Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
No sorry don't see the risk in a plastic cover..... might be stupid to bring one, but if checks are done correctly it should be spotted that it is not a gun....

Your levels of justification for this are astounding.

This isn't a vaguely gun shaped object (and do you walk around carrying hair dryers sticking out of your pocket?). The entire point of this case is to be confused for a gun sticking out of your pocket, in a crowded public area where people will likely notice and panic.

Even if you your hypothesis that it's super easy for metal detectors to determine a fake (yes, let's just casually not worry about the dude with the gun looking object while he waits in line to go through security), how do you propose everyone else in the airport cope?

Do you propose they issue a special "don't worry everyone this gun is not real" badge for the person to carry around, and maintain a "it's safe not to disregard civilian reports because we already cleared it" list amongst personnel through the the airport? or do you propose everyone at airports should just chill when they see a gun handle sticking out because security MUST have caught it?

Surely we must figure something out because wanting to look like you're carrying a gun in an airport is a fundamental human rights issue.
 
Not justifying the guy, but I expect
1) a "professional" to distinguish a real from a fake
2) a metal detector to identify a real gun (in case number 3 is not followed)
3) an Xray to see trought the plastic and see if it is a real one (yes cellphones have to be passed in the xray machine and not in your pocket.)

So IF the officers do the right job, then there should be no alarm!

All in all I think .....a slow news day.

I work on the other side of a shipping ports security so same procedures as a airport.
1 - it could be a weapon that they have not seen before or a home made weapon - They DO NOT KNOW THIS - the police run a fail safe system.
2 3- Yes a Metal detector/XRAY to could see through it but it is an OFFENCE to imitate a weapon as such! Toys are coloured here to make them clear they are toys. Also it appears that this is before XRAY and that the police before security so as far as they knew that could be a weapon in it.

The police operate on a fail safe system. Imagine if it was a gun? Someone was killed? You will be saying that the police did not do their job properly also.

This guy was a tit for it. He broke the law for just having it out of his pocket like a real gun as it imitates one. This is not America. We are much more cautious to guns and we don't see them as a freedom. No one carries a gun around to protect themselves in the UK.

The police did 100% their job here and though this was a false alarm, this guy was carrying something that imitates something that causes alarm.

Remember, DAESH and other terror groups are constantly looking at ways of getting through security...
 
Naw, this was as flagrant as being on a plane and yelling "BOMB".

I'm not saying the guy involved was necessarily (or even likely to have been, IMHO) using that iPhone case as some kind of political statement, lol (probably just someone who foolishly thought it was a 'cool' case). I'm sure MR aren't saying that either! I think they're just saying discussing this story has obviously political aspects to it. If there wasn't any "political nature" to the discussion, it would be a non-story, because no-one would have cared what shape his iPhone case was, or even if he had been carrying an actual gun.
 
Sooo it's not okay to have a phone case that's shaped like a gun but it's okay to have a gun shaped like a phone?
What if I eat my kid nibbles his pop tart into a gun? Would they arrest him?
Insane. It's not the gun that is evil folks. Very rarely does a gun go off by itself and kill anyone. It's 99.999% the other way around.

http://money.cnn.com/2016/03/21/news/gun-smartphone-ideal-conceal-carry/

Guns don't kill people. Bullets do.

And that .001% (it's a higher percentage, by the way) is a lot of innocent people.
 
Nope i said 50% with a hair dryer.....
The analogy was dumb regardless... unless your carrying the hair dryer in your pocket or have it tucked in your pants.:rolleyes:

The idea of a gun shaped phone case is completely stupid. You needlessly put yourself and, worse, others in a potentially dangerous situation for what? Pulling that case out to answer a phone looks just like drawing a weapon. Even worse the case doesn't have the orange barrel tip indicating it's not real. It's textbook "asking for trouble". To buy and wear something like this (especially in an airport) requires the level on the stupid and irresponsible dial to be cranked to 11.
 
good concept, but it won't fit an iPhone.

I guess the presumption is, "ask for the bullets later". Can't tell what's real and what's not ?
 
