Maybe it only appears to work fine because your iPhone is regularly inside the car as well?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
New York Police Department Encourages Car Owners to Use AirTags to Deter Theft, 500 Free AirTags Available
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You make a very good point. The vast majority of car crime here is done by boosting the key fob signal from inside the house to someone standing next to the car or blocking the signal in a car park when someone tries to lock the car. Then, with a cheap device they get into the diagnostic port where they can disable the alarm and tracking and start the car. Considering the price of even a cheap car and the hassle, an air tag is cheap insurance.
Interestingly, today… Nick Kyrgios (tennis player) had his Tesla stolen after it was carjacked while his mother was driving it. Nick immediately remotely slowed it to a max of 80 kph, tracked it and the police stopped it. That’s how this works at its best. In the meantime, we use an AirTag to track it, if we can’t afford a Tesla.
First thought: Good idea, innovation. Someone is using their head
Second thought: 500 for free? That will last all 10 minutes and involve low level corruption in the distribution of them
Third thought: Do you really think NYPD is going to run in and get your car back or that this will make a difference? By the time they get around to it, you insurance company will have canceled your policy and your car model will have been discontinued.
Second thought: 500 for free? That will last all 10 minutes and involve low level corruption in the distribution of them
Third thought: Do you really think NYPD is going to run in and get your car back or that this will make a difference? By the time they get around to it, you insurance company will have canceled your policy and your car model will have been discontinued.
Apple needs to add a feature to share just your Find My tracking of a specific device with law enforcement. At the moment police ask for your iCloud username and password to track devices which is handing over way too much data to anyone IMO
I don't think "working" for a law firm is very relevant. It was a civil matter. You should have hired one of the lawyers where you worked. I guess, just as the cops were not interested in making it a criminal matter, they didn't thinks either.
I have was born there, grew up in the suburbs, went to college there and worked there for many years. NYC's problems are no different that any other densely populated city. Crime, homelessness, overworked police and fireman and priorities than don't always sync with a particular citizens priorities. Never had any of the problems you mention or any of the issues you seem to raise
I never parked my illegally and I never didn't have didn't have a valid registration sticker for my vehicle. I was well aware of the consequences of doing those things and decided I did not want to experience them. Don't have one? Such a person deserves to be stopped and ticketed. Such a person is subject to the same laws the rest of us are even enforcement isn't consistent. Such people should take responsibility for their own actions.
Contrary to what you said, if NYPD tells you to do something, 9.9 times out of 10 you would be well advised to do exactly what they told you to do.
My phone and I are currently 7000 miles from where my car is and I have not had any problems tracking to the car and know where it is at all times.
And no one else with an Apple device is using the car? I’m not doubting it works, but I think to really test it one would have to have someone drive the car around who doesn’t carry an Apple device.
It works fine for me. I've had an Airtag hidden in my car for two years now (installed days after the Airtags were put on sale back in 2021), and I'm always able to see where my car is. Had to change the battery once so far in that two years.
On occasions when it's been in for regular servicing, or when I've brought it to have paint corrected/detailed, I find it useful to be able to confirm that my car is always where it should be; at the dealership or service centre, and not being taken for a joyride somewhere.
It obviously needs to have other iOS devices, etc. closeby for it to work effectively, but that's never been a problem for me. Whenever I've checked on my phone, I can see where my car is. And the "last seen" time is generally 2 mins or less...
Having an airTag is the car is very useful, mostly if your travel and may forget where exactly you left the car on this big multi-storey parking lot.
And as a side story, I had my son using my car to travel in France, and I was able to track the car during his whole trip. A very efficient solution with minimal incremental cost to me (this initial device price plus one CR2032 every 6 months).
BTW, the airTag is not really hidden, it is just dropped in a door storage pocket.
And as a side story, I had my son using my car to travel in France, and I was able to track the car during his whole trip. A very efficient solution with minimal incremental cost to me (this initial device price plus one CR2032 every 6 months).
BTW, the airTag is not really hidden, it is just dropped in a door storage pocket.
Why does anyone still live in NYC? As a someone who has for the last 42 years, I can mention the art, culture, music, Central Park, great food, etc. etc. ... but when it comes to safety -- NYC is the safest city in terms of violent crime, per capita in the United States. Look it up: here is one list for you, NYC isn't even in the top 75 --https://www.populationu.com/gen/most-dangerous-cities-in-the-us
Yes, NYC was dangerous, in the 1980s... things have slightly changed since then. So far as cars are concerned, maybe car manufacturers can start emulating Tesla? Century mode, ability to trace your car via your remote iPhone app, or otherwise help nature the thief. See for instance: https://www.drive.com.au/news/tesla-owner-lock-thief-inside-car/
A car theft is highly unlikely to get anywhere.
Not even needed. Any person carrying an iPhone passing near to your car will locate it. That's where the airTag is more convenient than many other more complex solutions.
The question discussed was that cars act as Faraday cages to some extent, so depending on where you place the AirTag within the car, the NFC may become more limited. I was pointing out that testing this would require driving the car without an Apple mobile device inside.
The only person driving it is doing it once a week for 15 minutes to keep the fluids and battery healthy while I am on an overseas assignment. No one else is driving it. AirTags do rely on Apple phones/mobile devices to work. Anyone's Apple mobile device will do the trick. It does not have to be your own phone. In most parts of the world, that's pretty easy.
Seen as how long it takes for your iPhone to say « item no longer detected » the car would have crossed five states before you’re notified…
Apple, Google partner on an industry specification to address unwanted tracking
Today Apple and Google jointly submitted a proposed industry specification to help address the misuse of Bluetooth location-tracking devices.
www.apple.com
Some areas are more vulnerable than others. What state do you live, what car do you have and what reg and what specific place did you choose to hide the AirTag? This information will be useful for helping others learn safe practices. 🛑
Everybody can have their own opinion. You are free to not use them for whatever purpose you don't want to use them for.
Their budget is only about 10.9 Billion so probably cant afford it. 🥲
Interesting idea, but did you make a calculation what will be the cost of it? What will you pay for prisons, guards, food, medic-care, heating, cooling etc. etc.?
And if you did, take a look at the the defence budget; any chance the minister of defence will get jealous at the department of correction?