Butthead said:
LOL, I guess AV didn't read my prior posts. Current & past DVD drives in various Apple products have not worked 100%. The Panasonic drives in recent Apple laptops don't work well, have problems writing to certain brands of DVD's; aren't even recognized at all, with some,
Of course there's problems, never said there wasn't. All I was saying is that many PC vendors are waiting for these drives to actually be somewhat reliable. Currently they're too unreliable and too expensive to even be considered as an optional component. My guess is that Apple is waiting too.. And they will probably continue to wait for better drive options and for their software updates to support them.
Butthead said:
software, if you had been to any of the lafcpug.org meetings, been to one of the HiDef film-festivals with roundtable discussion with the filmmakers & DP's- you'd know that FCP 3 sucked in a lot of ways.
I can't comment on FCP 3 -- never owned/used it until FCP 5. As for 5, works just fine, no complaints. Did everything I needed right from the start except I had to figure a few work arounds for 1080p24, which is now supported just fine as well. For video work, I switched from using Vegas, Fusion, Ecncore, Acid and AE over to Final Cut Studio, Shake. The only app I miss is Acid, but I still use it now and then, it's not like I threw it away. I had to go to a different software solution because of the HVX200 camera and I was sick of dealing with the hodgepodge worklfow I had. I demoed plenty of solutions, including various offerings from Avid. The only software on the PC I considered in the end was Edius Pro as it has the best support for MXF and great DVCPROHD performance, but it just lacked a lot of features I needed and didn't solve the hodgepodge problem. Since then, other PC solutions have come to light, but I'm happy with the current solution, especially given the price. If I were a big-time DP or producer, I would go for one of the larger Avid solutions, but I've got other things to spend my money on since video is only a portion of what I do.
Butthead said:
currently only making a tray loader for their laptop (uh, did you not read my prior post links on Blu-Ray???). Panasonic has shown a prototype Blu-Ray slot load drive made for laptops, that would be the most likely one to be included in a MBP, whenever it becomes available. End of story.
Yeah, I did read your links... They were either outdated news or product announcments, nothing much to do with what the situation is right now. Who cares if Panasonic has shown a slot-load, slimline prototype... So has Sony, Pioneer and Samsung. Actually, the Samsung slot-loader will hit the market first, but I'll believe it when I see it. None of them will be capable of writing dual-layer media in this first generation. The current Sony tray-load drive they're using in their Vaio notebooks tends to burns more coasters than any other optical drive in history, and not just BD media, but DVD media as well... I've known two people to buy these systems and I've seen enough forum complaints to steer me away for now. Of the two people I know who bought one when they first released, one could never get a BD disc to write, Sony replaced the drive once and then replaced the entire notebook and still no luck. So he sent it back. The other's system wouldn't write BD or DVD discs and wouldn't play BluRay movie titles back properly. Sony swapped out the system for him and the burner appears to work just fine. Actually Sony was pretty cool and gave him a 10 pack of BD media for free with the swap, customer service told him that their return rate on the notebooks with the BluRay super multi drive is about 50%. Other than Sony championing their own product, what system vendor would want to deal with that?
I'm not anti-BluRay or anything, but so far the whole BluRay "launch" is a complete joke. In the end, I'm sure it will win the format "war", but the hardware just isn't ready for prime time yet.
Butthead said:
Newegg has the desktop burners @$699[/url], expensive as all new products will be until economy of scale catches up (anyone remember how much the original DVD burners in the Apple desktops cost...almost the same as what Blu-Ray are going for now), which could be less than a year. Original DVD-burners dropped precipitously in price in the 1st year, same will happen with Blu-Ray. On a laptop, initially it would probably add not much more, than a $300-500 option.
Yeah, they will drop in price as demand increases. I just can't believe the amount of problems that BluRay is experiencing. The product launch is a disaster and it seems to be affecting every BluRay device manufacturer... None seem to be able to release players that were originally supposed to be released last spring/early summer. Samsung pushes a complete turd onto the market and has yet to offer up a fix or a revised model. The Sony burners are plagued with AACS issues that they can't seem to resolve, even with the recent firmware update to the dual-layer burner. The slimline notebook burner has QC issues that would make any OEM customer run away screaming.
FWIW, Toshiba isn't doing much better with HD-DVD... And to top it all off, they're now becoming arrogant and over confident in light of BluRay's continued stumbling. The next round of players are being dumbed-down from the current HD-[X]A1. The [X]A2 update actually removes features from the A2 and leaves the MSRP at $499 while the XA2 gains HDMI 1.3, 1080P output and some other goodies, but they push the MSRP all the way up to $1099. But at the rate BluRay is going, Toshiba will have second generation players on the market before Sony ships the BDP-S1, which is now on indefinite hiatus.
Sorry to go off-tangent, but it's really hard to get excited over BluRay and HD-DVD right now with the state of the industry.
Butthead said:
One thing for sure, this thread is rehashing everything over and over to the tune of nearly 100-posts/day, if they don't come out with a simple speed bump a la iMac with just the C2D, then by the end of November this thread my well be the longest ever on MR
Yep....
And we start all over again for this week beginning tomorrow. After all tomorrow (oh, wait, it's midnight Cupertino time), so I mean today is yet another disappointing Tuesday.