Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Status
The first post of this thread is a WikiPost and can be edited by anyone with the appropiate permissions. Your edits will be public.
Hmm...help!

1. Downloaded macOS Sierra from my 2013 rMBP
2. Downloaded macOS Sierra Patcher-2 from dosdude1
3. Used Patcher-2 tool to create bootable USB of macOS Sierra
4. Went to install...started in install and now receive the following message...
macOS could not be installed on your computer
No packages were eligible for install. Contact the software manufacturer for assistance.


Any ideas?

Mid 2009 MacBook 5,1 - had previously beta version from several months ago.

EDIT: Just noticed - there is a Patcher-3 ... maybe that is my problem...didnt fix it :(

@dosdude1 any thoughts?
@dosdude1

I fixed my problem! The system date on my machine was wrong. Was back in 2001. Once a changed that through the terminal I was able to install and go past my previous error message. I normally google everything - but since this osMac is soon new I didn't think it would help. Shame on me.
 
That is indeed a very real possibility, and I wouldn't put it past them. I mean, we must wonder if they might even visit this thread in order to determine how to frustrate our plans. :)

And @aquaticflow

Oh you can be sure Infinite Loop is aware of this thread...
From my experience in the restricted Apple developer forums, and some on this thread can directly relate to this, they pounce the second they feel something proprietary is compromised, like direct links to their pre released software. That's why I at least have been careful to elaborate on nothing but public releases. But while management (I'm looking at you Cooke and Schiller) only care about selling new hardware, the oompa loopas have left some doors open for us to play with. "mas" and the enterprise admin side of the house is an example. Harkens back to the days where they just gave us everything without reserve, knowing that being open would fill the coffers. "Think Different" is long gone. That said, we are supporting ourselves...hurrah!
 
  • Like
Reactions: extrachrispy
MacBook Pro 5,5 (mid 2009, 2,53 GHz C2D, 8 GB RAM, 128 GB SSD)

- downloaded MACOS on another mac
- Created USB
- formatted HDD and installed MacOS
- went back into the recovery to do the pre boot
- setup MacOS and installed update patcher

Amazing work and a piece of cake to do.i just followed your instructions:)

Thanks :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: dosdude1
And @aquaticflow

Oh you can be sure Infinite Loop is aware of this thread...
From my experience in the restricted Apple developer forums, and some on this thread can directly relate to this, they pounce the second they feel something proprietary is compromised, like direct links to their pre released software. That's why I at least have been careful to elaborate on nothing but public releases. But while management (I'm looking at you Cooke and Schiller) only care about selling new hardware, the oompa loopas have left some doors open for us to play with. "mas" and the enterprise admin side of the house is an example. Harkens back to the days where they just gave us everything without reserve, knowing that being open would fill the coffers. "Think Different" is long gone. That said, we are supporting ourselves...hurrah!

Wow, I guess I didn't even think of people at Apple looking through this forum, but I guess it makes sense... I also didn't think they would be specifically malicious to block attempts like this (after all we are still all running on Apple Hardware which we payed them for) and like someone else said a bit ago, about how 10.12 will run on a Macbook from 2009 with the same hardware, but not a Macbook Pro...? I understand not everyone has put a solid state drive in to replace the old moving hard drives, and maxed out their memory like I, and many of us have, but still, couldn't they just throw in a bit of support for the mbp's 5,3's? It was a nice upgrade when I went from 4GB to 8GB of memory, and it was a revolution when I went from old hard drive to the SSD. Felt like a new computer!

I don't even care about continuity, or siri on my computer... when I start a task on my phone, I usually finish it there anyways haha!
 
Last edited:
MacBook Pro 5,5 (mid 2009, 2,53 GHz C2D, 8 GB RAM, 128 GB SSD)
Same here, MBP 5,5 (mid 2009, 3,53 GHz C2D, 8 GB RAM, 512 GB SSD). Didn't do a clean install, though, but an upgrade over the most current El Capitan installation. All went smoothly after I had turned off file vault. Could be turned back on again after the upgrade to macOS Sierra. Everything works fine, including trackpad, wifi and iSight camera. Thanks, dosdude1!
 
