I actually ran out and bought one. I just finished setting it up and WOW! I haven't had this feeling in years and years of buying new Macs. I've been buying them every few years since 1990 or so. I've been through them all. And finally, this monster feels like a whole 'nother ballgame.
Not that anyone cares, but I have been using a late 2013 macbook pro with a Thunderbolt 1 Belkin Dock connected to a Apple 23" Cinema Display. The monitor has been my favorite for 10+ years that I've had it. But it's looking fuzzy, and keeps crapping out, I have to buy used powersupplies on ebay and hack them.
So I got goofy and went to BestBuy last week and bought a new 2017 15" macbook pro, the $2799.00 model. That started a crap storm - I bought the Thunderbolt 3 Belkin Dock so I could go 1 cable to monitor. But that old monitor just felt wrong, so I bought an LG 4K 27" monitor. It was fairly mac-like, white and silver, matte finish, quite nice.
But Adobe CC 2018 ran WORSE than it did on my El Capitan 2013 Macbook. High Sierra is a dog on the macbook. It was so slow I installed InDesign 2015 and it was way better. But I had already opened a bunch of docs and resaved them in 2018, edited a few FCP X videos that won't open on older FCP X, so there's no going back.
I did actually yesterday spend 1/2 a day wiping out my 2013 macbook, reinstalling El Capitan, and the 2015 Creative Cloud apps, and was going to soldier on with my old setup another year to see what the next macbook pros are like.
Then I got to thinking...I had to buy 4 or 5 dongles, a memory card reader, longer thunderbolt cables, the Belkin dock only had 2 rear facing USB A ports, and my old wired keyboard and mighty mouse used those up, nowhere for my iPhone dock to plugin, or my new 3 port SD card/hub I had to buy. And I had cables EVERYWHERE on my desk.
All that work and money, right around $4K for the macbook pro, monitor, dock and cables/accessories.
And it was no faster really than my 5 year old stuff. And the 4K monitor was ugly too. And wouldn't wake up from sleep all the time. And was very hard to shut off with a hidden power button that was a toggle switch too.
It was frustrating. I wasted 3 days stressing over the $4k I just spent, and ended up with zero improvement in the end.
I was boxing it all up to return to BestBuy. And then on the way to the store tonight I remembered this thread. And how MicroCenter was out of the iMac Pro when I called last week just for fun. I started really, really thinking about how nice an all-in-one would be for me. Insane power, killer 5K screen, killer new keyboard/mouse with no wires, a card reader, TONS of usb-c/thunderbolt and USB A ports, a speaker out on the back, and I got a big smile on my face.
I found a micro-center about 30 minutes away, didn't even know they existed. And got there tonight within 15 minutes of closing. They had 9 new ones, and I walked out the door with a total of $4299.00 spent. No extra cables, docks, nothing.
I hooked it up, downloaded the CC 2018 apps, fcp x, etc. And am shocked at the speed and power this thing has.
Seriously. My too slow on the MBP 2017 is now opens in seconds. No beach balls! The screen is beyond beautiful. The glare isn't even an issue...it has kept me from buying an iMac.
Would I have paid $5400 for it (tax included)? no. But $3999.00 just seems okay. Especially when a MacBook pro with 512K HD is $3000 with tax. Actually a few bucks more than $3000.
I am not a casual user. I am a self-employed graphic designer, web developer, video producer, photographer and do lots with Logic Pro for music production. I use my macs all day, 5 days a week.
The times I took my MacBook off my desk is realistically a few times a month at best. The rest of the time it sat here in clamshell mode. The iMac Pro has been completely SILENT! It's the first new mac I've had in a decade that felt really, really special. Apple got this one right. The color, the ports, the power, enough ram, hd and gpu on a base model to actually be perfect for most people. No more "better come up with another few hundred to buy more ram!". Just take it out, plug it in, and go. If this is any indication of where Apple is heading with the MacPro and hopefully a future MacBook Pro, we are all going to be better off.
And Price is not the end of the story. My first Mac was the SE30 something or other. It was $5000 decades ago.
The power is real. $4000 for this computer is not crazy. It's a killer deal, and MicroCenter is awesome for this deal. I don't care their motivation for doing it. I haven't found one single online or retail store offering beyond a few hundred off.
So in my opinion, this is a winner. The new macbook pro? Not a winner. Just not much faster or better than the last generation. The touch bar is useless to me, as I don't use it opened up much, the dongles are horrible, no sd card a pain, and no magsafe? Not better for me. For some, it's great I'm sure.
So go buy one! If you need it. I just can't see how anyone could be disappointed.