Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Leo wrote:
"neoprene case and backpack"

The backpack could be the problem.
How much pressure is being applied to the MacBook -- to both the top and bottom of the MacBook -- when it's "fully packed" into the backpack?

It probably doesn't take much to... "make an impression", so to speak.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rocko99991
Leo wrote:
"neoprene case and backpack"

The backpack could be the problem.
How much pressure is being applied to the MacBook -- to both the top and bottom of the MacBook -- when it's "fully packed" into the backpack?

It probably doesn't take much to... "make an impression", so to speak.
This. Even the slightest pressure, with the insane tolerances on these devices, can cause the screen to rub against the keyboard. That's why a ultra soft, clean cloth may help this get worse. If you can find a case that prevents any pressure on the device that would work too.
 
Leo wrote:
"neoprene case and backpack"

The backpack could be the problem.
How much pressure is being applied to the MacBook -- to both the top and bottom of the MacBook -- when it's "fully packed" into the backpack?

It probably doesn't take much to... "make an impression", so to speak.

The problem is not the backpack, problem is that Apple has a design flaw in this new macbook pro or Apple chose a poor quality screen.
My old pro macbook (Mid 2012), used for 4 years, storing in the same way, is with the screen without any mark.
 
  • Like
Reactions: laz232 and No. 44
I bought this
875331004030.jpg

https://www.radtech.com/products/screensavrz-macbook-pro-keyboard-cover
[doublepost=1503420230][/doublepost]How has that worked for you so far? It's been a while since you made this post, has there been any issues with the product? Does it interfere with the screen or keyboard in an unexpected way? Are you still using it today? Thanks!
 
Thanks for the suggestion, but a notebook of this value, has to have a good quality screen.
I have already learned that this protection can leave more marks on the screen.
Apple does not want to change the screen of my macbook and now I'm talking to my lawyer and we are going to ask another computer and indemnification for Apple .
Everyone had to do the same.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0920 copy.jpg
    IMG_0920 copy.jpg
    1.6 MB · Views: 808
  • IMG_8851.JPG
    IMG_8851.JPG
    1 MB · Views: 562
  • IMG_8852.JPG
    IMG_8852.JPG
    1 MB · Views: 497
Excuse me as I haven't received my MBP...

Any of you use use a hard case, like the thule attache instead of a neoprene cover? Seems like a hardcase would stop anything from pushing the screen into the keyboard? Sure it's bulky...But it should protect it, no?
 
[doublepost=1503420230][/doublepost]How has that worked for you so far? It's been a while since you made this post, has there been any issues with the product? Does it interfere with the screen or keyboard in an unexpected way? Are you still using it today? Thanks!

I use it every day and it's perfect. I recommend it to protect the screen.
 
None of my past laptops have had this problem. Then again, I've never bought a Glarebook Pro (glossy screen). My antiglare is recessed, lower than the bezel so it doesn't come in contact with the screen at all.

I'd avoid saying "all laptops suffer from this issue" as it is impossible for you to be aware of, and potentially have used every laptop out there. This is impossible which makes a statement without merit.

Apple's form over function is ridiculous - a laptop doesn't have to be super thin to be a great laptop. There are too many trade-offs for this thinness, and then add in the the outrageous pricing after removing ports etc...

All laptops suffer from this issue in some form or another. The problem is that even thicker screen cases are 'thin' relative to their surface area and so when pressure is applied near the centre of the casing, contact is easily made even if sufficient space was manufactured in. I even experienced this with my old IBM T42 and that thing was practically indestructible.

So far, nothing suggests that the new MBP screens are more prone to keyboard pressure than preceding models.
 
  • Like
Reactions: steberg and entropi
None of my past laptops have had this problem. Then again, I've never bought a Glarebook Pro (glossy screen). My antiglare is recessed, lower than the bezel so it doesn't come in contact with the screen at all.

I'd avoid saying "all laptops suffer from this issue" as it is impossible for you to be aware of, and potentially have used every laptop out there. This is impossible which makes a statement without merit.

Apple's form over function is ridiculous - a laptop doesn't have to be super thin to be a great laptop. There are too many trade-offs for this thinness, and then add in the the outrageous pricing after removing ports etc...

I quite clearly said 'in some form or another'. The point is that depending on your type of use (such as how you travel with your laptop), this problem can affect you regardless of design. Some laptops are more/less vulnerable of course. It just seems that some people mistake mass produced laptops for military standard stab resistant vests.
 
I have a Razer Blade 14 (2014 model) 3K touchscreen and there is no problem with coating

MacBook Pro 13 Retina (early 2015) one year younger and there is a problem with coating, screen replaced by Apple but I'm not sure how long it lasts

Bad design of screen causes a lot problem for users, from 2012 to 2015 Apple has a problem with coating in Retina models
 
Thanks for the suggestion, but a notebook of this value, has to have a good quality screen.
I have already learned that this protection can leave more marks on the screen.
Apple does not want to change the screen of my macbook and now I'm talking to my lawyer and we are going to ask another computer and indemnification for Apple .
Everyone had to do the same.