Wow, I guess I didn't even think of people at Apple looking through this forum, but I guess it makes sense... I also didn't think they would be specifically malicious to block attempts like this (after all we are still all running on Apple Hardware which we payed them for) and like someone else said a bit ago, about how 10.12 will run on a Macbook Pro from 2009 with the same hardware, but not a Macbook Pro...? I understand not everyone has put a solid state drive in to replace the old moving hard drives, and maxed out their memory like I, and many of us have, but still, couldn't they just throw in a bit of support for the mbp's 5,3's? It was a nice upgrade when I went from 4GB to 8GB of memory, and it was a revolution when I went from old hard drive to the SSD. Felt like a new computer!

I don't even care about continuity, or siri on my computer... when I start a task on my phone, I usually finish it there anyways haha!
I hear you.

What we are all experiencing attests to the difficulty of maintaining an old product line correctly. Like trying to change tires on a speeding car. No small matter indeed.
Thousands of things break, all of our systems are slightly different, that's why they have large regression testing labs well equipped to tackle it.
IMHO, they make billions every quarter, mostly through the sweat of external developers and over-priced hardware. Instead of hoarding cash in Irish banks, they could have easily dedicated extra resources in support of perfectly good systems. Would make those of us who plunked down thousands over the years happy loyal customers. I'll admit that my systems are fairly old, circa 2008-9, but at the very least they could make it easier for us to support ourselves right? Redemption codes, firewalls for developer releases etc...is all just paranoid madness. Especially since the beta test programs benefit them so much. I for one am not expecting Apple Support for my hardware, never have. No Genius Bar needed here. So they should just drop the stuff in an open directory somewhere on the net and let us die hards fend for ourselves...They used to do that, no too long ago.

Going back to your angst about moving to Sierra. One should carefully consider their need to upgrade. I had no choice, Xcode 8 and Swift 3 development require Sierra. Period. In the final analysis, I am pleased with its performance. It's faster and more resilient. That minty fresh taste. Along the way, you may enjoy new Siri, Photos, iTunes, Continuity etc...In my case, there are enough (loads) of under-the-hood changes that can only get developers excited. But for the average Joe, El Capitan (has) run just fine and the UI/UX changes are not significant. All in all, the risk of upgrading from El Capitan is a personal choice, but I've been running Sierra for my livelihood with (very few) ill effects. As always, back-up back-up back-up and then back-up again. Then playing with a shiny new OS is not as stressful. And remember, no one will force you to upgrade/patch (ie. the regular pain on this thread) continuously. You may be perfectly happy with 10.12.x for example for another year. Your mileage may vary...

Have fun and Good luck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aquaticflow
Safe mode is -x but i think first remove all non standard kext from that installation.

Here is the extensions list. Any thoughts?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7148.JPG
    IMG_7148.JPG
    484.6 KB · Views: 212
Thought I'd share my experience with my MacBook 5,1 late 2008 aluminium which might help someone along the line. Did a fresh install (booting from USB made with Dosdude's util). After the install I used Dosdude's tool and selecting the Recovery partition patch option. On first boot track pad or keyboard didn't work.

I fixed this by rebooting from USB, running the tool, didn't select Recovery partition patch, and then ticked the Force cache rebuild. Trackpad, keyboard, wifi, and isight camera all seem to work.

I also got my MacPro 3,1 up and running, cheated and ran the install from my 2009 Mac Pro 4,1. Then ran the tool and all booted up fine on my 2008.

Thanks Dosdude1!
 
Thought I'd share my experience with my MacBook 5,1 late 2008 aluminium which might help someone along the line. Did a fresh install (booting from USB made with Dosdude's util). After the install I used Dosdude's tool and selecting the Recovery partition patch option. On first boot track pad or keyboard didn't work.

