I really appreciate that Apple found the way back to making their webservice fully integrated into their other products not just by functionality but also by price. So that they are really just another feature of the Hardware product you already paid for. Makes it accessible to many more users, though I never minded paying for the .mac/me services all the recent years.
However, after switching from me to icloud really last minute last week, it all feels a bit like unfinished business. The transition worked fine, but I am really missing feature which have been essential to me. And which make iCloud not feel like a successor to MobileMe, instead rather like its predecessor.
And I mean this not just by functionality (why is stuff like mailbox, rules, keychain sync not part of Apple's advanced cloud strategy, why did they kill the comparably well featured MM galleries to come up with the plain Photostream and now Shared Photostream,....). I am also talking about design. While some may think of all the ultra-realistic styles for Addressbook, Calendar, Notes as super fancy they actually don't seem to have anything to do with the simple and functionality based design many of us are used by Apple for decades. It seems like they totally trashed their famous design guidelines and this nightmare obviously may continue for their other platforms too.
While it may be true and good, to use metaphors in user interface design that people already know, how many users of Apple's main target group actually still know, how a realy calendar, a real addressbook or a folder-bounded notepad looks and works like. Me myself, I havn't used any of them for ages. I already grew up with digital counterparts and I am not the youngest anymore.
Don't get me wrong, I am very open minded to all the fancy stuff, but still design should be functions based, then form follows.