Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Refusing to be brainwashed = you're being brainwashed by somebody else.

Nope. Just speaking on behalf of my own experiences. My last three models of iPhones never had this problem. Go drink some more stevejuice.
 
And touching the iPhone with one finger doesn't drop all signal. Do you even own the iPhone 4? I'm touching mine right now and it works.

"touching the iphone with one finger doesn't drop all signal" is not a true statement. Perhaps it doesn't for you, but it did for me.
 
Its amazing how consumer reports never picked up on any of the other glitches. I think this will tarnish their record as a fair product review publisher. The only reason why they review the iphone problem is because of the publicity it was getting, they saw an opportunity to jump on the ban wagon, and get publicity themselves to be seen as a up to date magazine. They should review every product including all smartphones the same way rather then singling one out. They should retract their comments about the iphone.
 
Why should Consumer Reports change their stance..... Apple didn't fix shiate.....iPhone is still s*h*i*t*t*y for people who have the problem, glad mine works flawlessly. No dropped calls yet :apple:

Do you realise how utterly moronic your comment is?
 
Thank god someone out there has the balls to stand up for something when it doesn't work as it should. My respect for Consumer Reports just went way up.
 
If Steve's little dog and pony show of cherry-picked statistics and a bumper case can stave off a recall costing hundreds of millions of dollars, then of course it's in Apple's interest to try.

I'm an Apple fanboy, Steve Jobs is my guru, and I love my iPhone 4. I'm not giving it up and I'm not hiding its elegant design inside an ugly piece of rubber.

I also just bought a new Toyota, a company which didn't have a masterfully communicative CEO to talk everyone out of recalls, even in the absence of any data whatsoever that there was a problem. To this day, Toyota never found a problem.

People freak out easily and the press fans the flames to get attention. This crap has been going on for a while now.

Recalls are typically done for safety issues, or when a product simply fails rather completely in a key area. A small loss of signal strength is not recall-worthy.

I subscribe to Consumer Reports. I trust them. They are nonprofit and they go out of their way to be unbiased. They don't recommend the iPhone 4 at this time. I have no problem with that. I need them to be conservative in their recommendations to balance against the hype coming out of company promotions of products. They rated the Jeep Wrangler at the bottom of their list and I bought one anyway and loved it. They were right, it was a horrible car in almost every way. But I still loved it.

I respect Apple. I trust Consumer Reports. And I love my iPhone 4, bar none. Well, maybe not bar none. I'll settle for at least one.

So as my Toyota blindly accelerates me to my doom as I death-grip my iPhone 4 and I lose the call wih grandma in my last seconds of life, I just want everyone to know that I died happy.

Hey partner! Well I don't own a Toyota but as far as the rest of your post goes I agree with you.
 
Con$umer Report$... Payola$ Anyone?

F**kers probably got paid by Android. :rolleyes:
I don't have any issues with signal... And I haven't had a dropped call since I got my iPhone 4...

Now, the proximity sensor problem really annoys me...:mad:
 
F**kers probably got paid by Android. :rolleyes:
I don't have any issues with signal... And I haven't had a dropped call since I got my iPhone 4...

Now, the proximity sensor problem really annoys me...:mad:

There is no issue with the proximity sensor, your cheeks are too chubby. Go get some plastic surgery and that will resolve the issue. :rolleyes:
 
Second, show me one of these videos where touching, with ONE FINGER, the entire phone drops all signal and calls cease to function, as well as stopping data transfers?

as somebody noticed, if you put ONE FINGER between TV and your remote
nothing will work, don't put your finger to the week spot, that's all

even worse, put only 1 finger into someone eye, that someone will lose his/her eye :eek:

there are many amazing things that ONE FINGER can do :rolleyes:
 
Duct Tape

Perhaps Apple should offer duct tape as one of the case remedies to appease Consumer Reports.
 

Attachments

  • duct-tape.jpg
    duct-tape.jpg
    23.4 KB · Views: 146
Which other phone loses 20dB when you hold it in your hand?

BTW, now we know why Apple decided to "re-calibrate" signal bar (as if they did not know how they worked before). They needed it to look better in terms of dropped bars compared to other phones during today's dog and pony show :D
 
Am I the only one that is getting REALLY tired with all the blind fanboys that spew nothing but garbage? Most forums are ok with people stating their opinion but just look at those youtube comments!
I dont really get the binarity of their statements, if I dislike a product I can usualy find a couple of good points about it.

The thing is, NO-ONE would use the same language and have the same anger about it if the where debating face to face, so why do it online?

Maybe it's time to enforce personal responsibility online to mellow stuff out, imagine a troll free internet because ppl would be personally accountable for what they do.
 
I hate when people come to a Mac forum and complain about Mac fanboys. It's a bit ridiculous.
 
Apple is investing 100million dollar for echiong chambers and mess the iphone4 up? Come on CR, Apple is not stupid!

Yes, they obviously are.

Apple would never bring a phone to the market if there where an issue, i think the main problem is that like jobs said x-marks the spot. and every tech blog crys.

Yes, obviously did.

Did anyone catch Jobs slip up during the PC, that part about them not sitting on their asses for 3 months. I bet if one could access their bumper order, one would find that it was placed 2 months prior to launch.
 
BTW, now we know why Apple decided to "re-calibrate" signal bar (as if they did not know how they worked before). They needed it to look better in terms of dropped bars compared to other phones during today's dog and pony show :D

Actually the funny thing is that Jobs was asked why they "fixed" the wrong bar algorithm again after it has already been "fixed" when the 3GS was introduced (the "fix" was that more bars were being displayed....). Jobs answered that he can't remember what the 3GS bar fix was.... Yeah sure. :D
 
Good for Consumer Reports. The bumper is nothing but a band-aid. I don't/didn't need a bumper or a case for my 3GS, 3G, 2G. Why for the iPhone 4?

I think Apple's point is that you don't need one for the iPhone 4 either, but if a bumper makes you feel better they will give you one. I get the impression that Apple thinks the whole affair is BS an overblown. They made a trade off for better performance and they are sticking by it.
 
After being a 5 year subscriber to Consumer Report I have cancelled my subscription. The lady asked me why, and I told her because of the stupid report you guys did regarding the iPhone 4 without having data and not knowing that other smartphone has the same problem.

She told me I wasn't the first to cancel.
 
as somebody noticed, if you put ONE FINGER between TV and your remote
nothing will work, don't put your finger to the week spot, that's all

even worse, put only 1 finger into someone eye, that someone will lose his/her eye :eek:

there are many amazing things that ONE FINGER can do :rolleyes:

Up:D
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.