Feeding time™
generik said:
What's so great about the current crop of Macs? That's fanboist thinking!
Let's start with the MBP.
1) ancient 3 year old design
Yes it is an old design, however Apple has said it themselves that the transition to intel is to be as seemless as possible. One reason for keeping the same design, was to keep the image that just because the insides are changing, dosen't mean that Apple has to change it's industrial design.
On a seperate note, the IBM hadn't really changed the industrial design of it's Thinkpad (a laptop you so highly praise, and not just in this thread) since the before Pentium II era.
Pentium II Thinkpad
again a pentium II Thinkpad
CURRENT T60 LENOVO
Again current Lenovo T60
With the exception of the intipoint mouse as opposed to a trackpad, and some minor bezel changes, the industrial design looks about the same as the most recent IBM Thinkpad or almost any current Lenovo product.
2) Functionality over form... NOT.
-overheating.. why? Cos Ives didn't want to mar the clean look with a vent!
-ever thought of doing your own HD upgrade? Woah
-ding and scratch magnet
-see point above, hope you don't fly lest the TSA officers touch it
-probably nice in John Lennon's "white room", but 100% purely impractical in the real world.
Didn't you just get done complimenting the MBP on how well the keyboard felt, and how much you liked it (again referencing the Thinkpad)? Having a good and easy to use keyboard must not be a part of functionality then!
Great point on the heat issue! However it is not unique to Apple, they just got more press regarding it.
Dings and scratches? Welcome to owning a portable electronic device. My HP and IBM laptop have about as much damage as my current iBook.
3) For a bit over half the price, what can you get with PC laptops? C2D, discrete graphics (ok not great, but the MBP's is not GREAT either!), bigger hard drive, better case! What are you getting from a MBP that makes it stand out from the crowd? As in "stand out 100% price premium" from the crowd? Apart from the white Apple logo at the back of it, nothing.
Fair enough, and valid point!
Please go buy a PC based laptop, and tell us how it is.
Funny how Apple is so innovative yet they can't churn out problem-free hardware. This is not software we talking, it is hardware. Perhaps they are so innovative that even their hardware designs are... bugged? Oh hang on, that doesn't make sense, it is more like someone on their design teams fails math and can't even do simple calculations to ensure components get to disscipate heat properly.
Please show us a company that "churns out™" problem free hardware. Don't be suprised however if someone on here points out a laundry list of problems with that hardware, just like you have for the MBP.
No laptop, computer, or piece of technology is perfect. All of it has been designed, built, and shipped by humans. Humans make mistakes!