Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is anyone able to provide a portrait keyboard comparison between the Plus and X? My prime concern is that the loss of width will make typing more difficult.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5105973
Doesn't bother me at all. The X is beautiful imo.
Yup....beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
Screen-Shot-2017-09-12-at-23.25.56.png
 
At this point there is simply too much wasted space. The virtual home button/line does not need that much dedicated space on the bottom.

The 5.8 inch X basically has a 5 inch screen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lancastor
It sort of seems that way, doesn't it? It makes you wonder what we are going see next year. Will the design change at all? Will we see a larger version of the iPhone X? Most likely, for the latter.

IF there is any sort of drastic design change next year based on the design of the X, current X buyers are gonna feel shafted. Doubt that's going to happen by next year though.

I won't feel shafted. I get a new phone every year anyway.
 
I find it amusing that people who berated the plus’s bezels are the same people praising the notch and squished up/chopped off content of the X.

It's not the people like the bezels it's just they feel Apple could have done a better job with the X. Apple is telling developers not the black out the "ears" the the left and right and to embrace the notch. It would look so much better if they had done that. One thing I don't like is the rounded corners on the screen. It's yet another thing that cuts into the real estate of the screen, especially with the ears which barely have room for the status icons as it is.
 
I love the feel the x has, like it ius always in full screen, I'm dying to get my hands on one.

Regarding status bar in landscape, can't we have a vertical status bar that still goes in the ears to the left instead of the top, when in portrait? Like when the phone is in landscape, the icons and date don't move, just turn 45 degrees in their same positions, given the ears have plenty of height space.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hush17
Now that the 8 is out of my consideration set, I have to focus on the X….as with most things in life, I reckon one can get used to the notch until
it's barely noticeable.
 
I only use my 6 Plus in landscape for watching videos, using the camera, and the occasional game, because I think it looks ridiculous on many apps (Safari especially). Even without the notch, you'd want the bigger left and right margins in landscape on the X to keep it from looking ridiculously wide. As far as portrait goes, it seems to compare pretty well with the Plus? Not really sure what the big deal is.
Really??
The 8 comparison looks like almost the same size!
The + real estate is quite bigger!
 
  • Like
Reactions: lancastor
Looks like an upgrade from the 4.7 inch iPhones for people who don't want the size of 5.5 inch iPhones
Exactly. Many Plus owners are understandably not interested as they obviously don't mind having a larger form factor & want the biggest screen screen possible. It'd only be the minority Plus owners who regret buying into a larger form factor & who don't mind a slight decrease in screen size that'll want the X.

But yeah, the X is more for those using non-plus models, so long as they don't mind the slight evolution in user interface.
 
The 4.7" iPhone and iPhone X share roughly the same width as each other.

Not physically.

The X is wider. They are only the same virtual width in that they have the same number of UI points across the screen. But because the X is physically lager, UI elements will appear slightly larger.

One other thing that is getting no mention: the resolution! The X may have the same virtual width as the 7 and 8, but it will be the first iPhone to support 3x assets at native resolution! It will look much sharper and much finer detail compared to all other iPhone models.
 
The X looks fantastic. Maximising screen real estate without oversizing the phone. The 'notch' is an irrelevance - the technology has to go somewhere.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DNichter
I cannot understand how they claim the X screen is larger than the + ..
You watch them side by side and the + definitely looks bigger.
Only when i’ll hold i’ll figure it out.
Maybe i could live with the x weird ratio.
Why couldn’t they made also a bigger X?
Or at least match the same width of the +?
 
  • Like
Reactions: dtdt123 and ABC5S
I think the people who were always complaining about the bezels are the same people who used to complain about movies on DVD not filling the entire screen of their old 4:3 TV. And the iPhone X is the same flawed solution to an imagined problem like the Pan&Scan versions of movies were, which cut off the sides of the movies just to give the people their "full screen" experience. I hope that when people actually get their devices and realize what a compromised experience it provides, the outcry will change Apple's mind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eelpout and roeiz
Now that the 8 is out of my consideration set, I have to focus on the X….as with most things in life, I reckon one can get used to the notch until
it's barely noticeable.
It's barely "notch"able? ;)
[doublepost=1506164952][/doublepost]
Only if all your contacts have short names. What about if you know Hubert Blaine Wolfeschlegelsteinhausenbergerdorff?
Apple HCI guidelines suggest auto layouts that use 'safe areas' with margins. Have a look at 4.53min of their video for developers here.
 
I dont get it you...
The iphone x is and will be the edge to edge display for the iphone 6-8 with 30%more area, and next year iphone plus 6.5” probably,will be the edge to edge of the current plus models, and will have the same plus UI
 
As someone who uses their phone 99% of the time (outside of shooting videos) in portrait mode, these screenshots just confirmed I will like the x.
 
Yes in portait mode the 5.8 will be ideal, and the next year 6.5” will come with ,hoping some ipad landscape mode,like today dock summon etc
 
Kudos to the OP for providing those images because they do a really good job of contrasting the differences between devices.

I just wanted to point out that there are only four apps shown, of which, are developed by the Apple team, thus they have had literally months to years (depending on how long this has been in the works) to perfect them.
  1. Safari
  2. Calendar
  3. iMessage
  4. News
Personally, it’s not Apple’s own software that I’m concerned about, nor the 20% of the big name companies i.e. Google, Facebook, Snapchat. It’s the 80% of other developers that have to modify their preexisting/future applications to accommodate the rounded corners and ‘notch’ of one new device.

Edit: Fixed Kudos from Kudus.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.