Merom MBP Will Be An All New Design Not Just A Chip Drop In
Machead III said:
I see no point in delaying a MacBook upgrade. All you need to do is drop in the new chips, prices don't even need to change, it would be completely pointless to let the line fall behind competitors.
1. It's not a drop in situation. It's a total MBP redesign featuring the easy access HD Bay.
2. Supply of Meroms is limited until a few months out.
3. Apple hasn't even received their shipment of them yet.
4. When they do, then they have to build up a launch quantity so they are for sale when announced.
Kjes said:
Mostly because they want to have difference between the Pro line and the others. Thats what I think at least, and I know some others agree.
Nope. It's completely due to
LIMITED SUPPLY of C2D processors for the first few months. There's plenty of differentiation between MB and MBP including speeds.
antistereo said:
The point is that there are still plenty of Yonah MBPs sitting around waiting to be dispatched. Once the backstock will be limited, Apple is going to announce the Meroms and start stocking those.
jaynano said:
Maybe Apple, in anticipation of the Merom release, ordered a smaller supply of Yonahs than they would have otherwise. They probably ordered enough to last them until now. The push back of ship dates and what not may be due to a short in the supply of apple's Yonahs.
Yes. And I'm sure Apple is retarding production as much as possible to minimize that supply of old models in the pipeline so when Meroms arrive they can inject the all new designed models into the assembly lines ASAP.
jaynano said:
If Apple put Merom into MB it would sell like crazy, why wouldn't they? Not only that, but those people who first get the Merom MBs would serve as a great advertisement campaign. So when Intel comes around to dropping the prices of the Merom chips, the MBs will be extremely popular amongst the not so savvy shoppers who don't do their research, and won't know that Santa Rosa is around the corner. Frankly, if apple waits too long to release a Merom MB, they will lose profit in the long run. What is someone who wants a 64 bit laptop supposed to do? I'm not gonna buy a MBP just cause apple is being cheap.
Machead III said:
Agreed. If Apple really want their two laptop lines to fit together, they need to release C2D versions of both at the same time and use speeds and other features, not processor type, to distinguish between Pro and consumer, to keep the lines synced over a longer period of time.
Just think of the crap the introduction of a C2D MB mid way through a Merom MBP cycle would cause. That's confusing enough for the Mac literate, let alone the average member of the public who knows little about core types.
I'd rather they showed their hand all at once so I can decide which is best for me, rather than relying on predictions of time and spec.
This point of view ignores the
LIMITED SUPPLY of Meroms that all manufacturers have to cope with for the first few months of production. MacBooks will get Merom after MBP lines are fully ramped up followed by the iMac lines. Remember iMacs are oldest since they have had their original introduction on January 10. So they deserve to be in the Merom queue before MacBooks.
This is assuming the iMac does not get a Conroe redesign-makeover which is a clear possability. I personally think iMacs are due for a total redesign. It's gotta happen sometime in the next 12 months for sure. It's not like Apple to leave the iMac looking the same for more than a few years. Redesigns encourage more repeat buyers to upgrade.
Moreover, the all new since May 16 MacBooks are not going to get a speed bump - only same speed Meroms which to 99.44% of consumers will mean NOTHING. Only fanatical FREAKS like us who are here right now give a rat's rear about Merom in their MacBooks.
Only the mini will get Merom LAST after MacBooks. Apple has brilliantly-wisely chosen to immediately put same-as they-will-be-when-switched-to-Merom speed/L2 cache Yonahs into the mini now so they can put Meroms into minis once the other three lines have been saturated with Meroms almost invisibly at the same new 1.66GHz dual & 1.83GHz dual 2MB L2 cache spec.