They phased out DVD drives when nobody really used them anymore, and there was a long transition phase during which Macs had both DVD drives and other connectivity. iPhones never supported Flash from the start, and it wasn't common on other phones before, so no existing use cases were affected.
The USB-C transition was, you all have to use this new port that no Mac ever included before, right now, and neither the market nor the port itself is really ready, so we sell expensive dongles so you can reverse the change.
One big thing that I think is overlooked when anyone “justifies” removing any oft-used port with the “Apple removed optical drives” example is: Apple in parallel also quickly made downloading of music & apps onto the computer very easy and convenient, and technically with no added cost to the user: Buy cd’s of music or apps, vs. pay & download music or apps. In a way, the discussion is more about electrons than hard/durable goods.
To this day, no packages from Apple have yet to arrive at my door with free dongles or free replacement USB-A to USB-C cables, or free replacement USB-C equipped hard drives, music/midi interfaces, etc. devices that use (and will use for years to come) USB-A inputs. The durable/hard goods in my office & music room have plenty of life left and are not cheap to replace, and they’re readily available in many offices & places I travel to. Buying dongles/cables/adapters/new hardware is not just about different electrons...implementing the change to a USB-C only MacBook has real costs, both monetary as well as the extra hassle to handle/store/tote/replace the new hardware. That’s the major difference. The optical drive example is a hard one to compare to removing MagSafe or headphone jack or USB port. Apple had hits with innovations like the iPod, iPad, Airpods, MagSafe, pretty computers, and removing the optical drive. Apple still has big misses, like removing certain
ubiquitous hardware/ports, and all the Jony Ive-pleasing flat/vague design since iOS7.
Last edited: