Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I'll tell you one thing, whilst I won't be buying this iPhone, I AM looking forward to seeing how all this plays out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ges
How does Face ID work for people who wear burkas?

Are you seriously asking this question or trying to incite something here?

While you are at it, how about asking:

How does Face ID work for people whose faces are severely mutilated in fires and wars?

I truly doubt the spirit of your post.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moccasin
I'm curious to see how it will manage facial recognition for users wearing sometimes contact lenses and sometimes glasses (like me).

Another issue is, as someone already told in the past days, when your face is partially covered, like skiers. To be honest, TouchID is already a weak point with gloves in winter time.

As I understand it, the phone will likely make a 3D map of your face with the IR camera. To unlock, the phone will match its 3D map with whatever face it’s seeing & unlock if sufficient points match. Since glasses don’t generally obscure much of your face - leaving your facial shape, cheeks, chin, mouth & nose visible - I don’t see them as an issue.

Like TouchID, the phone will only store the 3D map in its secure enclave & submit an authorisation token to apps or to payment terminals containing no personal data.

Also, like with Touch ID, if your fingers are obscured by gloves, by grease, water etc FaceID may not work with masks/balaclavas/false noses & those who regularly wear these when using their phone may have to remove them briefly to unlock their phones - or they could use the passcode.
 
Won't work. It would need to detect facial movements which FaceID will cover.

So you will need to smile or wink at your phone to unlock it :)

Going to be an interesting keynote, though that is just markerting, it's when it gets into end user hands we will see good feedback
[doublepost=1505033747][/doublepost]
Are you seriously asking this question or trying to incite something here?

While you are at it, how about asking:

How does Face ID work for people whose faces are severely mutilated in fires and wars?

I truly doubt the spirit of your post.

Actually it's not that.

The question is, can it unlock just by using your eyes. It's actually a very valid use case.

Wearing a burka is completely unrelated to facial injuries.

When I owned the S8, I remember that you could unlock with your eyes, designers take into consideration cultural use case scenarios
[doublepost=1505034355][/doublepost]
There should be infrared light (not visible to human eyes) to illuminate the face on dark situations. As for people getting on board with this...... you surely mean the people who were not willing to scan their fingers and use the touch ID years ago (who also were willing to protest)? Sure, of course I get it.

Touchid is actually much more intrusive , in relation to handing over your details. At this stage , as long as you have a photo Id of some sort, you have already given over your details for facial recognition.

Though yeah, people will make an issue of it. Next time people travel and have thier passport next to their iPhone X.... you gave away your details a long time ago
 
  • Like
Reactions: nextuser
There should be infrared light (not visible to human eyes) to illuminate the face on dark situations. As for people not getting on board with this...... you surely mean the people who were not willing to scan their fingers and use the touch ID years ago (who also were willing to protest)? Sure, of course I get it.

Do you whole heatedly think facial recognition to this degree is going to be secure?
 
Do you whole heatedly think facial recognition to this degree is going to be secure?

Yes otherwise Apple wouldn't do it if they didn't believe it was secure. Just because other devices like the Note 8 use facial recognition doesn't mean Apple's version will be the same, for a start it will use 3D rather than 2D (which is why the Note 8, S8 and other devices can be fooled by simple pictures).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moccasin
Do you whole heatedly think facial recognition to this degree is going to be secure?

The information coming through in terms of how the system is expected to work suggests that, yes it will be that secure.

By making a 3D map of your face - hence why you need to rotate your head during set up - the system will be able to determine facial structure & check that the pre-determined number of points match. It’s not relying on eyes & it’s not recognising a picture of your face, it’s matching shape of your mouth, nose, cheeks etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave245
The information coming through in terms of how the system is expected to work suggests that, yes it will be that secure.

By making a 3D map of your face - hence why you need to rotate your head during set up - the system will be able to determine facial structure & check that the pre-determined number of points match. It’s not relying on eyes & it’s not recognising a picture of your face, it’s matching shape of your mouth, nose, cheeks etc.

Also the phone knows when you are looking at it, which could for example mean that if someone else picks up your phone it will lock itself or ask you to verify. Not saying it will that's just a possibility, according to the leaks the display knows when you are looking at it and won't dim the display (like it does now after a few seconds). This tells me that Face ID works in the background as well.

