It is with great pain that I agree....
And in many ways, Microsoft has surpassed Apple in innovation.
Given that your forum name is "MacAddict", I can only image how much it huts you to say that. I have been a rabid Apple fan myself since 2008. Apple, through its products and events, has inspired me in ways that Microsoft seldom could. Now, even that gap is closing.
I had to install windows 8 under bootcamp for a class I have coming up, and my XBox One eased me into the tiles a bit... (which i never really liked...) but they are actually highly useful bits.
I test drove a Windows 8 laptop back in Fall 2013 for a week. It wasn't at all a bad experience once I figured out where everything was. The tiles system is a neat idea.
I think Win8 has a bit of an identity crisis even still (and its hard adjusting to hot keys on a mac for windows) but it's actually a really decent OS now that I've actually used it vs. bashing it without really knowing it. MS really has gone in a direction I thought Apple would have been the leader in, and Windows 10 seems to really have ironed out the lack of harmony between touch and keyboard and mouse use.
I haven't looked into this much. I'm sure I will when it is released.
I would love to be able to pop the display off my MacBook at times... or touch it.... touch has become a much more natural response to things. After I've been on my tablet, I do find the transition odd going back to my Mac. The iPad just still does not cut it as a true productivity device.
I so hear you on the desire to pull the display off my MacBook and carry it around. The problem is, sure, it could be engineered to do that, but then you have a heavy tablet. While this may be better than no tablet in many cases, the pounds add up quickly. I don't own an iPad, but I've played with them plenty enough to appreciate how touching the screen to move an object is more natural than using a mouse. Sometimes, though, I need the precision that the mouse offers. Tim Cooke says he can get 80% of everything he needs done on his iPad. I wonder if that is true for most users.
Win8 really has a bit more elegant mix of doc and mission control type layout, and more logical.
Yet for as much as I like about it, the identity crisis (do I want to be a metro app, a classic desktop app, or a decent hybrid like Chrome) is just still too awkward for me to say I would consider a Windows machine as a primary purchase.
It really is hard for Apple to justify the hardware costs considering the wide price gap vs. performance these days. That "it just works" classic mac appeal waned with the death of power pc. Yet Mac's still have a bit more logical work flow and ease of use.
Microsoft still hasn't quite learned to make a simple task 1 or 2 steps like apple. They still love you to take 9 clicks through screens to adjust a setting or do something simple.
I think I can agree with everything in this block.
Might now break down and buy a winbox, but bootcamp worth windows has become.
Let the hate rain on this post, but I really bashed the hell out of Windows 8 and then I actually used it.... not perfect, but definitely a mile run in the right direction. I honestly can't say that about OSX. The only real new feature was handoff, and it's really not that useful. OSX has mainly seen under the hood changes, lipstick, but not taken an evolutionary leap since maybe Leopard. Leopard was really that last release that felt satisfyingly new in features and experience. The most major shift has really been tabbed finder and the stop light buttons actually.... work like windows! 😱
I don't see why this should spark hate except from the immature. Computers are just tools that we use to solve problems. I have admitted from the beginning that you can accomplish most everything you would want to do on a Mac or a PC, depending on how much effort you put in. The user experience might be more enjoyable on a Mac in many ways. Sometimes less so (where is the cut and paste for Finder after 15 years!?).
Thank you very much for this thoughtful answer to my question.