Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Yeah, Arraez has been very good. Even been playing solid defense. Mea culpa, then.

At least I was right about Casey Schmitt.

Very interesting that Buster Posey traded away Patrick Bailey. They could not afford to carry his .396 OPS bat anymore, and they have a couple of stronger hitting catchers on the roster in Susac and Rodriguez (clutch game-winning hit yesterday!). I want to see more accountability for underperformance.

To be fair, you know what they say about hindsight…

and the people whose actual day job it is to make these decisions probably didn't see it coming either, having signed him for only a one-year deal.

By contrast, the Devers contract is already looking like an albatross.

There have been rumblings that Posey had some discontent about Bailey's defensive game, which made it easier given his lack of offense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
To be fair, you know what they say about hindsight…

By contrast, the Devers contract is already looking like an albatross.

There have been rumblings that Posey had some discontent about Bailey's defensive game,
which made it easier given his lack of offense.
I've said it before and I'll say it again: I do not like this dude. He strikes me as a clubhouse cancer type. People forget that he wouldn't play in the field for BOS at all, that's how we got him. Then he gradually agreed to 1B with us. I'd like to see Eldridge play 1B and pouty pants DH or play 3rd and let Chappy (who also seems to suddenly be incredibly bat shy) DH.

His defense was the only bright spot this season, and last. He's a very good catcher.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheIntruder
I've said it before and I'll say it again: I do not like this dude. He strikes me as a clubhouse cancer type. People forget that he wouldn't play in the field for BOS at all, that's how we got him. Then he gradually agreed to 1B with us. I'd like to see Eldridge play 1B and pouty pants DH or play 3rd and let Chappy (who also seems to suddenly be incredibly bat shy) DH.

If Devers, Chapman, and Adames are supposed to be the "NuCore" of this team, it's gonna be even more of a slog. They'd have to go on a hot streak to even flirt with the mediocrity of the past few squads.

His defense was the only bright spot this season, and last. He's a very good catcher.

He's good, but when you don't play defense in a way that your boss, a former catcher himself, likes…
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
So when did a combined no-no become such a major event.

I saw a clip that the Astros had a no-no, only to find out it, they did it with 3 pitchers.

No shade being thrown to Tatsuya Imai for pitching 6 solid innings without a hit. The second pitcher only covered the 7th inning, and so not having a hit there doesn't seem too terribly impressive, and then Alimber Santa had 2 no hit innings which is pretty good I suppose, but he celebrated like he just went 9 innings.

I just don't remember this being a major fete growing up.
 
Last edited:
So when did a combined no-no become such a major event.

I saw a clip that the Astros had a no-no, only to find out it, they did it with 3 pitchers.

No shade being thrown to Tatsuya Imai for pitching 6 solid innings without a hit. The second pitcher only covered the 7th inning, and so not having a hit there doesn't seem too terribly impressive, and then Alimber Santa had 2 no hit innings which is pretty good I suppose, but he celebrated like he just went 9 innings.

I just don't remember this being a major fete growing up.

Nor I...

I find it a bit absurd to say the least.
 
  • Like
Reactions: maflynn
Combined no-hitters were almost unheard of decades ago.

I'd say any no-hitter is an accomplishment worth celebrating, but the guy who gets the last out shouldn't celebrate quite as much as a pitcher who just finished a complete game no-no on his own.
 
My memory is fuzzy, but I don't believe that in the past, each step in the postseason ladder was followed by a champagne celebration like they've just won the WS, was it?

But that's sports nowadays. It's worse in football, where simply making a play is cause for celebration.
 
My memory is fuzzy, but I don't believe that in the past, each step in the postseason ladder was followed by a champagne celebration like they've just won the WS, was it?

But that's sports nowadays. It's worse in football, where simply making a play is cause for celebration.
Yeah. smh.

Drives me nuts... get back to the huddle it's just one play dude.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rhett7660
I'm glad to see the Cubs alone in first place! I hope it lasts for more than one day! The NL Central is so tight, and although it's early, I expect that to continue for at least 3 teams right down to the wire. It should be an exciting race.
Had to revisit this post 24 days later. After two 10-win streaks, they have now lost 10 in a row. Cubs are now tied for last. Of course, as you noted the NL Central is tight - 4.5 games top to bottom. The entire NL Central would fit between first and second place in the NL East!

