Back in the Apple Clear Frost (for now). Beats case will likely be going back. Felt grippy at first, but with more use, I found it was slipping too much when trying to one-hand the Air (especially reaching to the left side --I'm right-handed, or swiping up to go home). Despite the fingerprints and general smudginess that can develop, the Apple clear overall has more grip and is lighter and slimmer on the back. I really just wish Apple had released the silicone cases for the Air. They are already pretty light and thin cases so I think those would've been a great fit for the Air. Other silcone cases just don't have the same feel as Apple's.
Even with the lower weight, the super thin sides make the Air harder to hold than I thought it would be. I'm a pretty light user, so I figured the Air would be right up my alley, but now I'm rethinking things a bit.
I don't have a need for the Pro cameras and would prefer to stay on the lighter side, so I ordered a 17 base model in Mist Blue that I'm pretty sure I'll be switching to. I'm conflicted because I like the idea of the Air so much. I think it's the best looking of all the models released this year. And while the compromises don't bother me all that much, combined with the base model being nearly $200 less, I think that makes more sense for me.
I hope the official silicone case doesn't disappoint. Haven't been able to find many reviews on YouTube (besides just showing the colors) that mention the weight or buttons (are they redesigned this year?) but if they are no worse than previous years, I think it'll be perfect for my needs.
The hard part is that the 17s are 2-3 weeks out for delivery times (I'm nowhere near an Apple Store) and I'll have to return the Air before then. Wish I could compare at the same time and visiting a Best Buy with the security/charging thing attached is never a good indicator for me.
TL;DR I'm likely returning the Air and getting a base 17 primarily because I miss the official Apple silicone case too much.