I fixed this by rebooting from USB, running the tool, didn't select Recovery partition patch, and then ticked the Force cache rebuild. Trackpad, keyboard, wifi, and isight camera all seem to work.

I also got my MacPro 3,1 up and running, cheated and ran the install from my 2009 Mac Pro 4,1. Then ran the tool and all booted up fine on my 2008.

Thanks Dosdude1!
ha! Great. You used Target Disk Mode from pro to pro?
 
Sorry yes, I meant the usb flash drive, I've tried 3 different drives. I actually can't even get into the installer it just shows me the slashed circle everytime I try to boot from the usb.

So you have successfully and fully installed the macOS Sierra installer on three different flash drives, and each time that you have tried to boot from those same three flash drives, you have gotten the prohibited symbol?

Exactly how do you select to boot from the flash drive?

What is the size of your flash drives?

Are you certain that you are not trying to boot from a corrupted internal hard drive, that is, from a corrupted startup drive on your actual machine?

Just a few basic questions to get an idea of what might be going on there.
 
Thought I'd share my experience with my MacBook 5,1 late 2008 aluminium which might help someone along the line. Did a fresh install (booting from USB made with Dosdude's util). After the install I used Dosdude's tool and selecting the Recovery partition patch option. On first boot track pad or keyboard didn't work.

I fixed this by rebooting from USB, running the tool, didn't select Recovery partition patch, and then ticked the Force cache rebuild. Trackpad, keyboard, wifi, and isight camera all seem to work.

I also got my MacPro 3,1 up and running, cheated and ran the install from my 2009 Mac Pro 4,1. Then ran the tool and all booted up fine on my 2008.

Thanks Dosdude1!

Please update us about how macOS Sierra performs on your Mac Pro 2008 3,1 mate :)

Once I hear from you, I will update mine according to the methods listed down by dosdude1 :)

Does your wifi work? I'm using an Atheros firmware wifi airport card, hopefully it works on mine. Also, do you have the updated Nvidia web driver with you before you perform the update?
 
"Think Different" is long gone. That said, we are supporting ourselves...hurrah!

But thinking different is exactly what WE are doing, even if Apple no longer is. I mean, you have to think different and be a bit of a renegade to do what we are doing here. :)

Yeah, as I have said before. I have never been hoodwinked by Apple's "coolness" factor. I've realized all along that they are just another business, and that in the end, it is all just about the profit margin.
 
Please update us about how macOS Sierra performs on your Mac Pro 2008 3,1 mate :)

Once I hear from you, I will update mine according to the methods listed down by dosdude1 :)

Does your wifi work? I'm using an Atheros firmware wifi airport card, hopefully it works on mine. Also, do you have the updated Nvidia web driver with you before you perform the update?
I'm on macPro 3,1 2008 8 core and Sierra works Great!
Updated using @dosdude1 's tool continuously from inception dp1 to GM.
Haven't yet taken the plunge to Sierra final (on that system)
So over a month of banging on it with pre-released versions and GM and never crashed.
what works:
iSight (Firewire)
ethernet
external USB
external Firewire
internal SSD
recently changed:
wifi + bt card
graphics card (not Sierra related just a sorely needed upgrade to GTX 680 from original 8800GT)
 
Wow, I guess I didn't even think of people at Apple looking through this forum, but I guess it makes sense... I also didn't think they would be specifically malicious to block attempts like this (after all we are still all running on Apple Hardware which we payed them for)

Personally, I have considered it to be a real possibility from the start. The way that we end users look at things, and the way that Apple looks at things is very different. While starry-eyed fanboys may think that Apple can do no wrong and lose sleep over upcoming Apple events, in Apple's eyes, what we are doing here actually cuts into their sales, because we are making it possible for Mac users to continue using their old machines for longer than Apple wants them to use them. They want to force us to upgrade to new, shiny machines. It is as if they have silently declared "We will let end users use their machines for five to seven years, and then they must upgrade."

