Many thanks for the congratulations and kind words regarding my last post. It almost makes me think that maybe I should take my lens cap off more often.
I like the layering and colors in the winner, but not as well as this one. It has a better balance. The winner seems to be a bit bottom heavy to me.
By the way, your Critique of the Week never got posted even though people liked the idea. Mind if I do that Monday?
Dale
Thanks, Dale. That's funny, if anything, I would associate the
opposite photo with each point you made, but that kind of difference is what makes talking about photos so much fun. I would explain it by noting that detailed areas have visual weight, but areas with bright colors do as well (anything that attracts the eye has visual weight).
Nonetheless, I'm happy to hear that someone prefers the shot with the sun in it. That one is a risky, rule-breaking kind of photo, much more so than "Kindred Spirits." The latter is a very
lucky shot to get, though, which is surely what appealed to the editors who chose it: a concentrated grove of larches in their autumn state set below a sky that momentarily matches them in color, and with the silhouette of a prominent mountain peak echoing their forms--and all of this correspondence cranked up a notch by a sea of fog stretching between these points of interest. In other words: SUPER DUMB LUCK!

Hehe. I honestly didn't even know that grove was there before I drove up to that location that evening. Looking through my set in Lightroom, it's funny to see me take interest in the grove, then abandon it and go somewhere else, only to come running back when the sky turned orange. If only I could be so lucky on every outing...::::sigh::::....
Anyway, I had forgotten about Critique of the Week; yes, by all means, post it up on Monday! Friday through Sunday tends to be pretty slow around here, so a new thread like that might get buried if posted before Monday. I think the thread could be a real winner, and I look forward to participating in it.