Sorry for my honest reaction, but "what the **** is this?". If this can happen with normal use then it really is a terrible design flaw. Wow, I am stunned by this. I will receive a new MBP 15" in a few hours and already think about sending it back when seeing this crap.
 
  • Like
Reactions: leo-nunes
I use it every day and it's perfect. I recommend it to protect the screen.


I received my RADTech yesterday. It's useful, but I have noticed that when using, my display "lid" will not shut all the way, more so on the left side. I can move the corner with ease, but when I shut the lid without the RADTech everything is pretty tight and a little more stiff to open.
 
Anyone else seeing this happen?

I haven't abused or done anything out of the ordinary with my new MBP. I don't put a cloth or anything in between keyboard and display when closing it. Do you guys think this warrants going to an Apple Store to have it looked at?

Here's a pic of what it looks like.View attachment 680913

It's been a problem with all the MacBooks Pros I've owned. Skin oils and too small screen distance tolerance cause transfer of oils to display and etch the coating. Shame that Apple has still not fixed this. I hope they do get sued and forced to improve their design on such an expensive product!

NB: I wipe down my keyboard regularly and take great care of my equipment (I run a measurement lab - I'm used to dealing with super-precision equipment).
 
On my surface pro 4 I went with a glad screen protector to protect the real screen from the keyboard. However theres much less pressure.. Looser fit

I took a look and couldn't see any similar protectors for the mbp to 15 2016 but then I assume there Just isn't the space?
 
Wouldn't this fall under the coating repair program? I have slight imprints of the edges of certain keys in the middle of the screen of my two year old MacBook Pro. Also, significantly sized spots where the coating has come off have very recently developed around the iSight lens at the top of the screen. I was going to make an appointment at the Apple Store about it one of these days. Here's a picture of what the screen looks like when it's turned off and reflecting the sunny sky:


View attachment 701366
Just wanted to report back that Apple replaced my display for free, no questions asked, even without Apple Care and outside of the warranty period. Of course, I have no idea how to prevent this from occurring again in 2 years time. At which point the coating repair program will surely have ended. :/
 
I
I received my RADTech yesterday. It's useful, but I have noticed that when using, my display "lid" will not shut all the way, more so on the left side. I can move the corner with ease, but when I shut the lid without the RADTech everything is pretty tight and a little more stiff to open.
I also noticed the lip doesnt close completely on my 2017 mbp. Do you think will this cause a problem?
 
I

I also noticed the lip doesnt close completely on my 2017 mbp. Do you think will this cause a problem?

I stopped using mine. I felt that debris could get in easily. I did a really deep clean with water and a microfiber cloth and removed a lot of the marks. There is one that is permanent at this point. It’s from my shift key. I have also been wiping it down after using and keeping the display open, unless I’m carrying. I am thinking about getting rid of it and moving up to an iMac.
 
I stopped using mine. I felt that debris could get in easily. I did a really deep clean with water and a microfiber cloth and removed a lot of the marks. There is one that is permanent at this point. It’s from my shift key. I have also been wiping it down after using and keeping the display open, unless I’m carrying. I am thinking about getting rid of it and moving up to an iMac.
the reason you quit using is because the lid doesn't close completely ?
 
correct. the lid was open a bit on the left side. it wasn't secure enough for me
btw I have reached rad tech about the issue

"While I'm assuming you're already doing so, be sure to have the ScreenSavrz cloth centered in the keyboard area cavity, as this is the only area that can accommodate the cloth and still allow for lid closure (which is why the 2016/2017 MBP models are cut to the smaller footprint). If the cloth still does not allow for proper lid closure, the scenario below may apply.

I've had two other 2017 MBP customers (and also a 12" MB customer) mention fit issues of this sort with their ScreenSavrz - the rest of our customers have used the same ScreenSavrz and MBP combination together without any issues. We were able to physically look at one of these MBPs, and found that the lid closure tolerance was much tighter than the tolerance of our 2017 MBP, or of the ones we test fit at the local Apple store. I suspect there is a very slight size variance between some of the display assemblies - where some are not glued/bonded together tightly enough, or perhaps too much adhesive is present (which would also make the assembly thicker).

While I can't recommend a thinner cloth (this ScreenSavrz is already produced from the thinnest Optex microfiber grade), a slightly smaller footprint of cloth may help address the closure issue."

They also said:

"The easiest way to size this would be to slightly trim your current ScreenSavrz cloth, testing the fit after each trimming - once a size has been reached which allows for proper lid closure, measure the height and width and I'll have a new ScreenSavrz cut to those dimensions and shipped to you at no cost."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Timmy D
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.