[Sigh] I hate early season baseball. Go Cubs Go.
 
Had to revisit this post 24 days later. After two 10-win streaks, they have now lost 10 in a row. Cubs are now tied for last. Of course, as you noted the NL Central is tight - 4.5 games top to bottom. The entire NL Central would fit between first and second place in the NL East!

[Sigh] I hate early season baseball. Go Cubs Go.

I'm surprised the Pirates are still above water!
 
My memory is fuzzy, but I don't believe that in the past, each step in the postseason ladder was followed by a champagne celebration like they've just won the WS, was it?

There are more levels of season/postseason now. Back in the day, you'd have a champagne shower for winning your division, your League Championship Series, and the World Series. Now, you can get one for winning your division and/or Wildcard series, the Division Series, the LCS, and the World Series. So if you won your division, but your record wasn't as good as your league's other two division winners, you'd still have to play in a Wildcard series. If you won the World Series that year, you'd get five champagne baths!
 
Andrew McCutchen was DFA'd Not surprised, his productivity hasn't been stellar this year. What is surprising is how long he's been in the league. There's been a few times, where I thought he's done and will be retiring.

I've always liked him - seems to be a good guy AFAIK
 
Giants need a rebuild.

They have been needing a rebuild for years, but ownership and management have been in denial for a long time about the lack of quality and competitiveness on their major league roster. Meanwhile, they took on some boat anchor contracts in Adames, Chapman, Lee, and Devers that will be difficult if not impossible to trade away.

Trade Arraez and Robbie Ray for whatever you can get. Prioritize playing and developing the kids. Be patient enough to wait out a couple of dismal years at the major league level — all the minor league teams are playing very well and interesting prospects abound. Building around homegrown talent is the only way to win in SF. Commit to it. Now.
 
Will the Mets fire Mendoza and the rest of the coaching staff during the season? I guess he's in his final year of his contract, but its inexcusable to have the 2nd highest payroll and 3rd most losses in the NL
1779977508745.png
 
Will the Mets fire Mendoza and the rest of the coaching staff during the season? I guess he's in his final year of his contract, but its inexcusable to have the 2nd highest payroll and 3rd most losses in the NL
View attachment 2633276

Well, as a Braves fan the Mets can keep Mendoza and the rest for the entire season 🙂

If they can somehow get on a winning streak or two before mid season the standings will tighten up like the other divisions, and the doubters can breathe a bit easier? Team owner may lose patience before then, though.
 
Last edited:
Whelp, we knew it was coming. MLB proposed a salary cap, and I'm sure the player's assoc. will resoundingly reject it. But nearly every other sport having one, its going to be hard for the players to not look greedy I don't expect the players to capitulate on this, and I do expect a lock out/strike next year, so this is just the first move in a very long and slow dance.
 
Andrew McCutchen was DFA'd Not surprised, his productivity hasn't been stellar this year. What is surprising is how long he's been in the league. There's been a few times, where I thought he's done and will be retiring.

I've always liked him - seems to be a good guy AFAIK
He's one of my faves!
 
  • Like
Reactions: TechRunner
Giants need a rebuild.

They have been needing a rebuild for years, but ownership and management have been in denial for a long time about the lack of quality and competitiveness on their major league roster. Meanwhile, they took on some boat anchor contracts in Adames, Chapman, Lee, and Devers that will be difficult if not impossible to trade away.

Trade Arraez and Robbie Ray for whatever you can get. Prioritize playing and developing the kids. Be patient enough to wait out a couple of dismal years at the major league level — all the minor league teams are playing very well and interesting prospects abound. Building around homegrown talent is the only way to win in SF. Commit to it. Now.
I really want to keep Arraez though...
 
Andrew McCutchen was DFA'd Not surprised, his productivity hasn't been stellar this year. What is surprising is how long he's been in the league. There's been a few times, where I thought he's done and will be retiring.

