Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Windows has come a long way. It's a lot better than what people think.

As someone that HAS to use it for high end video and 3d work. Utterly disagree. It's a complete mess still...
Multiple UI types
Duplicate Apps for those
utterly confusing Settings / control panels with duplicate information everywhere
Notifications are terrible
The cluster fudge that is the Windows registry
UI elements from windows NT still exist. As MS can not bring themselves to Obsolete something from 1999 in case it kills some Corporate client.

Basically IF you have it set up and working. Never touch it again is my motto. Turn off auto updates apart from the MANY MANY MANY security updates. I went away for 6 weeks and came back to 120 updates...and guess what machine wouldn't boot.
 
Last edited:
So I'm a little confused.

For 13.5" Surface Book vs 13" MacBook Pro, it's 10 hour battery life is 70% longer than the MBP's 10 hour battery life? And according to the specs on Microsofts website, it says HD 620 graphics, not UHD 620, which means its based on the same Kaby lake 7th gen and not the current 8th gen refresh ones, and this same generation cpu is twice as fast? It remains to be seen if they are using the U or M variant I suppose.

The baseline model appears to be mostly the same specs internally as the 13" MBP 256gb sans-touch bar, for the exact same price. The Mac for that price has a pretty substantial bump with the iris plus graphics vs the HD 620, and I'd be willing to wager cash that the SSD in the 2017 13" MBP is significantly faster as well.

Devil's advocate though, Microsofts simple option for a GTX 1050 gpu in 13" makes it a pretty compelling option, and the 15" models do seem to have some better specs for similar pricing. This is probably where the 2x as fast comes from, but I still have some doubts.

The $1,999 13.5" with the GTX 1050 2 GB has an i7-8650U, which is Kaby Lake Refresh, so 4 cores and 8 threads.
 
I find it amusing how someone could treat Windows as such as POS OS, when it's powering so many businesses (particularly financial services) responsible for trillions upon trillions.

The OS isn't that complicated, or rubbish - and let's not pretend macOS is some kind of perfect OS either.

Anecdotal, but I've had a couple of Mac users tell me that spending the extra money over an OSX system, but saving on maintenance, ends up being a wash in the end. Their point? Don't get either b/c they're cheaper. Don't let that be the main reason. Get the one you'd want to use.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LordVic and bwintx
I find it amusing how someone could treat Windows as such as POS OS, when it's powering so many businesses (particularly financial services) responsible for trillions upon trillions.

The OS isn't that complicated, or rubbish - and let's not pretend macOS is some kind of perfect OS either.

And they are running VERY locked down custom version of windows... Probably windows 7 still infact. The fact that windows is customisable is it's biggest asset and it's worst failing. Virus's aplenty and old components.

Companies with any real idea with actually use Linux... as it's free.
 
This Surface Book 2 smartly targets some of the MBP's "shortcomings".
(USB 3.1 port, dedicated GPU, and an SD Card slot)

Apple could have achieved what Microsoft has done here, had they simply not given into form over function.
A few mm thicker MBP could have made all the difference.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yvan256
How i wish Apple would make the same thing, would be so useful for me personally, but no, we have the Touchbar... Yay!
 
I find it amusing how someone could treat Windows as such as POS OS, when it's powering so many businesses (particularly financial services) responsible for trillions upon trillions.

The OS isn't that complicated, or rubbish - and let's not pretend macOS is some kind of perfect OS either.

That does not mean its any better.
 
I think it can definitely work if the experience is just as good on both. I have used a windows "tablet" before and it is a pretty poor experience. Now if Apple could build a device like this that ran macOS and pulled off to be an iOS tablet, it would be the best of both worlds. I don't see Apple ever doing this though.

Yeah they should make it just in the smallest form factor, and then have the MBP be the full laptop devices.

I bet like most things apple does that they eventually build this device, despite how they keep saying they won't right now. At some point laptops will become thin enough that it becomes possible (like on this surface), and apple will have nowhere else to go.
 
Windows has come a long way. It's a lot better than what people think.
Totally! In preparation for the latest update, I was asked if I wanted ads personalized to me or randomized!

Choice in action right there folks! Don’t you wish Apple gave you choices?!?

windows10privacy-1-100716754-orig.jpg
 
Wow, slow down there Hobe1. You are mixing Apples and oranges. This survey isn't Consumer Reports opinion, but rather the results of consumers. I don't think any objective person would be comfortable with the reported, by consumers, of 25% of the Surface having reliability problems.

