Leather Cases - Patina Proud Photos

[BigMcGuire]

Can you share more about the comparison? Where does B beat A? Can you say which is thicker and/or heavier? TIA

Sure can. Bullstrap seems to be a slightly better built case. The leather is thicker and harder. The case hugs the phone better and the camera guard isn't a massive metal ring that protrudes out.

I have both cases and I prefer the Bullstrap but it costs a lot more and I'd be happy with the Andar if I had just that case. Andar leather smells amazing, is a bit thinner, softer, and the case doesn't hug the phone as closely as the Bullstrap does. So definitely a bit more premium feeling with the Bullstrap but you pay for it too.

Weight wise the two cases are about the same - but Bullstrap hugging the phone more makes the phone feel lighter/smaller (slightly) than the Andar case does.

 

[rgarjr]

Yeah I like how the camera ring on the bull strap, the leather wraps around it, they’re very well made.

 

[s2k_ap1]

Any details would be apprecaited?

Sure.
BullStrap
Pros: great fitment
Great quality leather
No imprint of MagSafe through the leather
No metal camera wring
More front lip protection

Cons: open bottom

Andar:
Pros: stronger scent of leather
And amazing leather quality

Cons:
I can see the MagSafe ring through the leather
Almost no front protection
No the best fitment case pops out way too easy (main deal breaker for me)

Open bottom just like bullstrap

 

[Knowlege Bomb]

Sure.
BullStrap
Pros: great fitment
Great quality leather
No imprint of MagSafe through the leather
No metal camera wring
More front lip protection

Cons: open bottom

Andar:
Pros: stronger scent of leather
And amazing leather quality

Cons:
I can see the MagSafe ring through the leather
Almost no front protection
No the best fitment case pops out way too easy (main deal breaker for me)

Open bottom just like bullstrap

I had the same experience with my navy Andar and have gone back to my midnight Apple leather (with a cheap Ali case in between that just looks awesome). Wish I had gone with Bullstrap.

 

[s2k_ap1]

I had the same experience with my navy Andar and have gone back to my midnight Apple leather (with a cheap Ali case in between that just looks awesome). Wish I had gone with Bullstrap

Yeah pretty bad experience with andar. I wouldn’t recommend it, sure BullStrap isn’t the cheapest, but it’s definitely a really good case with amazing warranty

 

[sorensonaa]

I'd be interested. I'm in the UK?

Shoot me a PM. I am in the US but would be happy to ship.

 

[igauravarora]

Does anyone else get bothered by the bullstrap logo right in the middle of the case? I have been keeping an eye on this thread and I absolutely love the pictures of the bullstrap cases except for the logo. I wished they made a version without any logo, I would buy it in a heartbeat.

 

[BigMcGuire]

Does anyone else get bothered by the bullstrap logo right in the middle of the case? I have been keeping an eye on this thread and I absolutely love the pictures of the bullstrap cases except for the logo. I wished they made a version without any logo, I would buy it in a heartbeat.

I actually like it. Better than the white lettering or branding on the sides of other brands. My own preference of course.

 

[Explorerlea]

Off topic but is there a thread on airpods leather cases?

 

[rgarjr]

Does anyone else get bothered by the bullstrap logo right in the middle of the case? I have been keeping an eye on this thread and I absolutely love the pictures of the bullstrap cases except for the logo. I wished they made a version without any logo, I would buy it in a heartbeat.

Nah, that bull is pretty small so it doesn’t bother me.

 

[maxrest]

I'm thinking of going for the The Marshal from Andar. I had that case for my 11 and loved it. The two-tone look is so nice, imo.

 

[Phil77354]

Don't worry she'll love it. It looks very chic and the leather on the inside is still quite nice. It's very expensive but the brand power can't be denied and I personally think it looks very nice. The nomad would be too "masculine" of a folio IMO.

Coach case received and looks great. I'll get a photo and post later today. The quality appears to be very good, should be durable. I'm glad that I ordered it for her.

EDIT - well, I spoke too soon. When I was taking a couple of photos of the case, I noticed that at the rear corner of the case around the camera area, the leather was pulling away from the plastic. It isn't really damaged, it looks like it simply was not glued sufficiently. I sent a note to Coach asking them about what they recommend to use for repairing it, or if they want to replace it. The Coach Outlet that we purchased it from will accept a return but they don't pay for return shipment costs, although given that the case was defective I don't know if they will make some accommodation.

So I'm slightly disappointed although it is not a huge thing assuming we can find the right glue to use for repair. The case is otherwise excellent and I don't necessarily want to exchange it for a new one, which would result in this case being wasted.

ADDED NOTE: I forgot to mention - one disadvantage to this case is that you can't use the MagSafe charger when the phone is installed in the case (and it is too difficult to remove it from the case to even think about pulling it on and off just to charge the phone). So it's back to charging using the Lightning connector. Oh well.

ONE MORE (FINAL) NOTE: Coach has already responded to the message I sent to their customer service just a couple of hours ago, and they are sending a replacement for this case. Great customer service! I really think this can be fixed but of course it shouldn't be coming loose so soon. We'll be able to take our time and re-glue this one, and have it as a backup if needed. Not bad and once again I'm reminded by how easy it is these days to get in touch with companies via their websites, and if the company is a good one then they respond quickly and resolve problems in a good way for their customers. Very good experience.

 

[Knowlege Bomb]

Does anyone have shots of a midnight case that’s been used since launch?

 

[nekron99]

Does anyone else get bothered by the bullstrap logo right in the middle of the case? I have been keeping an eye on this thread and I absolutely love the pictures of the bullstrap cases except for the logo. I wished they made a version without any logo, I would buy it in a heartbeat.

Opposite—I prefer my 12 Bullstrap to my 13 Andar because of the logo. The Andar looks like it’s missing something.

 

[mac_head]

Thanks! Do you know which is more bulky? I'd prefer thin. Sadly, though, the Andar looks out of stock -- but if that's best, hopefully it refreshes quickly. Thanks!

I had a Bullstrap Sienna and am now using an Andar in black. I’d say the Andar is a tiny bit thicker but the difference is only minor. The lip that goes around the edges and protects your screen when laid face down is higher on the Andar, though..

 

[Knowlege Bomb]

It’s unreal how indecisive I am when it comes to cases. I’ve now gone back to my Nomad and fully realize that the finality I’m feeling at the moment will be fleeting just like every other time. Looks amazing though!

 

[Brooke795]

It’s unreal how indecisive I am when it comes to cases. I’ve now gone back to my Nomad and fully realize that the finality I’m feeling at the moment will be fleeting just like every other time. Looks amazing though!

Oh trust me I feel ya on this. I already went back to my carved cases (I know you saw my post on the other thread!). I have option anxiety! Lol

 

[curious248]

If anyone's located in Toronto and wants to buy a Bullstrap Sienna MagSafe case for the iPhone 12, let me know - I'm going to sell mine off, brand new (ended up changing my mind on it).

 

[Daniel Narciso]

Not really liking this year’s patina. When looking up close does not look like real leather aging but more painting being removed slowly.

Does anyone recommend any good European leather cases? (American ones get too expensive with shipping + tax)

 

[Rebani]

My Apple Leather cover after 5 weeks of use.

 

[s2k_ap1]

.

 

[s2k_ap1]

Midnight leather case since November and now, really happy with it

 

[igauravarora]

Not really liking this year’s patina. When looking up close does not look like real leather aging but more painting being removed slowly.

Does anyone recommend any good European leather cases? (American ones get too expensive with shipping + tax)

View attachment 1952629

Did you use any alcohol wipes? Or is this the natural change?

 

[Daniel Narciso]

Did you use any alcohol wipes? Or is this the natural change?

Alcohol wipes, before I removed the coating I was getting this weird patina.

 

[igauravarora]

Alcohol wipes, before I removed the coating I was getting this weird patina.

God that looks bad, I have used alcohol wipes a week or so ago and removed as much of the coating as I could. I dont know if it looks better or worse than yours, you can judge for yourself.

I suspect that in your case there is still some coating left that could be removed but it could be risky to rub it off again.

The only thing I did different was to put a few drops of coconut oil on my hand and massaged the case afterwards for an hour.

There was also someone in this thread who used a damp magic eraser, they have had much better patina in my opinion.