Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Same here. People are way too much of fanboys here. But in reality you’ll probably get better quality speakers for less going with a competitor. But saying that here is blasphemous lol.

Hmmm I was to buy Zeppelin but will wait for the review. I dont want any Google/Amzon people listening to me so I will never buy any of their products. I am trying my best to limit use of their services to minimum.
Again I dont care about Siri either, but if that speaker sounds really good and could be used as lets say surround system with airplay 2 I will buy.
Sonos requires to use their app. And thats a big no no for me. Have you read their privacy policy?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Agent2015

Would you consider that an objective review from an objective source? Personally, I'm awaiting reviews from audio review sites not thoroughly married to the Apple ecosystem (nor necessarily mostly obligated by business motivations to stay on Apple's good side). I won't say that's absolutely a biased review- just wanting to see reviews from sources that appear more likely to be objective.

As soon as these are in the wild, sources way outside of Apple's general bubble will be able to buy one and review it without any potential bias. That's the best chance at real, objective reviews. Those given early access to units are hand-picked by Apple to get that early access. If any of them really pound away at this product, do they get hand-picked again by Apple for any future pre-releases?
 
Last edited:
Nope. This is very limited. Can't even be a BT speaker. Can't use as a speaker from Mac. Apple TV can't use it. Can't be turned into a sound system with more of them. The integration kind of blows.

This is basically apple music on a speaker with a bit of siri thrown in...tied to one icloud acct so screw the rest of the household.

What? I've hardly given any praise to HomePod here but this is B.S. disinformation. ATV can hookup to any Airplay speaker. Same with a Mac. It has BT 5.0 so where are you getting it can't be used as a BT speaker? It's not any different than AirPods in that regard.
 
Yes. You can stream anything from your iPhone, iPad, AppleTV or Mac using Airplay.

The difference or huge difference is Airplay 2 won’t interrupt your streaming when your iPhone rings or you get a text message. Now hoping FaceTime gets its badly needed update for multiple live chats, broader API access and quality.
 
Would you consider that an objective review from an objective source? Personally, I'm awaiting reviews from audio review sites not thoroughly married to the Apple ecosystem (nor necessarily mostly obligated by business motivations to stay on Apple's good side). I won't say that's absolutely a biased review- just wanting to see reviews from sources that appear more likely to be objective.

Why wait, buy, experience it and if you don’t like it return it. That would be the most objective review.
 
Don't forget sales tax unless you live in a no sales tax state. Out the door it's more like $370-380. Without any reviews seems pricey. I would love to see some reviews by known audio reviewers who know how to properly put speakers though their paces. All the reviews I've seen so far are by tech, not audio people, and seemingly under severe time conditions.

Or... Purchase one and make your own evaluation in your particular listening environment over a 14 day period. Don't like it? Send it back.
 
I read that it’s designed for Apple Music only, meaning that if you use Spotify you won’t have the same seamless experience of voice control, etc. Since I use Spotify and I think this is way overpriced, I’ll pass for now.

It's worse than that. I can kinda understand Apple waiting to roll out (or open up to) Spotify. But Siri HomePod won't even respond to my personal library via iTunes on my Mac. I doubt it's a tech issue since Siri now can play my music on my Mac and iDevices. That means Apple is intentionally gimping Siri on the HomePod to benefit Apple Music. With that I'm not even piqued to give it a try since it would literally just be a $370 Homekit microphone for me.
 
Would you consider that an objective review from an objective source? Personally, I'm awaiting reviews from audio review sites not thoroughly married to the Apple ecosystem (nor necessarily mostly obligated by business motivations to stay on Apple's good side). I won't say that's absolutely a biased review- just wanting to see reviews from sources that appear more likely to be objective.

Understood.
But 9 to 5 isn’t too biased towards Apple.

Anyway, I have a feeling that HomePod will do well in reviews from Audio sites, if they aren’t too biased in favor of 10,000.00 speakers
 
I got one in Space Gray. Hope to eventually buy a second one and use them to pair with my AppleTV 4K for watching TV and Movies with better sound. We will see. Especially if you can then control the volume with the AppleTV remote.
 
Would be interested at 199.

$349 is ridiculous.

You can get a Sonos for $200

Not saying this as an across the board Apple fanboy, but probably like with Air Pods when they get out in the wild it will be determined it is worth the price. It will probably also cause competitors to up their standards and their price for a comparative experience will go up too.

