Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This is true. I had “Liquid Glass” on my androids a decade ago. Does anyone genuinely believe that this theme is novel?

Has everyone forgot Windows Vista?

Guys, transparency themes are old as ****

Is this supposed to be controversial?

Apple literally copied Microsofts Aero design from Windows Vista.

Another swarm of opinions that completely miss the technical aspects of Liquid Glass. It's not just transparency.

Tap a button and it morphs into dropdown or a window. That's the brilliance of it, way beyond just a theme.
 
People want this?

Must just be me, but I use my phone as a tool to get things done. I don't want shapes or highlights moving around dynamically or having much transparency at all.

And here we have the dilemma... if Apple sticks to the same-ol' design, people complain that they aren't "innovating". If Apple introduces sometime brand new, people complain about that. Just can't win.

Hint: Turn on "Increase Contrast" to temper the effects of Liquid Glass.
 
Absolutely not surprised especially with the Chinese manufacturers copying design elements, both software and hardware. Others too might soon follow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mganu
Has everyone forgot Windows Vista?

Guys, transparency themes are old as ****
Haven’t you heard that complete originality does not exist? Nothing is created in isolation and everything is a variation on a theme and inspired by something that already exists or came before. Like how in the past 8 years or so the 90’s has come back hard but with a Gen-Z twist.

It’s all good man. We keep mixing our paint and tey new combo’s.
 
Except that there's no Liquid Glass in that UI at all, it's just frosted blur (introduced way back with iOS 7). The whole point of Liquid glass is the refraction effects near the edges of elements in the UI.

Anyone that looks closely can see that this copycat is missing that completely. So they're just copying general style, shapes and colors.
 
In a strange way this is simpler and works better.

Liquid Glass warps the background image imitating the way light bends and refracts through rounded glass.

This appears to be much simpler. A blurred translucent layer with a slight bevel at the edges to give the appearance of depth. It is much simpler for graphics processing and much simpler to implement as a design language. But because it is more of a flat 'frosted-glass' type effect it actually achieves greater usability/readability.

I like liquid glass, but it's too extreme in its first implementation and trying to show off how cleaver it is. I suspect just as I found iOS 7 too jarring with later versions of iOS slightly toning down the effect just a little, I suspect iOS 27 and beyond will subtly dial back the effect and find a better balance. At least I hope so.
 
Funny because “liquid glass” itself looks like it has been copied from an Android themes pack.

I find it ironic that, because Liquid Glass has transparency, people claim it rips off older Android or even Windows Vista when at the time Windows Vista and early Android was seen to be ripping off Apple's Aqua design language from early OSX.

Design is cyclical. It's the same outside of software and technology. In the late 2010s an updated interpretation of Mid-Century Modern was the big thing in interior design and now interior design trends are seeing a revival of Post-Modernism. In the 90s baggy clothes and lots of denim was popular, in the 00s skinny was the trend and now we're seeing oversized fits making a come back.

What keeps design 'new' is that it isn't a complete copy of the previous version, it it heavily influenced by the past but adds new concepts and ideas over time. Liquid Glass is obviously reminiscent of the period that saw Apple's Aqua design language and the glass layers of Windows Vista, but it adds to it and is a modern interpretation.
 
Why is almost the entire software industry a bunch of NPCs like Tim Cook? Microsoft pioneered this disaster known as flat design, but the rest of the industry luckily stuck with skeuomorphic design for a couple of years after that. And then Apple mindlessly copied Microsoft and Google by jumping on the flat design bandwagon, and the rest of the industry sheepishly copies Apple by purging skeuomorphism and implementing flat design. The same thing is starting to happen now with glassmorphism, which is a variant of flat design.
I was first very excited about iOS 26, but then learned it is the same old 💩 but wrapped in a “new” branding, literal iOS 18 but worse.

Microsoft meanwhile was on the backseat of design ever since Windows 8 dropped, I still remember how mad were people about tiles and no classic start menu. Their designs are awful in terms of user experience. And Apple copies everything from them now, even fugly settings app. Sad days, sad state of tech. Well, at least these NPCs are saving me money cause I am not even inclined to get any new product anymore, only if necessity strikes (if something breaks for example)
 
Last edited:
Quite the opposite. Windows Aero is copyright 2006. Yes just shy of 20 years ago.

Try again.
Hmm so maybe we can hope for “20 years anniversary collectors’ edition” from Microsoft in 2026?🤔

Like Windows 12 Aero.

Would be cool if they do it better than Apple. Looking thru the years Vista and 7 were not too bad in terms of design
 
And here we have the dilemma... if Apple sticks to the same-ol' design, people complain that they aren't "innovating". If Apple introduces sometime brand new, people complain about that. Just can't win.

Hint: Turn on "Increase Contrast" to temper the effects of Liquid Glass.
Liquid glass is unfortunately not innovation, it is same old flat abomination. I expected full-blown skeuomorphic return but instead they have added even more microcontrast in UI. Interface is so cluttered that it feels I am using old touchscreen Nokia, nothing similar to simplicity of old Apple.

So yeah, Apple is not innovating at all. This is barely a skin on top of already bad design that aged poorly.

Apple was telling “you will get used to it” in 2013. Well, I still cannot get used to it! Ever since then I use my iPhone like a dumbphone - take a photo, go to Safari to access a website, write a message in messenger, launch ChatGPT, that’s it… I no more care about which wallpaper I have or how good my icons are, because they are bad ever since iOS 7. Also I no more download apps because most apps use that design philosophy. I mean I have lots of apps installed but use just 3-4.

Also competitors nowadays offer much better options. Their cameras are better, their UI is also flat but somehow more usable, though the app flawlessness will never be on the level of iOS.

But what I had noticed is lots of bugs in iOS. New iPhones work as slow as old ones, lots of glitches and such. I’ve been using 16 Pro from time to time and honestly, how people don’t feel that? It works as slow as my 11 Pro, maybe a bit more smooth because of 120Hz display (which doesn’t even work in 120Hz constantly like 60Hz displays)
 
Another swarm of opinions that completely miss the technical aspects of Liquid Glass. It's not just transparency.

Tap a button and it morphs into dropdown or a window. That's the brilliance of it, way beyond just a theme.
It's also rubbish, and makes life harder in terms of readability at pretty much every juncture, but aside from that, yeah, it's awesome.
 
And you know the best part? They actually added a slider to change the effect to your own liking!
This is literally all they had to do to appease everyone.

I say 'all'. I don't know what technical challenges that would cause but it should have been a given. But you have to do everything the Apple way, or not at all.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.