Like anything , it's got pros and cons , overall the echo is a winner for me. I have an elderly grandmother who cannot use computers of any sort, the echo and echo show are game changes for communication purposes with her family. I'll just buy echo dots and post them globally around the world so they can just communicate , for me this is massive , just by saying "call x"
I just can' t grasp why apple has to make standalone Siri speaker with a (small) screen, while all their idevices also have a screen and microphones, it is just not apple's way. There must be more to it.
They could make a dedicated system/speaker with already advanced microphones, but can also combine your voiceinput from the microphones of all your i devices, to improve the understanding of voice commands , and a very fast router with the latest and fastest wifi you can get, so it can push screen content very fast/instantly to your iphone/ipad/whatever.
It is also possible that the speaker will also be an Apple TV or have a dedicated connection to an Apple TV, so the big screen will become your display.
And perhaps you can set preferences , so you can choose, which display is your favorite for displaying content, or you can choose to let the system decide by tracking which device is closest to you or on which device you are currently working.
But there is more to it than just a speaker with a screen, like amazon, i don' t need the speaker to have a big screen for FaceTime or displaying YouTube, i already have an ipad for that.
[doublepost=1494758277][/doublepost]
I recall you saying in a previous post how An active display would benefit your grandmother/smart speaker capabilities. That's a good point and active display would be more suitable for somebody that would appreciate having a visual versus just having audible feedback.
But does that grandmother already have an iPhone/iphone or another smartphone, and does she now how she can use those devices? Because, if she can and already has one of these devices, she doesn' t need a build in screen.
If she doesn' t have a smartphone and doesn' t now how to use it. I would not bother on getting her a Siri speaker...