To be objective, if you are looking for a tablet first, the iPad is much better. The iPad is the best tablet you can buy. If your need is for more of a true laptop computer with the bonus of occasional use in tablet mode, then the Surface would be a better choice. It all depends on your needs, and also whether or not you are a Windows user. The two devices are not direct competitors, despite whatever the advertisement says. An iPad versus a Surface is an apples versus oranges comparison. I own both an iPad mini and a 13 inch Windows notebook that has a tablet mode. Both are excellent devices, but are for different uses. I use them both heavily.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Microsoft Pits Surface Pro 7 Against iPad Pro, Says Surface is 'Still the Better Choice'
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The Surface Pro 7+ has an LTE model.
They're not wrong, but they're missing the point. If you're looking for a Windows machine get a Surface. If you're looking for iOS then get an iPad.
If you're looking for a tablet computer then the choice isn't as straightforward...but maybe you should start with a cheap Amazon tablet or an iPad and see how it works out.
If you're looking for a tablet computer then the choice isn't as straightforward...but maybe you should start with a cheap Amazon tablet or an iPad and see how it works out.
😂Until the surface run window I prefer to spend 10k on another device and adding 1k more for a stand.
I like my iPhone 12 Pro as my daily driver, my iPad mini for media content, but my Surface Pro X for all other stuff where I need/want to use my mouse and I know I am going to be sitting down for awhile, extended researches, writing on my personal blog, updating hobby site, travel planning etc. I like my Mac Mini for creating family videos since most of my media is on my iPhone. One is not really better than another, I just use what I need depending on what I'm doing.
Yes, but you know the second Apple comes out with their own MacOS tablet (and you know they will eventually), people here will go ape**** over it and how revolutionary it is.
Better choice... ...with an intel mobile chip? 😂 Good luck with the fingering, though.
A single device that has no compromises doesn’t exist. And if I need to use a computer running Windows I would never use anything other than a laptop or desktop.
There’s no PC vendor that sells more mobile systems than Apple sells iPads and Apple STILL has lots of room to grow.
What Microsoft should have done....
See, with a Microsoft surface tablet, you can minimize your work, switch to something else, come back later and hey, it's still there ready for yout to finish, app doesn't suddenly 'forget itself'.
With an ipad, look lets minimize our work, switch to something else, but when you come back, oh look, app has reset itself and totally forgotten where you were at. Hope you saved that work somewhere else to pick back up.
See, with a Microsoft surface tablet, you can minimize your work, switch to something else, come back later and hey, it's still there ready for yout to finish, app doesn't suddenly 'forget itself'.
With an ipad, look lets minimize our work, switch to something else, but when you come back, oh look, app has reset itself and totally forgotten where you were at. Hope you saved that work somewhere else to pick back up.
If iPad wasn’t beating every other laptop in sales, they MIGHT have went in that direction. As it is, the only folks that want a macOS tablet (complete with non-tablet optimized apps) are folks that grew up on macOS. That market is small and shrinking everyday.
Funny! “Many people wanted me to compare...” Did people call Microsoft and ask for that kid to do this comparison since his first appearance?
Don’t get why they create commercials where they try to make him appear like a youtuber. Dora any work, at all...
Don’t get why they create commercials where they try to make him appear like a youtuber. Dora any work, at all...
Last edited:
One with icons that can be organized in little pictures of folders on a desktop, I’m guessing.
We have three touchscreen PC's in our household, a Dell all-in-one desktop with a 27" screen, a Dell 15" laptop, and a Samsung Galaxy Book Flex Alpha 13.3" 2-in-1, primarily used by my husband. He never, ever uses the touchscreen on any of them. Even my kids, who are used to their iPads and iPhones (and touchscreen Chromebooks issued by their schools), when they very occasionally use the Dell desktop and Dell laptop, surprisingly never reach for the screen.
Weighing in on the original theme of this discussion, I have found that I can get absolutely everything done for my work on my combo of an 11" iPad Pro, Smart Keyboard Folio, and Apple Pencil. Granted, I know that not everybody can, but for my work purposes I can and I would love an iPad Pro with an even bigger 15" screen, paired with a Magic Keyboard and Apple Pencil. The combo has the perfect versatility I want, in that I never use a case with my iPad and I love being able to simply and quickly attach and un-attach the keyboard based on whether I want to get work done, or have some leisure time/entertainment. I actually just sold my 11" iPad Pro to purchase the (hopefully-soon-to-be-out) 12.9" with Magic Keyboard, and hopefully sometime in the future Apple will come out with a bigger iPad Pro which will be a day one purchase for me.
I bought my husband the Surface Pro (the biggest screen size, with the best specs), along with the keyboard and pen, and we both used it extensively for a few weeks (I really wanted to get a feel for it and give it a chance, see what it was like to use on a daily basis, although it was really for my husband). We both disliked it immensely. And my husband uses PC's regularly. As many people have said, it was not a good tablet when we used it in tablet mode, and not a good laptop in laptop mode, but a sort of compromise between the two. The touch interface was nowhere near as good and smooth as on the iPad; same goes when using the Surface Pen vs. Apple Pencil. My husband said the laptop/PC experience was far superior on his Samsung laptop; I felt the tablet experience was basically crap on the Surface and leaps and bounds better on the iPad. My husband would frequently just go back to using his Samsung laptop and I'd go back to my iPad Pro/keyboard/Pencil. Needless to say we returned the Surface Pro.
If it's just a big iPhone to you, you're not using it to its fullest capability.
Yeah no. I used to run a laptop and an iPad, but now am running an iPad and M1 Mini. I just don't need a laptop anymore. For anything out and about, the iPad is great. Music, photos, video, reading, docs, remote support, etc.
And those magnets are STRONG, too, as I’m reminded every time some metal ends up attached to my device LOL Are there vendors aware of your requirements that work to meet your needs? With many systems using magnets for fairly trivial tasks, I’d guess there’s few that your folks can use.
Video does have good points. Surface form factor, kickstand and keyboard are better than iPad Pro and rubbish magic keyboard. No way I'm paying $1100+ for a dumbed down and locked down iPad Pro that's only barely decent for consumption. That said I would skip the Surface Pro 7 and get the Surface Pro 7+ or wait for Surface Pro 8 and hope it comes with AMD instead of Intel.
I agree with all of that as far as usability goes. There's no technical reason the iPad line needs to exist alongside the Mac line. But it seems like Apple has found it more profitable to do that.
Last edited:
I really wish iPadOS had the ability to create encrypted containers -- like how you can create an encrypted disk image on a Mac using Disk Utility. I'm sure it's not heavily requested, but that's one of the top features that would make it a more capable, computer-like device in my eyes.