HobeSoundDarryl
macrumors G5
I wonder if I might suggest that it can sound very different in your home. Even if something sounds great in the Apple Store; Best Buy; etc.,etc. the sound will vary greatly depending on flooring, ceiling height, furnishings, and window dimensions, among other things.
I completely agree with this. For the ultimate test, there's no place like home and nothing like our own ears hearing our own audio source selections.
It probably is best to purchase one and try it out in your home to determine whether or not it meets your personal audio preferences (also highly individual).
I disagree but only per my own purposes. I personally would rather let some reviews answer some open questions about it first. Then, I can easily visit a store and play with it there for something a little closer to a personal review. Then, take it home if it gets past both of those filters. However, that's just driven by a smallish lack of desire to box things back up and send them back if I don't like them. If someone else doesn't care about that, see the first answer.
[doublepost=1516985041][/doublepost]
The discussion I saw about the really expensive speaker comparison, was from The Loop based on a reddit thread.
http://www.loopinsight.com/2018/01/24/on-homepod-and-audio-quality/
OK, thanks for the link. Basically, that's just speculation from available information. Everything we're reading in these threads could be just as right or wrong about this product.
In speculation: technically, this can be a box of crap or the best audio speaker in the world. It's probably somewhere between those 2 extremes. The cheerleaders here are spinning it as the latter. The naysayers/bashers here are spinning it as the former. But nobody knows (yet)... except some people inside Apple and some hand-picked reviewers who have shared only select opinions, that may or may not be somewhat biased to keeping themselves on the early reviewer list.
I hope it's fannnnnntastic. New competition is always good for us consumers. Odds are favorable it will be a good smart speaker- how often does Apple just completely miss a target? They're smart, skilled, hardware makers that have ridden about 5 distinct tech products to become the richest company on the planet. But none of us can make strong pro or strong con comments about this unreleased product and be definitely right at this point. We have a sense of what is. Reality is coming very soon. Reality may be better or worse than our sense. None of us know which yet.
Last edited: