Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So for us that were trying to figure out who the leather provider was for Apple when things went wrong with their cases. I believe the Pixel Bellroy leather case can confirm that it was ECCO leather and tanned there. Bellroy’s pixel case is almost the identical leather to Apple’s cases since the 12. Also from videos of pixel’s in the past, it looks like it ages just the same.

I truly believe ECCO’s tanning process is the issue. They “paint” or put a heavy protective coating to keep the brand new look as long as possible, but it only makes the leather age terribly because only the high use areas wear down that coating. I don’t think the quality of the leather is bad, it’s the coating. Also from videos on the Bellroy, it seems it top grain which I think we all pretty much knew.

If only we could figure out who made the leather for the 11 pro and below. Nothing on the market matches the fit and finish of those cases for an iPhone.
Nomad uses ECCO in their non Horween cases and they patina beautifully.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Surf Monkey
Just ordered a Lonli case from Amazon. Description says genuine leather but video reviews of past cases from this manufacturer say it is vegan leather. It might be going back but I'll give it a try first. Pics will come in a few days.
 
I really like my whisky because it reminds me of the old apple saddle brown cases but that slate is one of the cleanest looking leather cases I’ve seen. Really wish I would have ordered both.
I may buy a whisky laterI plan to keep my iPhone 15 Pro Max for few years so I will rotate the case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mjpearce023
I finally decided to upgrade my 12PM. My 15PM Natural Titanium will be here Friday along with my Keyway whiskey case.

Here’s my 12PM BS sienna case that’s
been off and on for like a year or so…

ba72e3df08590e7550b76f5da5619a5c.jpg

65a3e3ef9333bd0035e71717ed565788.jpg
 
Was in the Marshall’s on Vegas strip tonight. It’s overstocked with Apple brand Leather cases for the 13 & 14 series. So if you’re in need check your Marshall’s.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikext
I really like my whisky because it reminds me of the old apple saddle brown cases but that slate is one of the cleanest looking leather cases I’ve seen. Really wish I would have ordered both.
Some weak-willed people might have done that in reverse - ordered a slate, but then decided to order a whiskey (even before receiving the slate).

But, umm, no one I know. Nope.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: mjpearce023
Some weak-willed people might have done that in reverse - ordered a slate, but then decided to order a whiskey (even before receiving the slate).

But, umm, no one I know. Nope.
See I was trying to wait till the whisky came in to decide if I wanted the slate but by the time I got it the slate was gone. I wish I had ordered it when it came back in stock
 
I finally decided to upgrade my 12PM. My 15PM Natural Titanium will be here Friday along with my Keyway whiskey case.

Here’s my 12PM BS sienna case that’s
been off and on for like a year or so…

ba72e3df08590e7550b76f5da5619a5c.jpg

65a3e3ef9333bd0035e71717ed565788.jpg

I am gonna get slammed for this, but I am just gonna say it. I don’t see that much difference in how this ages compared to the Apple leather cases. The edges are what get dark first, and the middle only patinas on highly used parts of the case. Yes Apples is harder to get any age in the middle, but just saying I don’t think this looks that much different.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iFone88
I am gonna get slammed for this, but I am just gonna say it. I don’t see that much difference in how this ages compared to the Apple leather cases. The edges are what get dark first, and the middle only patinas on highly used parts of the case. Yes Apples is harder to get any age in the middle, but just saying I don’t think this looks that much different.
Yeah. This patina didn’t come out very well actually. It does resemble a lot of apple’s cases for some reason.
 
Yeah. This patina didn’t come out very well actually. It does resemble a lot of apple’s cases for some reason.

Honestly I haven’t seen many patinas from iPhone 12s and up that look much different. It’s the shape of the phone that leads to this. The highest quality leather case I don’t think ages great
 
That looks like it’s been treated some how. The corners and sides look even with the back, and everything is even. These flat sided iPhones don’t lead to an even patina.

I hate to break it to you but I did nothing to this case except for use it and all 3 of them looked very similar after a year. Around the camera ring was the lightest part each time.
 
I hate to break it to you but I did nothing to this case except for use it and all 3 of them looked very similar after a year. Around the camera ring was the lightest part each time.

That doesn’t make a sense because to the right of the camera cutout gets no hands, but yet it’s just as worn as the other parts of the case. My BS hasn’t done that at all. There is a very uneven patina
 
  • Like
Reactions: Surf Monkey
That doesn’t make a sense because to the right of the camera cutout gets no hands, but yet it’s just as worn as the other parts of the case. My BS hasn’t done that at all. There is a very uneven patina
This is an iPhone 12 mini and I held it with one hand next to the camera when watching videos in landscape. Keep using your BS and you'll get there.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.