Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

What do you think?

  • The suspension is fair.

    Votes: 1 3.3%
  • The suspension isn't nearly enough.

    Votes: 6 20.0%
  • A&M should be put onto probation and Manziel lose his eligibility.

    Votes: 5 16.7%
  • The NCAA needs to revise its rules.

    Votes: 7 23.3%
  • Who cares, all the teams in the SEC cheat.

    Votes: 11 36.7%

  • Total voters
    30
Sorry gang but I can't help but feel that no matter who is ranked where the true #1 Should be either 'Bama or Auburn.
And the true #2 should be either 'Bama or Auburn.

That said, I still think 'Bama is the best team in the nation.
 
Sorry gang but I can't help but feel that no matter who is ranked where the true #1 Should be either 'Bama or Auburn.
And the true #2 should be either 'Bama or Auburn.

That said, I still think 'Bama is the best team in the nation.

Who did Alabama beat to prove how they should be #1?
 
Auburn Fans

congratulations the better team won, which was Auburn..hope y'all win the SEC

and yes I am crying in my beer...ROLL TIDE!!!
 
It's rare, but Odell Beckham Jr. did it two months ago in the LSU-UAB game. The problem is that the FG team are a bunch of fat cows who can't run. Really only have to make a couple of guys miss. Kind of shocking it doesn't happen more frequently.

Ahh...you are correct. I don't follow much outside of my own team and a few games I might find interesting. But, while that is a possibility, the thought of being able to do that against Alabama is what I meant by "unheard of". Against UAB is another story.

The chances of making a 57 yard field goal are slim to none. Way too much can go wrong (bad snap, fumbled snap, blocked, etc.) to risk it.

Right...but 99.9% of those would result in nothing more than the clock running out after whatever happens and still going into overtime. The slim possibility that your kicker does make that field goal means you win. Of course, in this case, we found that the one second that Saban wanted back ended up being his downfall.
 
Anyone they beat from the SEC. Still the best conference.

That top five I keep seeing you guys list is full of paper tigers.

So, Alabama beating a 2-10 Kentucky team from the SEC proves it is the best team in the country? Oh, you must mean the 3-9 Arkansas team. And that victory over 5-7 Tennessee seals the deal.:rolleyes:
 
Anyone they beat from the SEC. Still the best conference.

That top five I keep seeing you guys list is full of paper tigers.

So, what you're saying is, there shouldn't be any competition then? We should just cut out the middle man and just randomly give an SEC team the championship, because, "still the best conference".
 
So, what you're saying is, there shouldn't be any competition then? We should just cut out the middle man and just randomly give an SEC team the championship, because, "still the best conference".


Not at all what I'm saying. Arkansas clearly sucks as do many other teams in the SEC. But, yeah, there are a lot of very good teams in the SEC. As many if not more than most conferences. Especially now that we keep getting new, good, teams to join.

I am saying that Alabama, in my opinion, is still the best team in the nation.

Auburn is very good too though. As is tOSU, FSU etc etc. But I still think if they were to play 'Bama in the title game they would lose.

That said, I'd love to see someone else win the title. And it looks like this year there is a very good chance of that happening.

----------

So, Alabama beating a 2-10 Kentucky team from the SEC proves it is the best team in the country? Oh, you must mean the 3-9 Arkansas team. And that victory over 5-7 Tennessee seals the deal.:rolleyes:

HA! read the above.
 
Not at all what I'm saying. Arkansas clearly sucks as do many other teams in the SEC. But, yeah, there are a lot of very good teams in the SEC. As many if not more than most conferences. Especially now that we keep getting new, good, teams to join.

I am saying that Alabama, in my opinion, is still the best team in the nation.

Auburn is very good too though. As is tOSU, FSU etc etc. But I still think if they were to play 'Bama in the title game they would lose.

That said, I'd love to see someone else win the title. And it looks like this year there is a very good chance of that happening.

----------



HA! read the above.

The experts agreed with you going into the Auburn game, most giving it to the Tide 35-21.

And we saw how well the Tide did vs a team everyone thought would have been a walk. Hell, historically the Tide had outscored the Tigers 90-14, and yet, here we are.

tOSU faced a Northwestern that's shockingly creeping into the top 10, a still top 25 Wisconsin. If they beat MSU in the Big 10 championship, they'll have a victory vs a Top 10 team.

FSU has 2 top 10 victories (do we really want to count the win vs Maryland as a big win?). They get the style points for running the board vs teams like Idaho, and sadly, those still count, I mean, that's why Baylor's name kept being bandied around.

Auburn has 2 top 25 wins, one against a mediocre Georgia team, and one against the All-Mighty Alabama (a game, like I said, the experts had winning by at least 2 TDs).