Its one thing to detain him "while we inspect the case" but then let him go when we find out "oh, lt's safe"
 
It is silly that they produce such thing..... but to risk because of a toy? I mean they check this kind of stuff and then the real deal does not get detected.....


How could you put peole in danger by carrying a case???


People have committed "armed" robbery using toy guns. Now try that on an airplane...
[doublepost=1467902216][/doublepost]
This so dumb but legal

Carrying four ounces of hair gel through airport security is illegal. Why would carrying a fake firearm in an airport be legal?
 
  • Like
Reactions: amirite
You have to be a moron to use those.

Police or criminals might shoot you thinking you're a threat.

Nobody will be intimidated since they'll realize you're an idiot the moment you remove your phone to answer a call or post a selfie to social media.

Bulky.

Bastard went full retard.

Can we please drop "retard" as a synonym for "dumb"? I have a close family member who is mentally retarded. There is a huge difference between her daily plight and this stupidity.
 
How could you put peole in danger by carrying a case???

He's putting his life in danger. Say he gets surrounded by cops, weapons drawn, ready to make the fire/don't fire decision in the blink of an eye. He wants to show the cops it's only a cell phone case, and nothing to worry about, so he reaches for it.

He'd be lucky to survive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: robeddie
Imitation, replica and airsoft are also banned under most circumstances, toy guns have to be painted bright colours to be allowed.

Its not quite that clear cut..... You can buy imitation/replica/airsoft if you're over 18.

What americans would call "open carry" of imitation/replica/airsoft has its own law in the UK and is banned. So yeah you can buy them, you can own them, you can shoot them, but not in public.
 
I have no idea what would possess someone to have one of these. They're inconvenient and dangerous.

And for the record, I'm a major 2nd amendment supporter. This isn't about guns per se but about mimicking carrying the real thing. In some places (Nevada, Wyoming, Texas) that might not be a big deal because open carry is normal. In the London airport? Not such a good move.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vmistery and miknos
Its not quite that clear cut..... You can buy imitation/replica/airsoft if you're over 18.

What americans would call "open carry" of imitation/replica/airsoft has its own law in the UK and is banned. So yeah you can buy them, you can own them, you can shoot them, but not in public.
But its a illegal to open carry them also - the same laws apply to fire arms and imitation in the sense of transport
 
I have a concealed carry permit. I often have my handgun within reach (unless I am in an area marked "Victims Inside" (or sometimes "No Guns Allowed"). But concealed means no one can see it. You don't know I have it and that's the way it is supposed to be. This case is just nuts. I would only consider it in a state that allowed open carry everywhere, and even then I wouldn't. The only thing this case can do is get you in trouble, and it can't get you out of trouble.

And in an airport? Insane.
 
Are you saying i cannot hife a gun in a hairdryer??

Are you saying that if they cannot spot a plastic cover from the real thing they will be able to discover my modified hairdryer?

Again IF checks are done correctly there should be no alarm!


Given what happens lately I know that checks are NOT done correctly and that is the problem, NOT a plastic cover.

IF checks are done 100% correctly AND post-check-in airport security has 100% confidence in those checks AND flight attendants PLUS every single passenger have 100% confidence that the checks would have weeded out a real weapon... then, yes, everyone would just truly believe that thing sticking out of his belt was a toy, and act accordingly.

Do you honestly believe it is possible or feasible for check-in security to be so effective that everyone should just assume something that appears to be a gun is not?

Would you?
 
Can we please drop "retard" as a synonym for "dumb"? I have a close family member who is mentally retarded. There is a huge difference between her daily plight and this stupidity.

Not a wrong definition. He acted like a 5 year old kid. Even if he were a teenager, I would call retardation.
 
I have no idea what would possess someone to have one of these. They're inconvenient and dangerous.

And for the record, I'm a major 2nd amendment supporter. This isn't about guns per se but about mimicking carrying the real thing. In some places (Nevada, Wyoming, Texas) that might not be a big deal because open carry is normal. In the London airport? Not such a good move.
Carrying this in an airport in Nevada, Wyoming, or Texas is equally irresponsible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vmistery
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.