It is just like radio station or TV station owners. We may think that the songs are cool, or the shows are cool, but from their perspective, they are trying to earn money through advertising. Songs and shows are just the bait. I was once a radio DJ decades ago, so I know the real score.

Apple is the very same way. They try to sell us on the "coolness" factor.
 
I'm on macPro 3,1 2008 8 core and Sierra works Great!
Updated using @dosdude1 's tool continuously from inception dp1 to GM.
Haven't yet taken the plunge to Sierra final (on that system)
So over a month of banging on it with pre-released versions and GM and never crashed.
what works:
iSight (Firewire)
ethernet
external USB
external Firewire
internal SSD
recently changed:
wifi + bt card
graphics card (not Sierra related just a sorely needed upgrade to GTX 680 from original 8800GT)

Thank you for the update. I have the same system as you have. I have done my updates on two MacBook Pro's the mid-2009 and mid-2010. They both work terrific! Now, I'm currently preparing the update for my Mac Pro 3,1. Wish me luck mate :) I will share my woes and success here when I'm done. Cheers.
 
Thank you for the update. I have the same system as you have. I have done my updates on two MacBook Pro's the mid-2009 and mid-2010. They both work terrific! Now, I'm currently preparing the update for my Mac Pro 3,1. Wish me luck mate :) I will share my woes and success here when I'm done. Cheers.
Yes keep us posted. Good luck.
 
IMHO, they make billions every quarter, mostly through the sweat of external developers and over-priced hardware. Instead of hoarding cash in Irish banks, they could have easily dedicated extra resources in support of perfectly good systems.

Ouch! pkouame holds nothing back! :)

Would make those of us who plunked down thousands over the years happy loyal customers.

Indeed! As I have mentioned before, since I first became an actual Mac owner in 1993, I have spent considerably more money on Mac computers, Mac peripherals, Mac software, etc., than on any other thing in my entire life . . . well, besides things like rent, utilities and food, of course. I have spent more money on Macs than on cars, and on Macs than on medical bills. So, yes, I agree that Apple owes us in that regard.

I'll admit that my systems are fairly old, circa 2008-9, but at the very least they could make it easier for us to support ourselves right? Redemption codes, firewalls for developer releases etc...is all just paranoid madness.

But paranoia has been their modus operandi since day one. I can understand protecting trade secrets, but I agree that Apple has been way too heavy-handed in some regards. I tend to think that it is because they have become too big. When you become that big, you begin to make whatever rules you want, and you don't care what your end users think.

Especially since the beta test programs benefit them so much.

Indeed. We are what make their products better.

I for one am not expecting Apple Support for my hardware, never have. No Genius Bar needed here.

I am pretty much the same way. I use my machines until I run them into the ground. In the 26+ years that I have been a Mac user, I can count on one hand the times that I have taken in a Mac for repair. I have never stepped up to a Genius Bar. I don't even know what one looks like. :)

Going back to your angst about moving to Sierra. One should carefully consider their need to upgrade.

Agreed. Considering how old this machine is -- 7 3/4 years -- I could have easily stayed on El Capitan until this machine dies completely. But I am a bit crazy in that regard, and sometimes I like to live on the edge, even though I really shouldn't, since I run a web server here.

But for the average Joe, El Capitan (has) run just fine and the UI/UX changes are not significant.

Again, agreed. I didn't upgrade for one single one of Apple's new toys or flashy new features -- although I was hoping that Siri would be a lot better than it is. I mainly upgraded for any possible stability and security improvements.

As always, back-up back-up back-up and then back-up again. Then playing with a shiny new OS is not as stressful.

If there is one golden rule of computing, backup has to be it. I have also harped on this same issue for years now. When you are dealing with buggy betas and GMs, it is crazy, and in fact irresponsible, to operate any other way. We have no one to blame but ourselves if we lose important data.

You may be perfectly happy with 10.12.x for example for another year. Your mileage may vary...