I've always liked him - seems to be a good guy AFAIK

I like him a lot and he does seem like he is one of the good guys of baseball.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
Giants need a rebuild.

They have been needing a rebuild for years, but ownership and management have been in denial for a long time about the lack of quality and competitiveness on their major league roster. Meanwhile, they took on some boat anchor contracts in Adames, Chapman, Lee, and Devers that will be difficult if not impossible to trade away.

Trade Arraez and Robbie Ray for whatever you can get. Prioritize playing and developing the kids. Be patient enough to wait out a couple of dismal years at the major league level — all the minor league teams are playing very well and interesting prospects abound. Building around homegrown talent is the only way to win in SF. Commit to it. Now.

They came close once, in 2002, but one would think that the years of futility of trying to build a champion around Bonds, and other free agents would not be forgotten. Nor would the lessons of the home grown approach that did yield success in the early 2010s.

But the current regime's strategy, in so far as they have a business (if not baseball) strategy at least, is to field a team that's good enough, and draws enough to keep the business profitable. No sense of baseball enthusiasm from the ownership.

On the field, the Vitello experiment has yet to mature, and probably not fair to judge given the team he's inherited, but calling up your #1 prospect, and having him ride the bench half the time is not helping his development.

Blowing it up would result in some pain, but at least those losses might yield some positive results later. Something the current team can't, and probably won't offer.

Posey was part of such a youth movement himself, and I don't think it's lost on him. Which then makes you turn your glance back toward ownership again.


The team owners were once willing to sacrifice a season. To get a cap, I'd bet they're willing to do it again, but it's early, and we'll see what happens.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
Maybe its the youtube algorithm, or the sports YT channels I watch, but there seems to be a higher preponderance of players getting ejected for stupid reasons. I wonder if the umps are a bit more frustrated with the players now able to challenge balls/strikes, but overall they seem a bit more on edge. Again, it may be just the videos that are hitting my feed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachyderm
They came close once, in 2002, but one would think that the years of futility of trying to build a champion around Bonds, and other free agents would not be forgotten. Nor would the lessons of the home grown approach that did yield success in the early 2010s.

But the current regime's strategy, in so far as they have a business (if not baseball) strategy at least, is to field a team that's good enough, and draws enough to keep the business profitable. No sense of baseball enthusiasm from the ownership.

On the field, the Vitello experiment has yet to mature, and probably not fair to judge given the team he's inherited, but calling up your #1 prospect, and having him ride the bench half the time is not helping his development.

Blowing it up would result in some pain, but at least those losses might yield some positive results later. Something the current team can't, and probably won't offer.

Posey was part of such a youth movement himself, and I don't think it's lost on him. Which then makes you turn your glance back toward ownership again.


The team owners were once willing to sacrifice a season. To get a cap, I'd bet they're willing to do it again, but it's early, and we'll see what happens.
They definitely need to let Eldridge get at bats. I'd like to see him in the field as well.

I really want Devers out. Won't happen, but it's what I want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheIntruder
Maybe its the youtube algorithm, or the sports YT channels I watch, but there seems to be a higher preponderance of players getting ejected for stupid reasons. I wonder if the umps are a bit more frustrated with the players now able to challenge balls/strikes, but overall they seem a bit more on edge. Again, it may be just the videos that are hitting my feed.

I could see them getting a little miffed by the ABS ... and then getting revenge... lol
 
Bloody hell, what a comeback for the Giants. Down 9-1 to the Nationals in the 8th inning, I was having dark, dark thoughts about Posey and Vitello's future employment. However, they scored 5 runs in the 8th and 5 in the 9th, capped off by a walkoff grand salami by Bryce Eldridge.
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: pachyderm
Bloody hell, what a comeback for the Giants. Down 9-1 to the Nationals in the 8th inning, I was having dark, dark thoughts about Posey and Vitello's future employment. However, they scored 5 runs in the 8th and 5 in the 9th, capped off by a walkoff grand salami by Bryce Eldridge.
I still have dark thoughts abut Posey and Vitello's employment, but I couldn't believe that just happened. Eldridge is a special player.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.