094
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.