You extrapolated some points of out of thin air there.This is silly. Most of our business comes from accidental damage, and many people do not insure against accidental damage because insurance is often a poor option. You often get a used or refurbished device expensively with a long turnaround. Further, many of our repairs are on 4-7 year old devices, way outside even a 3 year warranty you are suggesting should be standard.
There is no law I can think of that would fairly require a manufacturer to repair a product that a consumer dropped, spilled liquid into, stepped on, ran over with their car, or a device over 5 years old. The idea that I do not care about consumers or consumer protection law because I do not advocate for legislation that requires manufacturers to repair accidental damage by consumers is ridiculous on its face.
Your post asserts that if consumers do not have insurance and accidentally damage their product, there should be no option. Many of them disagree with you. That is why this is popular.
Firstly 3 years was never specified by me anywhere. I’d expect a device to be free of manufacturing defects for way longer than that. The manufacturer should support both hardware failures and software patching for 6 years. At the end of the supported life they should be forced to pay the owner a portion of the original value back to ensure that they recycle it and don’t leave it to regional waste disposal to deal with. That forces environmental responsibility both on sourcing and disposal.
Secondarily I agree: if you do something stupid at no point should the manufacturer foot the bill. Not sure where you got your version of that from. But they must provide up front transparent pricing on repair costs and have a guaranteed repair service available. Apple already do this.
If you don’t like the pricing of the device or the repair costs, simply insure it or don’t buy it. Don’t go complaining afterwards because the old mantra applies: if you can’t afford to replace it you can’t afford to own it.
My points still stand firm in my last message. The reason your business exists is poor consumer protection legislation and lack of foresight and risk analysis by the average person.
We should solve those problems, not push the status quo harder.