I'm not a big fan of cases, but the other day when I was in the Apple store I decided to go ahead and get the black Apple case. Found a seating area out in the mall and fitted it on to my iPhone 5. Felt very snug and secure and it certainly felt nice in the hand. I didn't care for how it covers the on/off button, though, and I also was a little concerned about lint building up when I have the phone in-and-out of my pockets. Wandered on down to the AT&T store and found that they had the 64 GB Space Grey iPhone, so traded in my 32 GB iPhone 5 for it. While waiting for the salesman to do something with paperwork, I tried to get the black Apple case off my iPhone 5. No luck! Finally had to have the salesman do it, and he had to use something to gently pry one edge up first. At home I keep my iPhone naked, and so when the salesman asked about putting the case on the new phone, I said no, because I had just decided that it was too much of a hassle and wouldn't work well with my lifestyle and the way I use my iPhone. After finishing up at AT&T I went back to the Apple store and returned the case. No point in spending $40 on something I wasn't totally happy about.
Now I've ordered a Sena UltraSlim Classic in orange. That should suit my needs much better. In the meantime I'll keep using the old Fortte case I had for my first-gen iPhone.