Well said. It didn’t work.
But, I think it was made to bilk people out of money more than anything else.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
MKBHD Shutting Down Controversial 'Panels' Wallpaper App
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Well said. It didn’t work.
But, I think it was made to bilk people out of money more than anything else.
never make a hobby a career
He lost me when he did a video about him being black. Unsubscribed instantly.
Mom's basement dweller or failed tech entrepreneur?
Definitely a misfire, and I feel like that should've been obvious from the initial negative reaction to it. It was released in a tone-deaf manner, and I'm not surprised it didn't take off.
I actually do still like MKBHD (especially when he stuck to his guns re. his negative review of that dumb AI pin), but like all YouTubers who've found success, the quest for monetization never ends, and it leads to flops like this one. Not the first time I've seen a YouTuber try and create a subscription service that didn't take off. Everyone wants that monthly bag, you have to give people a good reason to give it to you. Marques clearly didn't.
I actually do still like MKBHD (especially when he stuck to his guns re. his negative review of that dumb AI pin), but like all YouTubers who've found success, the quest for monetization never ends, and it leads to flops like this one. Not the first time I've seen a YouTuber try and create a subscription service that didn't take off. Everyone wants that monthly bag, you have to give people a good reason to give it to you. Marques clearly didn't.
This dude is so out of touch now, it's really not worth watching his "content" even if it looks nice and flashy, there's nothing of substance there anymore, just clicks and views as it ever was.
A good example of Tall Poppy syndrome
In my country (NZ), we’ve almost perfected the art of Tall Poppy syndrome, to the point where some people don’t even put their head up above the parapet just to avoid the ensuing onslaught.
A 12 usd/month subscription to download wallpapers? Why?? That's half the price I pay for gigabit fiber internet access. If you have that much disposable money, might as well give it to a homeless person, but please don't spend it on virtual decorations that have zero real world value. I think the very existence of such a service is ridiculous.
Probably makes more coin than the poster you quoted. /s
His production value is top-tier, but the actual content feels safe to the point of being bland. I'm watching a review to understand what someone thinks, not just what a product is or does. When every take is carefully hedged and every opinion is middle-of-the-road, it starts feeling more like polished marketing material than genuine critique. I want reviewers who'll actually have, vocalize and explain an opinion, even if I disagree with it.
NVM the cesspool Youtube reviewer ecosystem, I don't even trust it for silly cat videos anymore. Seems like everything is AI slop w/ the same fake voice and same emotive soft music and even the video itself can't be trusted.
The "vision" was to harvest your data and monetize it. Pretty disappointing from someone who should know better.
His mannerisms likely help hide most of the frustration he might have. Most youtubers are a bit over the top.
I just got an iPad Air M3, and trying to figure out what sort of case I wanted for the thing.. Something just to cover the screen, the edges? The keyboard? There's so much junk reviewers out there, with maybe one out of Vancouver getting in to the nitty gritty of what makes some cases work best over others... but boy... how many videos do I need to watch these days where I need to skip 90 seconds ahead to get through a plug?
But, I was drawn to Marques' video about use of the iPad to replace a laptop... Could you make use of that very, very expensive keyboard, and highlight some of the features of iPadOS 26, and whether it truly went far enough to replace a laptop, and why it fails or succeeds for him in certain situations, and that ultimately being the crux. What do you do day to day, and can you live within that box? He makes points to consider because no device does everything.
I have never subscribed to his content, and likely missed a bunch, but I've seen him clearly criticize in the past. The ludicrousness of the Apple Mouse charge port from TEN years ago when no other mouse manufacturer does it, the Mac Pro trashcan being sold for $3600 while also being able to be traded in for... nothing... Apple would recycle for you. I think it was the lightning port on the Airpod Max when there was a clear shift to USB-C. I think he's taken stabs at the refresh rates on most Apple iPhones until this year.
Yeah, I have no interest in MKBHD at all. He's always rubbed me up the wrong way - not at all what he seems.
BUT I do subscribe to The Studio channel, there's a great team of people behind the scenes. I also watch the podcast, but the best ones are when Marques isn't there and the other guys can just relax and have fun with it - those episodes are the best.
I mean he is young. And it's OK to make mistakes. The only ones who never make a mistake are those who never do anything.