The iOS 8 rollout is good in your opinion? It's ok if it is. Just asking.
I think it's a disaster. We're in agreement on that. I was just giving a good natured reminder that comparing software releases before, during and after Forstall's tenure doesn't really imply Forstall was the reason for the distinctions. I should have put an emoticon there to indicate a smile.
I'm trying to find a causal link between Forstall and iOS success/failure, and I'm hoping that one of the people who keep coming to his defense knows something about how he operated in the company-- because I don't. I'm not trying to be argumentative, just making sure I'm not selling Forstall short based on media reports when I shouldn't be. If he's the reason, there's something to learn here.
The problem with relying on correlation is you can fall victim to confounding variables. For example, there is significant overlap between changes in Forstall's influence and that of other prominent executives at Apple. He arrived with Jobs, for example, so was the transition from "before" Forstall to "during" Forstall because of Forstall or Jobs or some combination of other NeXT employees that tagged along.
Forstall didn't stay around past Job's death and the year in between included the Maps debacle. So was the transition from "during" Forstall to "after" Forstall because of Forstall, the loss of Jobs, the rise of Ive and Cook, general mourning and malaise within the company after losing Jobs, or some other combination of factors?
Is it all just a matter of iOS getting increasingly complicated and crufty, and therefore more difficult for anyone to manage and therefore caused by time and not people?
Did Forstall's departure make room for the critical QA manager to get promoted from their role leaving the job to a less qualified person-- meaning Forstall's presence didn't make the difference, but his departure started a series of events that led to iOS8?