agree somewhat
I don't see how iMovie or iDVD are usable even on a consumer level. They're dumbed down for the lowest common denominator. Combining them would be ideal, but why not focus on giving iMovie/iDVD more features, specifically in the editing arena? I feel like I'm using the trial version of some imaginary official app.
I am not a fan of the current iMovie as stated, I think the leap they made from the previous version made things confusing from previous users (I know many who agree). Imovie is great for people not wanting to jump into FC or even FC Express, I know lots of people who just want to get their video on a DVD and make it simple. They don't have the time to do what we do.
As a pro user I like to have all options available. I think iDVD is great for a simple menus, leaving out the work on DVD Studio (which of course is way bette, just not as time friendly). iMovie is great for family DVD's, simple to the point. I prefer using FC to edit and just find a nice temp to use with it, add in the music and pics myself and a okay menu is on screen. i have never used it for real pro use.
I can see why they would combine them both, common sense, for the non pro user. Just let me download the soon to be gone iDVD, or be able to keep it, an option would be great.
iMovie/iDVD will make it easier for their users in the long run. I do think iMovie blows away whatever comes on a your common windows machine and certainly needs an update. No matter what I will find a way to make it all work.
There is no real reason to get rid of iDVD, just keep it as is and take it out of the dock, keep in Application folder, and let the new iMovie run wild, problem solved.
No need to knock iMovie it helps a lot of people out there who do not take video work as serious as we do. For instance I love Garageband and I am a musician, there is a tool for everything if you can find a way to make it work for you.
As for iWEB, I really hope they update iWeb to make it more functional on Windows based computers. I am not a web designer and love iWeb. I always wanted to learn more about web design, but I have enough to bog me down, so keep iWeb easy to use, pro looks, and slick. I thought the last update would be better but sadly I was not that impressed.