If nothing else I'm sure it will blow the sound quality of Amazon's and Google's competitor products out of the water.
 
It's worse than that. I can kinda understand Apple waiting to roll out (or open up to) Spotify. But Siri HomePod won't even respond to my personal library via iTunes on my Mac. I doubt it's a tech issue since Siri now can play my music on my Mac and iDevices. That means Apple is intentionally gimping Siri on the HomePod to benefit Apple Music. With that I'm not even piqued to give it a try since it would literally just be a $370 Homekit microphone for me.

you know if you upload that library to iCloud music library FOR FREE then HomePod will be able to play it using voice command ???
 
Why wait, buy, experience it and if you don’t like it return it. That would be the most objective review.

That certainly works too. For me personally, I don't like the trouble of blind faith buying anything and then potentially having to pack it back up and return it... when I can just be a little patient, read some objective reviews and then decide if I want to make a final review myself, in my own home, listening to my own sources of audio. In short: I don't burn at all to be "first", to potentially win the first "unboxing" thread, etc. This doesn't make or break my life if I get it first day or 50th day or 500th day.

I do NOT have an AM subscription- much prefer the alternative myself (which works fine on all my other Apple stuff but apparently not this thing unless we go the airplay route). I've accumulated thousands of songs in my iTunes library the "old fashioned" (ripped from my CD collection) way, and there is a fairly strong belief that this thing may ONLY be able to see iTunes music via AM or ONLY purchased from iTunes (CD rips excluded). If that's true (and I can't hardly believe Apple would do that... and yet, all this time later and Siri on :apple:TV still can't "see" my locally-stored video rips- only the videos purchased or rentable/buyable from the iTunes store), I'd have almost NO use for this product myself. Wait for reviews and someone is going to confirm or refute that one with certainty.

Some are wondering if the one-time "Match" option might overcome this issue too, though "Match" won't actually match up to everything ripped to iTunes.

And then there's the question of which version would HomePod play if the Match option does grant it access to most of a ripped collection in iTunes- the 256Kbps version via streams or the up to lossless versions on our own Macs in our own libraries? Since so much of the spin about this speaker is about sound quality, at least a big portion of that equation will be tied to the quality of the source material. Hopefully, it WILL be able to play ripped content from CDs in our own iTunes libraries at whatever quality we've opted to rip those songs. But we'll see soon.

And I completely agree: for those that don't mind potentially boxing stuff up and returning it, nothing beats doing your own review, in your own home, with your own media.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bruinsrme and Jax44
Preordered mine in white.

I'm curious if the power cord is a fixed length or if you can retract it inside the HomePod, in looking at the breakaway diagram it looks like there is space down near the bottom around the base inside for the cord to wrap around if you pushed it inside, and in looking at pictures of the back it doesn't look like a typical fixed power cord connection.
 
Or... Purchase one and make your own evaluation in your particular listening environment over a 14 day period. Don't like it? Send it back.

I'm talking about professional reviews. I'm not qualified either by ear or equipment. But I would be temped to give HomePod a try if Siri HomePod worked with my personal collection. But it doesn't so right now I have no use for a feature-limited HomePod at current price point. That doesn't mean I'm not interested in reading a pro review for reference -- and curious as to why if it is in fact so "superior" sounding, Apple didn't give it to a known audio reviewer before now to put through the paces.
 
Understood.
But 9 to 5 isn’t too biased towards Apple.

Anyway, I have a feeling that HomePod will do well in reviews from Audio sites, if they aren’t too biased in favor of 10,000.00 speakers

Even though HomePod uses similar (but obviously cost-reduced) signal processing technology and techniques as this speaker, audiophile sites are reporting HomePod comes up woefully short in comparison, from conducting a recent series of blind test listening evaluations.

Bummed. Apple is therefore doomed.
 
Last edited:
24638FDC-3E98-4721-80A9-A190C4F4E514.jpeg
Ordered 12. One for each room in my mansion. At $350 per pop you’d be silly not to buy this. Over spending money on frivolous things is one of my most enjoyable passions.

Well for your sake I hope these two aren’t making your delivery. If the are, you’re going to learn what a write off is.
 
Luckily I have a relative in the US and he let me send it to his house so I can get it shipped to here in Canada!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.