Why did they bother with Windows Phone to begin with?
so you decided not to read the article before commenting, I'm guessing?
Why did they bother with Windows Phone to begin with?
They should have gone with Android. It's such a no brainer. Lots of quality, affordable sets and even rugged options like the Galaxy active series. Windows phone never had a future. They were too late to the party and by then both iOS and Android were the only real game in town. They should have invested in surveillance software on Linux/Android instead but Windows still has a stranglehold in enterprise. It's also the OS that most people are comfortable using since it never required buying proprietary hardware to run it.
One person made this decision and screwed up the review process. She should have known better as the so called "tech expert" of the NYPD that a phone platform with a horrible market share compared to Android and iOS would eventually go defunct.
They would have the iPhone 6, which still supports the latest OS. Microsoft abandoned their hardware. Apple didn't. That's why they're in this situation.So if they bought iPhones back in 2014 when they bought the windows phones, they wouldn't be replacing them right now?
Somebody needs to notify Tim Cook, 3 years is too soon to replace iPhones. His reliance on a 2 year update cycle is a disaster and Apple is Doomed.
The article specifically mentioned the Windows phones were cheaper. Did you even read it?
Hence, if you go the cheap route, you'll pay more in the long run.
why would they do this?so lets say they switch to iPhones... does that mean they will upgrade the entire force every year to the next newer model up or do they keep them for a few years first?
which is sad, microsoft took the one big potential they had to really grab a choke hold on a huge market, and they floundered it horribly(almost as bad as they did with the mobile phone market).The Xbox business is a rounding error in Microsoft's accounting. Azure is the rising star in their portfolio, but Windows and Office are still very big cash cows.
There is a lot less risk with iOS. Plain and simple that's what it comes down to.
I do consulting for the city (but not NYPD). There are at least three reasons:Why not a more modern BYOD approach?
In my experience, enterprises will give great weight to the strategic recommendations made by Enterprise IT, which is populated, by these so call "computer science" experts.Technicians don't steer enterprises. Executives do. While there are certainly platform zealots in technical roles, executive, C-level employees should definitely be beyond such things.
What an absolute waste of tax payer dollars to have choosen windows phones.
This is the type of clueless leadership that doesn't clearly think through how to future proof their technology requirements and better equip officers with stable and functional tools.
3 years of usage...they would have replaced the phones regardless of what manufacturer they chose.
Yeah, and it was going to be the year of mass switch to Linux for the last 20 years.If Google/Alphabet ever comes out with a desktop version of Android, Windows will be toast.
Not sure exactly what you mean.
How many times has the average person on this forum, myself included, paid for an iPhone? I bought the first gen iPad maxed out with 64 gig of flash and the cellular version; hardly being cheap there. And just a couple of years later it needed to be replaced.
NYPD apparently bought windows phones a few years ago in 2014 paying $160 million for 35,000 units. iPhone would have been in the same ballpark, they hardly took the cheaper way out, it's time to replace them now and they're choosing to buy iPhones. What does this have to do with a cheap person paying twice?
[doublepost=1503965104][/doublepost](Just as an FYI I am a Windows Phone user, but I say this with an unbiased opinion as possible)
Less than a year after completing a rollout of Windows Phones to its entire police force, New York City Police Department officials plan to begin replacing them with iPhones by the end of the year, according to the New York Post.
![]()
Image: NYPD via YouTube
The report didn't specify whether the NYPD will opt to use one of Apple's latest iPhone models, or an older model like the iPhone 6. Apple is also widely rumored to announce the so-called iPhone 8 with an OLED display in September, although the high-end device may be out of the department's price range.
In October 2014, New York City mayor Bill de Blasio and other officials announced plans to roll out 35,000 handheld devices to every NYPD officer for the first time ever, along with tablets for every patrol car. De Blasio said the major $160 million initiative would help bring the department into the 21st century.
The NYPD's smartphones of choice were Nokia's Lumia 830 and Lumia 640 XL, released in October 2014 and March 2015 respectively. The since-discontinued devices run Windows Phone 8.1, which Microsoft ended support for in July to focus on its newer Windows 10 Mobile platform and cloud-based services.
The devices provide police officers with expanded search capabilities, including access to the majority of NYPD databases, and the ability to conduct various record checks from the field in a timelier manner. The devices also provide real-time 911 call data, often prior to radio dispatch, the department said in 2014.
The NYPD's choice of Windows Phones raised some eyebrows given iOS and Android combined have over 99 percent market share of smartphone operating systems, according to research firm IDC.
The department insisted on Microsoft-based smartphones in part because it was already using Microsoft software to run the video-surveillance program at its Lower Manhattan Security Initiative Command Center, according to the New York Post. The devices were also more affordable than iPhones.
A spokesman for the NYPD said the department wouldn't comment on the matter until its Deputy Commissioner of Information Technology Jessica Tisch returned from vacation later today, the report said.
Article Link: NYPD Expected to Replace 35,000+ Windows Phones With iPhones Starting This Year
Not sure exactly what you mean.
How many times has the average person on this forum, myself included, paid for an iPhone? I bought the first gen iPad maxed out with 64 gig of flash and the cellular version; hardly being cheap there. And just a couple of years later it needed to be replaced.
NYPD apparently bought windows phones a few years ago in 2014 paying $160 million for 35,000 units. iPhone would have been in the same ballpark, they hardly took the cheaper way out, it's time to replace them now and they're choosing to buy iPhones. What does this have to do with a cheap person paying twice?
You do realize the lifespan of these devices is only 2-3 years and that include idevices.
You and I may get up to 5 years but normal use and tech improvements mean an organization must upgrade everyone rather than each individual when that time arrives.
Other than the Windows phone being dropped by MS there's nothing new going on here, three+ years of service is normal.
There's no why in heck they'd upgrade the phones every year! Maybe every 3 years or so.
I was thinking maybe for important customers like this Apple would have maintenance and upgrade deals where they swap out the older units to recondition and resale for newer units for some small cost each year to assure everyone is always up to date.
You pay an inexpensive amateur to fix your roof, you'll have a professional back later to do it properly.The article specifically mentioned the Windows phones were cheaper. Did you even read it?
Hence, if you go the cheap route, you'll pay more in the long run.
So first - the 35mill deal wasn't just for the phones. Secndly, Windows phones were built by Nokia so were of a really good standard. Next, Windows phone (and Windows 10 mobile) is a very secure operating systems. All phones have TPM chips etc.,
For a user like the NYPD, they are going to want secure, well built phones that intergrate into their environment. They are probably going to lose / damage quite a lot of them so need a reasonable replacement cycle. Comparing Android with iOS with Windows Phone, it's fairly clear why Windows Phone won.
Some of the 'kids' on here have no idea how an enterprise works. All things considered, I think the Windows Phone was a good choice for NYPD at the time. Time moves on, and as Microsoft are exiting the phone space, NYPD are going to have difficulty getting new hardware so have to look around again.
I personally think supplying iPhones is a waste of taxpayer money but there is now little choice in the market with regards to security. Samsung's VP was recently jailed for bribery. No way could NYPD be associated with that.
Hopefully they get a good deal from Apple - for the taxpayers sake.
Frankly, it doesn't seem worth the cost or the effort that that would require. All a police force will likely need is a secure and reliable communication and internet device. What's the point of swapping out thousands of devices every year to get a faster processor, and bells and whistles like facial recognition, wireless charging, slimmer bezels, or OLED displays? That would be like changing their fleet of squad cars each year just to have the nicest upholsteries.