NFC South batting practice: Brees or Ryan?
Ryan has had a great 3 years, better than the first 3 years for any QB for wins
And I think he is a very good QB who could become a great QB
But what Brees has done in SD and NO is amazing, and he has a ring
Let Ryan win out this year and get a ring, and then we can have this discussion
Until then, I am not willing to say that Ryan is the best QB in the NFC South
Thanks for the link. I think Ryan is already a great QB. He's not just a one season fluke. But of course it's way to early to say he will be in the next class of dominating QBs over the next several years to come. I think he will, but so much could happen.
The ones I think who will take the mantle that once belonged to the Warners-Bradys-Mannings in the 2000s, can be Sanchez-Rodgers-Romo-Rivers-Ryan-Vick-Brees with maybe three of that group coming out on top from 2011 onwards and stay on top through 2016 or so. That being said, Manning or Brady can sneak in there after 2011 and get a ring. I also don't count out Flacco or Big Ben, either.
This is what makes football so fun.
Where in baseball, somebody who is really great in a long 162 game season could be relied on most of the time to deliver pretty well the next year. Age catches up with players but its more gradual as in the case of Randy Johnson or Barry Bonds, but in football, the physical skills could decline in one season never to come back. Warner was way on top at one time and looked to be the next Dan Marino, but there was a marked decline and inconsistency once he marched through his 30s. It's possible that we could be seeing an inconsistent streak due to age in Peyton Manning.
Anyway, the aging thing opens up the field for new talent for QBs and other more high profile positions. When an important figure on the offensive or defensive line gets old and replaced, it usually doesn't make big news even though the impact could be just as huge.
I thought the Pats were done when some of their key defense players left, but the Pats could rebuild with a Brady or not and still remain a tough team. It's fun to see the Pats, even with their lowly ranked defense catch fire and become like the Pats D of old. They seem to be headed there very quickly (a evidenced by the last quarter against Green Bay, and they can be the perfect counter to the Atlanta Falcons.
If the Jets go against the Falcons, my gut says that Atlanta will be all over them, but the Jets beat the Steelers in a fashion I didn't think they would and they could come out of nowhere. The Ravens who are under the radar can still take their division, but if not that, have the widespread talent to take Atlanta on in the Super Bowl.
When it's a KC or Raiders that get to the SB, then if it's against Atlanta, I wouldn't think they could beat Atlanta. But the 10-6 Giants beat the 16-0 Patriots in the SB.
The press and talk radio are so into Atlanta, both because of their record, and also because they are new to the top of the NFC leaderboard. I am on the other coast and when I turn on sports, you would swear you were in Georgia.