But it does say that that changed CR's opinion to negative on Surface. And this crowd found so much fault with CR's opinion when it was negative on one Apple product. So double negative, thus (we should be) positive on this Surface? ;)

Personally, I'm heavily Apple myself... but I do have many friends with Wintel and none of them seem to suffer nearly as much as the cumulative sentiment of threads like this imply. When I have to fire up bootcamp or Parallels to use Windows (because some software still only runs on Windows), I had to admit that it doesn't feel nearly as bad as implied by the sentiment to me either.

AND as Apple seems to be in a mode of regularly raising prices while cutting hardware utility, it's not so hard to imagine that one can get better hardware "guts" for much less money too.

Of course, I fully expect this thread to basically run with every possible thing- real or imagined- wrong with Windows, Microsoft and anything else that is not Apple that can be associated with this product but there is a whole world not so mentally married to Apple... that seems to do just fine and prosper using non-Apple stuff.

I know. I know. For some that's probably harder to believe than just about anything else one could say or write. What percentage of the world runs on Wintel vs. Mac? Does such a large number of the world seem miserable and unable to accomplish their computing objectives? How are they surviving without Macs?
 
Looking at the specs for 13" MBP with dual core processor, maybe they claim twice as powerful with the 8th gen Quad core chip and better graphics card.

And Windows10 is not my bag. Even after shutting off Cortana and all the data mining bs, not a fan. I will use it to learn what I need for a job and at work, but otherwise I will stick with :apple: for all home and creative use as long as they show the Macs and OS some love, care, better QC and decent price points going forward (yeah those wishes are inline with their mythical "pipeline.")
 
13 inch Macbook Pro with Touch Bar - $1799

CPU: i5-7287U (2 cores 4 threads)
GPU: Intel Iris Plus 650
RAM: 8 GB LPDDR3
SSD: 256 GB

13.5 inch Surface Book 2 - $1999

CPU: i7-8650U (4 cores 8 threads)
GPU: GTX 1050 with 2 GB GDDR5
RAM: 8 GB LPDDR3
SSD: 256 GB
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DJ_S
lol at all the windows hate out there.

Personally, I don't like MacOS... Windows is much more easier. But I still prefer IOS for phone. I'm a weird person, but each his own opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: udayan81
I love it when Microsoft points out the performance difference between the surfaces and the MBPs. Like they are 100% identical machines.
 
Ho Hum, with Microsoft rumored to be getting out of the hardware business all together. Is this the last big announcement? Surface products have not been reliable hardware according to many.
 
lol at all the windows hate out there.

Personally, I don't like MacOS... Windows is much more easier. But I still prefer IOS for phone. I'm a weird person, but each his own opinion.

You must not have used OS X much then, because once you learn it, it's a hundred times easier all around. Quickly get to apps, browse, find stuff, troubleshoot, etc.
 
The hinge is horrible

Kinda horrible like the IPhone X's animoji gap....

To all the folks saying "But it runs Windows"... how many of you have installed BootCamp to be able to run Windows applications? How many of you are even real power users? Seriously... quit the nitpicking. Each operating system has their pro's and con's. Microsoft releasing a better Surface Book is nothing but GOOD for Apple, because it creates competition. IMO, Apple needs to release a real touch screen based MacBook Pro, they can't get by with that TouchBar on the next gen release. They need to start innovating with their computers, NOT just their handheld devices.

They still haven't answered the Surface Studio, did people forget how awesome that is for artists and photographers? That product will only get better with time (Have any of you ever seen one and tried one out in person... it is a AWESOME product).

Competition is good. The Surface Book 2 being released with some current hardware and specs is good. Soon people will start saying things like "That MacBook Pro 15" was $2,500 and it doesn't have a touch screen...?"

Touch screens are not going anywhere, they are becoming a standard. My kids always try and touch our old MacBook Pro thinking it will work like the iPad. Its a thing folks. Apple needs to adapt. OSX needs to adapt and so does the hardware.

Kudos to Microsoft for making the Surface Book more powerful while keeping it the same product (the hinge, the detachable display, etc.)... shame on Apple for releasing that lame TouchBar "feature" and then charging more for it (13" lineup), acting like its a game changer. They should have made it a standard on the Pro line up across the board while keeping the pricing the same. The only good thing about it is being able to unlock the computer with your finger... is that worth the $400+ premium?
 
Last edited:
Surface? Surface Pro? Surface Book? I understand the need for multiple model lines, but the naming schemes are getting wonky as the Iph8 and IphX/Iph10.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.