Yep . . . for many of us, this will be the last OS on our current machines. Then it will be money crunch time. This is my last working machine, after all.
 
Hallo Freunde

dosdude1 HaBen auf Ihrer Webseite: http://dosdude1.com/sierrapatch.html ein foto von supportet und nicht WiFi BCM4321 Karte supportet.
Hier ist mein Screenshot aus El Capitan 10.11.6 (in Sierra is not available) von meinem Wificard in macmini3,1 Ende 2009
da stirbt ein anders foto dosdude1 .... warum ist das?
im bedeuten: 0x90 nicht, Dass wir auf foto 0x8C oder 0x8D

Hat jemand eine Idee, sterben warum Werte Unterschiedlich Sind von mir?
 

Attachments

  • My WiFi-BCM4321.png
    My WiFi-BCM4321.png
    417.7 KB · Views: 232
Last edited:
Hallo Freunde

dosdude1 HaBen auf Ihrer Webseite: http://dosdude1.com/sierrapatch.html ein foto von supportet und nicht WiFi BCM4321 Karte supportet.
Hier ist mein Screenshot aus El Capitan 10.11.6 (in Sierra is not available) von meinem Wificard in macmini3,1 Ende 2009
da stirbt ein anders foto dosdude1 .... warum ist das?
im bedeuten: 0x90 nicht, Dass wir auf foto 0x8C oder 0x8D

Hat jemand eine Idee, sterben warum Werte Unterschiedlich Sind von mir?
I can't understand what you said, but I'm pretty sure the BCM4321 is only hardware is 0x8C... You say you're using a MacMini3,1?
 
Yes keep us posted. Good luck.

+pkouame and +dosdude1,

I forgot to mention that I have a GTX750 with my Mac Pro 2008, and I don't have a boot screen EFI due to the fact that my card that came with the mac pro HD2600XT was burnt and spoilt. Any idea how do I upgrade the OS through USB update method proposed by +dosdude1? Will I be able to boot from the USB without EFI screen? Or should I remove my SSD from the Mac Pro 2008, update it using a macbook pro 2010, and then shift it back to the Mac Pro 2008? Would it work that way? Cheers.
 
+pkouame and +dosdude1,

I forgot to mention that I have a GTX750 with my Mac Pro 2008, and I don't have a boot screen EFI due to the fact that my card that came with the mac pro HD2600XT was burnt and spoilt. Any idea how do I upgrade the OS through USB update method proposed by +dosdude1? Will I be able to boot from the USB without EFI screen? Or should I remove my SSD from the Mac Pro 2008, update it using a macbook pro 2010, and then shift it back to the Mac Pro 2008? Would it work that way? Cheers.
You need an EFI flashed graphics card, you won't be able to see anything even when the installer boots.
 
You need an EFI flashed graphics card, you won't be able to see anything even when the installer boots.
Can I take out the SSD from the mac pro, insert it to a macbook pro 2010, update it, and then put it back in the mac pro 2008? Also, do you know if my wifi card would work? Picture of the wifi card specs as attached.

Screen_Shot_2016_09_24_at_06_51_31.png
 
Can I take out the SSD from the mac pro, insert it to a macbook pro 2010, update it, and then put it back in the mac pro 2008? Also, do you know if my wifi card would work? Picture of the wifi card specs as attached.

Screen_Shot_2016_09_24_at_06_51_31.png
Yeah, you can do that. Just make sure to run the post-install patch on the volume after you install. And yes, your WiFi card should work fine.
 
dosdude 1 it's true, it is a Mac mini 3,1 late 2009, and the image is of El Capitan 10.11.6

here jat Someone another problem, but you can also see it here in the mac mini3,1 well as a card in it is:
https://discussions.apple.com/thread/2731693?tstart=0
With me but works in El capitan 5GHz and WiFi n Standart properly.
Only it is not so rare that the macmini 3.1 late 2009 those cards have it. so I'm not the only one with such a card.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.