This is directly from 9to5 Mac:

Interesting to note is that the Face ID setup mentions being aware of when a user is looking at the phone. This falls in-line with previous discoveries:

Attention is detected when you are looking at the screen. When attention is detected, iPhone does not dim the display.

https://9to5mac.com/2017/09/08/how-setting-up-face-id-iphone-8-will-work/
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moccasin
Do you whole heatedly think facial recognition to this degree is going to be secure?

All I am saying is that at this point we will have to wait and see, but I tend to trust more Apple then bunch of people in this forum who jump on their silly conclusions before this feature have been revealed/explained. Like it always is the case with people in this forum.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Moccasin
Sounds like you can do more than one facial expression which will help a lot when it comes to maybe in the dark or on a table maybe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dave245
So, this GM can be run on a iPhone 7s and use FaceID?

The GM stands for Gold Master and it's IOS 11 code inside the code are features for the next iPhone's , the code was leaked early and some very clever people (from 9to5 Mac) have dug inside it and found features, the Face ID feature can't work on the iPhone 7 or anything other than the X because that's the only device that will have "Face ID" but this video shows the features that will work on the iPhone X.
 
The GM stands for Gold Master and it's IOS 11 code inside the code are features for the next iPhone's , the code was leaked early and some very clever people (from 9to5 Mac) have dug inside it and found features, the Face ID feature can't work on the iPhone 7 or anything other than the X because that's the only device that will have "Face ID" but this video shows the features that will work on the iPhone X.

So he fabricated this video?

What I mean is, If he is Using FaceID for real in the video... How could he without a iPhoneX and the correct sensors. So either it runs on a 7S or he has completely fabcricated the video so it LOOKS like how FaceID works..?!?
 
Makes you wonder.....................

Just How is this going to work?

face recognition.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: nextuser
So he fabricated this video?

What I mean is, If he is Using FaceID for real in the video... How could he without a iPhoneX and the correct sensors. So either it runs on a 7S or he has completely fabcricated the video so it LOOKS like how FaceID works..?!?

No, it's all about the code he's installed the leaked GM on his current phone, Face ID won't work on any other device accept the iPhone X because it's the only one to have the Facial recognition system. It's only the animation it doesn't actually work on his device!

http://appleinsider.com/articles/17...11-gold-master-reveal-face-id-setup-animation
 
You should, there’s animation of fingerprint being scan to show whether the payment goes thru or not. People are making way too many obscure excuses to make Face ID a step back method. When I use Apple Pay sometimes it doesn’t go thru because of my sweaty fingers. Face ID should be a lot more convenient for me.

I really don’t. I know if it’s active or not when I pass through the barriers when I use it most. My face isn’t near the phone and sometimes I have it face down.

I tend not to have sweaty fingers when I use it, so I don’t have that problem.
 
Apple is solving a problem that is *going* to exist.

Touch ID requires a prompt and an action by the user. That’s ok for today’s use. But future applications (such as augmented reality) will require constant authentication to ensure security. Frequently pestering you to verify who you are is neither practical, nor desirable.

Face ID will always know that you’re the authorized person to be using your phone and won’t have to keep asking you to verify that you are. Face ID is passive authentication. It doesn’t require your intervention, yet maintains constant security.

Apple is skating to where there puck will be. People who say that Touch ID is fine, aren’t thinking long term.

As for claiming that Face ID is less secure, it’s just the opposite. It significantly increases security. Touch ID unlocks a door, after which anybody can walk through and browse the supposedly secure room. Face ID on the other hand is a security guard who is constantly checking that the person inside the room is supposed to be there. It moves the security threshold from only having secure checkpoints to constant security.

Not sure how you've reached the conclusion that AR requires constant authentication. It won't be constantly checking authentication either unless Apple is shipping a phone with 2 hour battery life.

That’s the difference between the people who work at Apple and the people who criticise Apple here.

The folks working tirelessly at Apple to implement these features will likely have thought of the same scenarios we have, but the difference is that they will then go on to come up with solutions to resolve those issues in one way or another. I too remember the crap storm this forum had when rumours of the 5s having a fingerprint sensor broke. TL; DR - none of the arguments held water.

Meanwhile, the critics here use these myriad of “what if” scenarios to anchor criticism and use them as proof of why something shouldn’t be done. It’s neither constructive nor productive.

I believe that come next week, Apple will answer all our concerns with regards to face ID and we will wonder how these conversations even happened in the first place.

Well not really. Time will prove how secure it is. We aren't going to learn that from an Apple Keynote.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.