Then we have the mighty Alabama, who, to be honest, played no one of any particular strength, and lost a game due to some seriously sloppy play. Barely beating an unranked Mississippi St doesn't help their cause.

I am amused at how many people called tOSU's schedule a cake walk, but if you look at the top 10, non of them had strong schedules. They all had close calls, and near misses, to be honest, the only reason why tOSU and FSU are the top 2, is because of the big zero in the loss category. I know SEC fans fap to their dominance, and think that they deserve to be #1 and 2 still, the coaches, writers and computer seem to disagree. I mean, look at the numbers, tOSU is almost a full .1 higher than Alabama, and almost splitting the difference between the Seminoles and Tigers.

Fun bit of trivia, several of tOSU's 2014 verbal commitments have been getting unsolicited calls from Nick Saban, personally, to get them to jump to Alabama. Including St Ignatius linebacker Kyle Berger. Think someone's scared that Urban Meyer is finally at a school with the money and recruiting power to let him build the team he wants?
 
Take note: I've never said tOSU had a cake walk. I do believe they are very, very good.

But as someone who lives in the south watching 'Bama roll people up week after week after week... Just have a feeling about them. Don't get me wrong, their['Bama] schedule includes patsies too!

Seen tOSU play quite a bit this season too...


'Bama lost last year as well to Texas A&M. Fortunately for them they did it at the right time.

Of course, losing late and to Auburn is what unhinged their SEC title hopes and possibly their National title hopes as well.
I just don't think Auburn can pull that kind of win off again. But we will see.

And let's face it, Auburn won on a fluke play. 'Bama made a decision to kick the ball when they knew the odds of their kicking being able to kick the ball that far weren't very good.

And,yes, Auburn is good and that was a great game. I would have preferred them go to OT to finish it though.
 
Last edited:
Predictions for tomorrow's games?

I'm going with:

  • Oklahoma St over OU
  • Baylor over UTex
  • Auburn over Missouri
  • Stanford over Arizona State
  • Florida St over Duke
  • Michigan St over Ohio St

I agree but I'm thinking Missouri over Auburn. I have a feeling that Auburn's luck finally decides to go out. I have a feeling some higher power wants to see a SEC team in the BCS title game and make Ohio St. the casualty :)

(If this does happen, I can't wait to see how everyone is going to react with a SEC team in the title game. This is what I like about watching college ball, everyone is so opinionated!)
 
I agree but I'm thinking Missouri over Auburn. I have a feeling that Auburn's luck finally decides to go out. I have a feeling some higher power wants to see a SEC team in the BCS title game and make Ohio St. the casualty :)

(If this does happen, I can't wait to see how everyone is going to react with a SEC team in the title game. This is what I like about watching college ball, everyone is so opinionated!)

I'm hoping that both Florida State and Ohio State win so the SEC is locked out of the title game.
 
Northern Illinois and Jordan Lynch were completely exposed. Glad BCS bid doesn't get wasted on an NIU team that has never deserved it.
 
I'm hoping that both Florida State and Ohio State win so the SEC is locked out of the title game.

Agreed.

I agree but I'm thinking Missouri over Auburn. I have a feeling that Auburn's luck finally decides to go out. I have a feeling some higher power wants to see a SEC team in the BCS title game and make Ohio St. the casualty :)

(If this does happen, I can't wait to see how everyone is going to react with a SEC team in the title game. This is what I like about watching college ball, everyone is so opinionated!)

I'll take Mizzou too. If Mizzou didn't have Franklin back I'd probably give it to a coin flip or for Auburn.
 
I'm hoping that both Florida State and Ohio State win so the SEC is locked out of the title game.

I want to see the SEC get in, but get beaten. I have a hard time accepting a national champion that doesn't beat the best of the best conference.

Hate much?


Even though I live in the South I am not a "SEC for life" type goon but I feel it really is the best conference. Although maybe not so far ahead now as they were in years past.

Alabama getting bounced really has leveled the playing field.

As for someone else winning it... it would be fine with me too. But the teams I'd really want to win aren't that good anyway. Stanford winning would be awesome and completely unlikely, ASU would be fantastic and unrealistic.

tOSU is the most likely imo. And that would be be fine with me.

Mizzou and or Auburn winning it all would be fine. I think Auburn will that game. Rooting for Mizzou though.

FSU or anyone* else in the list winning would be fine with me too... and I have to say that anyone from that list would be a lesser champ. MSU* the only exception because they would have beaten tOSU.


p.s. Us posting about it, discussing it, maybe even arguing about it.. that is the way it should be, again, just my opinion. I don't care for the BCS play off stuff. I like the speculation and debate.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.