Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Come on dude seriously? First of all that dude is a total weasel and is obviously disrespecting you and has no regard for the fact that she has a boyfriend.... second of all I am inclined to think that she slept with him if she gave in and went to the hotel at that time. Really he so easily convinced her that they were better off in the hotel room cause it has a couch and chairs.. Come on!

I've rationalized that by her naivety

Oh yes, he's told her that he has a "girlfriend" so she uses that in her argument lol "But he has a girlfriend!" I don't understand how she doesn't realize that doesn't matter to some people?...
 
I predict....when she dumps you, she'll say it's because you're too controlling and don't trust her
 
Well I mean come on, I'm gonna give her the benefit of the doubt. I'm convinced that nothing happened. But anyone hearing about the situation of course would assume something did. I know her and I trust her but I just don't see how it makes sense to see him when her friendship with him means almost nothing. Especially at the risk of upsetting me. So of course there are some puzzling questions there but I don't think you can say that since the hockey game ended before 12, somtehing happened. I just think that its stupid he would invite her over to watch the game and she goes when its essentially over. She did come back from a 4 month trip so of course there are things to talk about but seriously, for 2 hours? Ugh.. a phone call would have sufficed...

I have to treat this situation carefully. If I go too lightly, as some one said that makes her feel like she can do anything she wants and step on me. If I go too harsh, she is like "f this" and gets upset and turns it on me somehow when I'm 100% in right as far as I see it. And since she came back and has said nothing happened and I believe it, it makes it harder show her that this was clearly an issue regardless of what happened.

There is ZERO reason for a woman of any age to hang out with a guy of any age she used to work with who used to hit on her, in a private setting like a hotel room. If it was a bunch of people getting together I'd be more willing to believe she isn't banging this dude. Why would she want to catch up with some guy who was "upset" he didn't get to throw it in her? She doesn't work with him anymore, they have no professional relationship.

If she wasn't up to no good, she would have brought you with her. I know you want to believe she isn't ********ting you, and as would I if I were in your situation, but based on what you've said, she is playing you.

Give me one good reason why she needs to hang out with this guy. A legit one. If you're in a committed relationship with someone, there is no reason to go hang out in someone else's hotel room. If they really wanted to go catch up, they'd do it out somewhere in public. When you want to bang without getting caught, you go to a hotel.
 
She asked if I wanted to come to the hotel room with her. I said no, there's no reason I have to be there while you catch up with your "friend" just go to some public place like a bar or coffee shop or something.

Seems like she was more concerned about upsetting him than me lol which is awful.. but deep down I don't think she meant it that way. She's just blind...
 
I predict....when she dumps you, she'll say it's because you're too controlling and don't trust her

That's her problem then. Not mine. If I have done nothing wrong and she ends it because she's that retarded then that's on her and I wouldn't want to be with someone who thinks how I'm acting is controlling and untrusting
 
I think we need pictures of said girlfriend to really be sure or not what happened here.
 
How long before this thread has the OP replying saying girlfriend admits to cheating?
 
Go get a hotel room and get some girls up in there. Tell your girl they are just coming over to watch a hockey game.
 
Hotel, Man and woman and a little alcohol.
Fire-Triangle-Diagram.jpg
]

Sorry but I would never knowingly say that was ok.

First of all if she valued and respected you she never would have put herself in such a situation, one on one.
I don't buy any argument that she called you out of trust and respect.
She called to let you know she is looking at an option.

its good that you came to ask but I think your gut knows the true/right answer.
 
I'm on the fence simply because of her hypocriticalness. She says she would be upset if the same situation happened with you with a woman, but still does it anyway?

I would be uncomfortable in that situation as well I would admit. But I would know if she didn't have cheating intentions( of course only way of knowing this is if you trust her not to cheat), that if anything inappropriate happened she would slap him out the window and leave. It sounds like you do as well as you stated, you trust her, not him. Being reluctant to leave the hotel to go somewhere better suited is a definite red flag on his intentions.

I understand you being uncomfortable and definitely voice it to her( not in an argumentative tone or intention), but you can't control her and the moment you do is when you're in the wrong.
 
That's her problem then. Not mine. If I have done nothing wrong and she ends it because she's that retarded then that's on her and I wouldn't want to be with someone who thinks how I'm acting is controlling and untrusting

Trust me there is a woman out there that will value you and your trust and not text you from a hotel asking if she can spend a night with another man.
 
1 word:
cuckold

2 words:
not really

In plain English, cuckold husbands are men who stand by and accept wife's infidelity, being sexually excited by her actions. They may have normal sexual relations with their wife part of the time, or they may accept that the wife has chosen another man to replace them completely in her sexual bed.
 
insisting to meet in his room means he had an agenda and she being ok with that means most likely something you don't approve of occurred

Face the reality of the situation, she cheated on you
 
insisting to meet in his room means he had an agenda and she being ok with that means most likely something you don't approve of occurred

Face the reality of the situation, she cheated on you

Exactly.

Then she told you part of the story to make her be able to live with it to trick her mind in to thinking she fessed up and you can now forgive her.
 
What was the hockey game score? She should have known the answer if she was watching it. Or maybe the TV was less important than other activities.....
I wouldn't go to meet my friend in a hotel room, nooooo waaaaay dude, just no freaking way.
Two adults in a hotel room, having a Bud, yea right.

The most important question is: she's not his friend, she was offended by him(or that's what she says and the plot started there already) so why the hell is she meeting him? Go one shoot me but really I don't know. What's to catch up here? Him molesting her? Ohhhhhh where catching this up, I forgot.
 
1 word:
cuckold

Actually I think "beta" is more appropriate.

renewed said:
Then she told you part of the story to make her be able to live with it to trick her mind in to thinking she fessed up and you can now forgive her.

Women as a general rule can (and will) rationalize just about anything.

To the OP: it's a lot easier to start over at 22 than 32 or 42. Learn from this.
 
One more thing to consider here though... although I still stand with my last posts.

If she was going to cheat on you with that guy why would she even need to tell you shes going to the hotel room?

She could have just lied and said she was at a cafe or bar or something but then went to the hotel room anyway....


She its a tricky one.. but she still went against your feelings
 
The most important question is: she's not his friend, she was offended by him(or that's what she says and the plot started there already) so why the hell is she meeting him? Go one shoot me but really I don't know. What's to catch up here? Him molesting her? Ohhhhhh where catching this up, I forgot.

She said he offended her so the OP wouldn't question whether or not she would do anything with him. It was to ease him. If she would of said he was a really good guy and super funny then the OP would have no question.

She has you where she wants you OP... questioning your gut.
 
She said he offended her so the OP wouldn't question whether or not she would do anything with him. It was to ease him. If she would of said he was a really good guy and super funny then the OP would have no question.

She has you where she wants you OP... questioning your gut.

lol i was like "he's 30? really?"

"ya but he's so immature i dont think of him as that old" uh.... lol isnt that even worse? yes.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.